Had dealer check compression - What's normal though?
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Beach'n SD, So Cal, USA
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Had dealer check compression - What's normal though?
I wanted to have a real compression check done before the extended warranty ran out, so at 57k miles I paid $73 and had it done. Here are the results from my paperwork:
Rotor #1 at 315rpm: side 1 = 8.9, side 2 = 8.6, side 3 = 8.0 (kg/cm2)
Rotor #2 at 304rpm: side 1 = 9.4, side 2 = 9.4, side 3 = 9.2 (kg/cm2)
<states> "COMPRESSION NORMAL AND ENGINE OK"
I did not get a chance to see my service advisor about the results and not sure of his credibility yet with RX8 service and issues. ...So my question is directed at any rotary experts here. Based on this data, is my engine healthy? ...I'm concerned especially about rotor #1 with one side being 8.9 and the other being 8.0 (kg/cm2), and the min/max spread 8.0 on rotor 1 to 9.4 on rotor 2.
Issues I'm having with the car are vibration at idle, especially with AC on. They also pulled some misfire codes and say 2 of my coils are bad - I ordered new ones and will replace them this week. They looked at the engine mounts and say they are okay, at least visibly. And I had a loss of power above 5k rpm (response went completely flat) when I drove out to the desert last week - 150 miles or more each way with the temps out there at 95 degrees. Power returned when I got back to cooler temps.
All updates have been performed including the recall but I don't believe they checked the engine (vacuum test) since I never complained about lack of power.
Thank you for your time and help.
Rotor #1 at 315rpm: side 1 = 8.9, side 2 = 8.6, side 3 = 8.0 (kg/cm2)
Rotor #2 at 304rpm: side 1 = 9.4, side 2 = 9.4, side 3 = 9.2 (kg/cm2)
<states> "COMPRESSION NORMAL AND ENGINE OK"
I did not get a chance to see my service advisor about the results and not sure of his credibility yet with RX8 service and issues. ...So my question is directed at any rotary experts here. Based on this data, is my engine healthy? ...I'm concerned especially about rotor #1 with one side being 8.9 and the other being 8.0 (kg/cm2), and the min/max spread 8.0 on rotor 1 to 9.4 on rotor 2.
Issues I'm having with the car are vibration at idle, especially with AC on. They also pulled some misfire codes and say 2 of my coils are bad - I ordered new ones and will replace them this week. They looked at the engine mounts and say they are okay, at least visibly. And I had a loss of power above 5k rpm (response went completely flat) when I drove out to the desert last week - 150 miles or more each way with the temps out there at 95 degrees. Power returned when I got back to cooler temps.
All updates have been performed including the recall but I don't believe they checked the engine (vacuum test) since I never complained about lack of power.
Thank you for your time and help.
#2
Registered
Originally Posted by socalightning
I wanted to have a real compression check done before the extended warranty ran out, so at 57k miles I paid $73 and had it done. Here are the results from my paperwork:
Rotor #1 at 315rpm: side 1 = 8.9, side 2 = 8.6, side 3 = 8.0 (kg/cm2)
Rotor #2 at 304rpm: side 1 = 9.4, side 2 = 9.4, side 3 = 9.2 (kg/cm2)
<states> "COMPRESSION NORMAL AND ENGINE OK"
I did not get a chance to see my service advisor about the results and not sure of his credibility yet with RX8 service and issues. ...So my question is directed at any rotary experts here. Based on this data, is my engine healthy? ...I'm concerned especially about rotor #1 with one side being 8.9 and the other being 8.0 (kg/cm2), and the min/max spread 8.0 on rotor 1 to 9.4 on rotor 2.
Issues I'm having with the car are vibration at idle, especially with AC on. They also pulled some misfire codes and say 2 of my coils are bad - I ordered new ones and will replace them this week. They looked at the engine mounts and say they are okay, at least visibly. And I had a loss of power above 5k rpm (response went completely flat) when I drove out to the desert last week - 150 miles or more each way with the temps out there at 95 degrees. Power returned when I got back to cooler temps.
All updates have been performed including the recall but I don't believe they checked the engine (vacuum test) since I never complained about lack of power.
Thank you for your time and help.
Rotor #1 at 315rpm: side 1 = 8.9, side 2 = 8.6, side 3 = 8.0 (kg/cm2)
Rotor #2 at 304rpm: side 1 = 9.4, side 2 = 9.4, side 3 = 9.2 (kg/cm2)
<states> "COMPRESSION NORMAL AND ENGINE OK"
I did not get a chance to see my service advisor about the results and not sure of his credibility yet with RX8 service and issues. ...So my question is directed at any rotary experts here. Based on this data, is my engine healthy? ...I'm concerned especially about rotor #1 with one side being 8.9 and the other being 8.0 (kg/cm2), and the min/max spread 8.0 on rotor 1 to 9.4 on rotor 2.
