Pirelli PZero Nero M+S
#351
Ryan13b: I have a set of these (235-45 17s on dedicated wheels) I use as "winter tires" and certainly have driven with them in an inch of snow. They are much better than the OEM summer tires. However, they are nowhere near as good as true snow tires.
You have to ask yourself what you expect of your winter shoes. For me, I live in northern NJ where we do get a fair amount of frozen precipitation. However, we enjoy a high number of snow plows and a local government happy to salt the hell out of everywhere at the first snowflake. Additionally, I am perfectly capable of working from home on days of obvious inclement weather and my wife drives an AWD SUV so that serves as our vehicle of last resort for truly foul weather. Given my circumstances, the Pirelli's are great and I am very happy with my decision. The tires do an admirable job in light snow and in conjunction with traction control they are a reasonable compromise for me.
As they say, Your Mileage May Vary.
You have to ask yourself what you expect of your winter shoes. For me, I live in northern NJ where we do get a fair amount of frozen precipitation. However, we enjoy a high number of snow plows and a local government happy to salt the hell out of everywhere at the first snowflake. Additionally, I am perfectly capable of working from home on days of obvious inclement weather and my wife drives an AWD SUV so that serves as our vehicle of last resort for truly foul weather. Given my circumstances, the Pirelli's are great and I am very happy with my decision. The tires do an admirable job in light snow and in conjunction with traction control they are a reasonable compromise for me.
As they say, Your Mileage May Vary.
#352
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chesapeake Virginia
Posts: 283
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The tires may help a bit, but they won't help much. I was still slipping and sliding around even though I was going 1-2 mph...scary! Understand that this car does not like any of the slippery stuff.
If you have the $$, the dedicated tires/wheels is the way to go. However, I wouldn't expect the RX to drive like a Jeep through the snow even with the dedicated tires. The car just does not drive well with any level of slippery stuff on the road.
The M&Ss are better than stock tires on dry roads though...no doubt about that.
Slippery roads? Better hang on! Better yet - park the 8 and pull out your kid's car and drive that.
If you have the $$, the dedicated tires/wheels is the way to go. However, I wouldn't expect the RX to drive like a Jeep through the snow even with the dedicated tires. The car just does not drive well with any level of slippery stuff on the road.
The M&Ss are better than stock tires on dry roads though...no doubt about that.
Slippery roads? Better hang on! Better yet - park the 8 and pull out your kid's car and drive that.
#353
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Brooklyn, NY
Posts: 194
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Katchoo
The tires may help a bit, but they won't help much. I was still slipping and sliding around even though I was going 1-2 mph...scary! Understand that this car does not like any of the slippery stuff.
If you have the $$, the dedicated tires/wheels is the way to go. However, I wouldn't expect the RX to drive like a Jeep through the snow even with the dedicated tires. The car just does not drive well with any level of slippery stuff on the road.
The M&Ss are better than stock tires on dry roads though...no doubt about that.
Slippery roads? Better hang on! Better yet - park the 8 and pull out your kid's car and drive that.
If you have the $$, the dedicated tires/wheels is the way to go. However, I wouldn't expect the RX to drive like a Jeep through the snow even with the dedicated tires. The car just does not drive well with any level of slippery stuff on the road.
The M&Ss are better than stock tires on dry roads though...no doubt about that.
Slippery roads? Better hang on! Better yet - park the 8 and pull out your kid's car and drive that.
#354
Originally Posted by Katchoo
The car just does not drive well with any level of slippery stuff on the road.
I take that back, it does have serious problems in deeper, slushy stuff, as the wide tires apparently tend to float or hydroplane. But in dry, and especially packed snow, it's fantastic.
#355
Registered
iTrader: (4)
Originally Posted by crisis
Comments like these confuse me. My old car was a '97 A/T mirage and I drove that car in snow all the time. I drove for 5 years on the factory tires and another 4.5 years on basic dunlop all season tires. I never had an accident and only slid a few times in the ice and snow, this is including the year I lived in Boston. Of course I drove much slower and way more cautiously. When I read comments about how bad the rx8 is I wonder exactly what people mean? Is it this bad because it is rear wheel drive? My 8 is only a week old and I can't decide if I should go with dedicated winter tires, which probably will only see a minimal amount of snow in the DC area or good all season's like the pirellis and for teh 3 or 4 days a year the snow is that bad car pool or just don't go to work?
#356
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Cincinnati
Posts: 376
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Ryan13b
Anybody try these out in more than an inch of snow? I'm torn between a set of these, or full on snow tires for winter.
#357
Registered
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: New York, Northern NYC Burbs
Posts: 601
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Has anyone used or have any input on the handling & ride differences between Nero & Rosso? And yes, I know the Rosso are not all season. I am not corncerned with winter driving.
Thanks
Thanks
#358
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chesapeake Virginia
Posts: 283
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by crisis
Comments like these confuse me. My old car was a '97 A/T mirage and I drove that car in snow all the time. I drove for 5 years on the factory tires and another 4.5 years on basic dunlop all season tires. I never had an accident and only slid a few times in the ice and snow, this is including the year I lived in Boston. Of course I drove much slower and way more cautiously. When I read comments about how bad the rx8 is I wonder exactly what people mean? Is it this bad because it is rear wheel drive? My 8 is only a week old and I can't decide if I should go with dedicated winter tires, which probably will only see a minimal amount of snow in the DC area or good all season's like the pirellis and for teh 3 or 4 days a year the snow is that bad car pool or just don't go to work?
Maybe it is the light wieght or the distribution, don't know. But the bottom line in my view is that you better be REAL careful driving the 8 in the winter. I know mine does not like it at all...maybe yours will. Good luck.
P.S. IF your area has decent snow removal then you might be all right. But remember that it is what is undernieth the snow that matters. You get a slight haze of ice or something....whoosh! I posted elsewhere about one of my experiences going 1-2 MPH and ultimately having to stop because I was sliding all over the place...no gas, just letting off of the brake and away I went. Finally had to stop for 2 hours to let the roads clear up. Other cars were just moving right along without a care in the world...
#359
Originally Posted by Katchoo
I used to live in Connecticut where we got some pretty significiant snow and other nasty stuff. Had rear-wheel drive cars up there (Camero, Chevelle, etc.). Those cars drove much better in that stuff than the RX-8 does in the area where I now live - Virginia.
What kind of tires were on your RX-8 when you had to park it? If you read through the various threads on winter driving, you'll find that the vast majority of people have few problems driving the RX-8 in snowy conditions WHEN they have dedicated snow tires.
#360
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chesapeake Virginia
Posts: 283
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am telling you that I had a '69 Z-28 and an '71 SS 454 Chevelle and they both drove better in the Connecticut winter than the RX-8 does (with either stock or the P Z-nero M&S) does in the slight Virginia winter we get in the Hampton Roads area.
Maybe that is because the Connecticut weather was a decent snow rather than the slight icy slippery stuff we get here in eastern VA. Don't know why that is...but I have had the RX for 2 winters now and both scared the crap out of me...at the slowest speeds.
I do NOT have dedicated snow tires. Never said I did. Just don't expect great things with the M&S tires in all conditions. They are great on dry pavement, they are great in the wet, but I have found them to be lacking in the type of cold stuff we get here. Just my opinion.
I have never driven the car in deep snow...so far only about 2 inches.
If you wanted to have a great car in the snow...guess what? The RX ain't it. Not really dissing the car, but driving in snow up to your door handles or across a frozen lake was not what the car was designed for.
NEWS FLASH: Buy a Hummer if you want to have a total, all-weather transport machine.
Maybe that is because the Connecticut weather was a decent snow rather than the slight icy slippery stuff we get here in eastern VA. Don't know why that is...but I have had the RX for 2 winters now and both scared the crap out of me...at the slowest speeds.
I do NOT have dedicated snow tires. Never said I did. Just don't expect great things with the M&S tires in all conditions. They are great on dry pavement, they are great in the wet, but I have found them to be lacking in the type of cold stuff we get here. Just my opinion.
I have never driven the car in deep snow...so far only about 2 inches.
If you wanted to have a great car in the snow...guess what? The RX ain't it. Not really dissing the car, but driving in snow up to your door handles or across a frozen lake was not what the car was designed for.
NEWS FLASH: Buy a Hummer if you want to have a total, all-weather transport machine.
#361
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chesapeake Virginia
Posts: 283
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by HeelnToe
You're suggesting that high-torque cars with wider tires, inferior handling, and less weight on the drive wheels perform better in deep snow than the RX-8 does in light snow?
What kind of tires were on your RX-8 when you had to park it? If you read through the various threads on winter driving, you'll find that the vast majority of people have few problems driving the RX-8 in snowy conditions WHEN they have dedicated snow tires.