Issues I'm having with the car are vibration at idle, especially with AC on. They also pulled some misfire codes and say 2 of my coils are bad - I ordered new ones and will replace them this week. They looked at the engine mounts and say they are okay, at least visibly. And I had a loss of power above 5k rpm (response went completely flat) when I drove out to the desert last week - 150 miles or more each way with the temps out there at 95 degrees. Power returned when I got back to cooler temps.
All updates have been performed including the recall but I don't believe they checked the engine (vacuum test) since I never complained about lack of power.
Thank you for your time and help.
I must say that those are pretty high engine cranking speed numbers. You must have the upgraded starter and a fully-charged upgraded battery?
Last edited by Go48; 03-27-2007 at 06:02 PM.
#3
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Beach'n SD, So Cal, USA
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Go48! I guess I should get a copy of the service manual. Yes, I have the upgraded starter and battery. I appreciate you for graphing my results. Looks like my lowest reading rotor side (#1- 3) could be below minimum for that cranking speed (315rpm). So, do you (or anyone else) think the numbers are good for a 60k mile rotory engine??? I'm worried about getting stuck with a damaged motor having to do with Mazda's poor oil injection programming - I hope to go another 60k before rebuilding my motor.
#4
Registered
Originally Posted by socalightning
Thanks Go48! I guess I should get a copy of the service manual. Yes, I have the upgraded starter and battery. I appreciate you for graphing my results. Looks like my lowest reading rotor side (#1- 3) could be below minimum for that cranking speed (315rpm). So, do you (or anyone else) think the numbers are good for a 60k mile rotory engine??? I'm worried about getting stuck with a damaged motor having to do with Mazda's poor oil injection programming - I hope to go another 60k before rebuilding my motor.
BTW, see my PM.
#6
we had a car come in recently that did something really really really weird.
it was flooded, we got it started, but it was running on 1 rotor. so we compression tested it, and one rotor was ok (in the 9's) other rotor was in the 5's, dead engine right?
mazda told us to put coils into it. we did.
engine is now fine. compression came up to specs, car runs fine.
ive been playing with rotaries since 93, but NEVER seen a bad coil change compression numbers.
i would consider your compression test numbers meaningless until you get the coils fixed.
also the motor mounts dont fail visually yet
it was flooded, we got it started, but it was running on 1 rotor. so we compression tested it, and one rotor was ok (in the 9's) other rotor was in the 5's, dead engine right?
mazda told us to put coils into it. we did.
engine is now fine. compression came up to specs, car runs fine.
ive been playing with rotaries since 93, but NEVER seen a bad coil change compression numbers.
i would consider your compression test numbers meaningless until you get the coils fixed.
also the motor mounts dont fail visually yet
#7
Zoom-Freakin'-Zoom
iTrader: (5)
Originally Posted by j9fd3s
we had a car come in recently that did something really really really weird.
it was flooded, we got it started, but it was running on 1 rotor. so we compression tested it, and one rotor was ok (in the 9's) other rotor was in the 5's, dead engine right?
mazda told us to put coils into it. we did.
engine is now fine. compression came up to specs, car runs fine.
ive been playing with rotaries since 93, but NEVER seen a bad coil change compression numbers.
i would consider your compression test numbers meaningless until you get the coils fixed.
also the motor mounts dont fail visually yet
it was flooded, we got it started, but it was running on 1 rotor. so we compression tested it, and one rotor was ok (in the 9's) other rotor was in the 5's, dead engine right?
mazda told us to put coils into it. we did.
engine is now fine. compression came up to specs, car runs fine.
ive been playing with rotaries since 93, but NEVER seen a bad coil change compression numbers.
i would consider your compression test numbers meaningless until you get the coils fixed.
also the motor mounts dont fail visually yet
flooded motor wiped out all the oil in the chamber... compession test was done before the motor was run.. with new coils. now the plugs fire and that rotor is not in a constant state of flood..
start motor apex seals get oil, compression comes back...
beers
Last edited by swoope; 03-27-2007 at 11:07 PM.
#9
Originally Posted by Charles R. Hill
As for my own car, my dealer supposedly did a compression test and reported numbers in the 6's. Unfortunately, those idiots ignored Mazda protocol and ignored the fact that I have the failed starter and battery so I probably also had a low rpm during the test. I repeatedly asked for the rpm's but they claimed they didn't have those numbers. That tells me they didn't use the proper machine(is it called the WDS?) to do the test.
My previous dealer once did a compression check when the engine was cold. Man were those numbers shocking.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Touge
Canada Forum
0
08-19-2015 11:00 PM
ahyuo121
New Member Forum
3
08-03-2015 01:52 AM
dbarber
Series I Trouble Shooting
14
07-25-2015 01:34 PM