What kind of tires were on your RX-8 when you had to park it? If you read through the various threads on winter driving, you'll find that the vast majority of people have few problems driving the RX-8 in snowy conditions WHEN they have dedicated snow tires.
It may be that the 8 (with the M&S tires) works better in deeper snow than in the light nasty stuff we get here. No clue.
The parking time with the RX-8 was with the PZeros. Took foot off the brake, no gas, rear wheels started to spin at idle and off I went! Zooom! No body else around me seemed to have any problems...long story, you would have had to been then to understand the situation.
IF you have 3-4 months of winter get dedicated tires. If you have 2-3 weeks of it (like we do here) then get the M&S (and hang on) or just park it. Depends on the type of winter you get too.
That Chevelle was fun too...big block, cowl induction, fast! And I did drive that all the time in winter - to and from work. The '69 Z was a pain - too many valves to adjust! LOL
#362
Registered
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Alto, Michigan
Posts: 195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I live in western Michigan (60 - 100 inches per season). If I did drive my 8 in the winter months, I'd go for four snow tires. But, I wouldn't compare the OEM Bridgestone's snow performance to the Pirellis. Katchoo's description of 2 mph slipperyness matches my experiance with the Bridgestones - worthless, stay off the road. The Pirellis are significantly better. Not enough better to depend on them for daily driving!
#363
What benefits would I expect from getting the larger 245/40-18 tires on my stock 18 inch wheels? I called my local service station to make sure that they could actually mount the suckers and the guy said they could, but I would more than likely get some rubbing. From reading this thread I don't think it will be a problem, but I'm just concerned before putting down $600+ for these things that i'll run into trouble. besides, aren't wider tires less desirable in the snow?
#364
Registered
iTrader: (4)
I have them for my car, there is no rubbing. They are a 4 month/year tire for me. I switch to performance tires for the rest of the year.
Wider tires are less desirable in snow. They cut through snow instead of packing it down. But, how much snow do you normally get? Here in Chicago, we get 1 to 2 inch snowfalls and the roads are cleared quickly. I want the wider tires for traction on ice. The more rubber on the road, the more grip there is.
Wider tires are less desirable in snow. They cut through snow instead of packing it down. But, how much snow do you normally get? Here in Chicago, we get 1 to 2 inch snowfalls and the roads are cleared quickly. I want the wider tires for traction on ice. The more rubber on the road, the more grip there is.
#365
hmm, decisions decisions then. Do I want the wider tires which aren't as good in snow but better on icy roads, or the stock size which is better in snow but not as good on icy roads? I'm also worried that the dealership will have "issues" installing the larger ones and blame it on me for getting tires that are not stock size. were you given a hard time with the install?
#366
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chesapeake Virginia
Posts: 283
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have the larger tires on my car. No problems with fit or with the dealer.
The car just isn't a good winter condition car...wasn't designed to be. Just understand that and drive accordingly.
The car just isn't a good winter condition car...wasn't designed to be. Just understand that and drive accordingly.
#367
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chesapeake Virginia
Posts: 283
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
BTW...no rubbing with the larger tires. They fit fine. Handle great in dry conditions...much better than stock.
The only things that work good on ice are chains and studs...and I would not put either on my RX even if they were legal around here.
The only things that work good on ice are chains and studs...and I would not put either on my RX even if they were legal around here.
#368
Registered
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Alto, Michigan
Posts: 195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No problem with rubbing. Now have about 8K miles on them.
The problem in mounting is making sure the dealer has experience with tire pressure sensors. They broke one of mine and decided to pay my Mazda dealership to install the replacement! I highly recommend taking in the service bulletin, or your manual, and reviewing the procedure with the tech, even if they DO have RX-8 experience. An excerpt is shown, below. My painful ordeal is included within this thread, dated probably around March 2005.
Bulletin No: 02-004/04
© 2004 Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Last Issued: 12/21/2004
Page 3 of 6
CHANGING TIRES ON WHEELS EQUIPPED WITH TPMS WHEEL UNITS
1. Remove the wheel from the vehicle.
2. Remove the valve stem cap.
3. Remove schrader valve.
4. Un-bolt the TPMS wheel unit (11mm deep socket). Allow the sensor to fall into the wheel.
NOTE: This will prevent damage to the sensor while the tire is removed from the wheel with a tire removal
machine.
yada yada yada
The problem in mounting is making sure the dealer has experience with tire pressure sensors. They broke one of mine and decided to pay my Mazda dealership to install the replacement! I highly recommend taking in the service bulletin, or your manual, and reviewing the procedure with the tech, even if they DO have RX-8 experience. An excerpt is shown, below. My painful ordeal is included within this thread, dated probably around March 2005.
Bulletin No: 02-004/04
© 2004 Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Last Issued: 12/21/2004
Page 3 of 6
CHANGING TIRES ON WHEELS EQUIPPED WITH TPMS WHEEL UNITS
1. Remove the wheel from the vehicle.
2. Remove the valve stem cap.
3. Remove schrader valve.
4. Un-bolt the TPMS wheel unit (11mm deep socket). Allow the sensor to fall into the wheel.
NOTE: This will prevent damage to the sensor while the tire is removed from the wheel with a tire removal
machine.
yada yada yada
#369
When I called my local dealership to see if they could handle the install before buying the tires the guy seemed kind of insulted that I would assume they couldn't. I took that as a good sign.
#370
Originally Posted by tramahound
When I called my local dealership to see if they could handle the install before buying the tires the guy seemed kind of insulted that I would assume they couldn't. I took that as a good sign.
The moral of this story: Don't believe everything you hear and that goes doubly so for car dealerships...
#372
ok after reading freaking 25 page thread from front to back, you guys convinced me. I was gonna get kumho spt (???) summer tires (since I am FL and they are cheap), but I changed my mind and get Pirelli PZero Nero M+S instead. Luckily tirerack has them in stock.
One question is that tirerack rates it WR but it is actually ZR raiting? Does everyone notice same thingy? Not an issue but I luv to have ZR over WR.
Hopefully I will love it as much as you guys do. (I guess I just added more to this long long thread.)
One question is that tirerack rates it WR but it is actually ZR raiting? Does everyone notice same thingy? Not an issue but I luv to have ZR over WR.
Hopefully I will love it as much as you guys do. (I guess I just added more to this long long thread.)
#373
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Boulder County, Colorado
Posts: 7,966
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by typej
ok after reading freaking 25 page thread from front to back, you guys convinced me. I was gonna get kumho spt (???) summer tires (since I am FL and they are cheap), but I changed my mind and get Pirelli PZero Nero M+S instead. Luckily tirerack has them in stock.
One question is that tirerack rates it WR but it is actually ZR raiting? Does everyone notice same thingy? Not an issue but I luv to have ZR over WR.
Hopefully I will love it as much as you guys do. (I guess I just added more to this long long thread.)
One question is that tirerack rates it WR but it is actually ZR raiting? Does everyone notice same thingy? Not an issue but I luv to have ZR over WR.
Hopefully I will love it as much as you guys do. (I guess I just added more to this long long thread.)
My PZeros are rated WR per the marking on the sidewalls, but I have noticed of late some magazine ads listing the PZeros as ZR. No idea why, unless maybe Pirelli has upgraded their rating.
#374
Got mine from distcount tires. Mention that their online store were selling them for 156 and they match the price and charged me 10.00 per tire instead of 20.00 per tire for the install.. Best part was no shipping cost hehehheh.. anyways so far they have been great..
#375
FX8TED on my RX-8
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 815
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've had my P-Zero Nero M+S replacements for about 10K miles now. If I had to do it over again, I would NOT buy these tires. I got them because so many people raved about them, but IMO they suck big time. They are downright scary in the wet, and I don't feel nearly as confident with them as I did with my OEM Bridgestones RE03's. My TCS light is always coming on when I give it the gas or take a hard corner - I rarely lost traction with the OEMs.
About the only good thing I can say about the P-Zeros is that they'll last a whole lot longer, although that just delays my having fun once again when I go back to the OEMs. Also, they look great on the car!
Frankly, I don't understand how they can behave so poorly for me when others seem to love them. Maybe when my engine was replaced I got an extra 100 ponies... yeah, that's it :D
About the only good thing I can say about the P-Zeros is that they'll last a whole lot longer, although that just delays my having fun once again when I go back to the OEMs. Also, they look great on the car!
Frankly, I don't understand how they can behave so poorly for me when others seem to love them. Maybe when my engine was replaced I got an extra 100 ponies... yeah, that's it :D
Last edited by khoney; 03-22-2006 at 09:03 PM.