coilover wear
#1
No means yes
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Jersey City NJ
Posts: 1,507
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
coilover wear
Quick question for people with coilovers - how good are they wrt wear? I am considering buying a used set, so I'm trying to figure out:
- how many miles would be too much? (alternatively, how many miles on yours and any problems?) 1k? 10k? 100k?
- how to check if they're still "good"?
Thanks,
-Dmitri
- how many miles would be too much? (alternatively, how many miles on yours and any problems?) 1k? 10k? 100k?
- how to check if they're still "good"?
Thanks,
-Dmitri
#3
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Misinformation Director - Evolv Chicago
Posts: 3,086
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have about 20K on my Tein Flex and they're still fine. That's also on downtown Chicago roads which are not really in the best condition and hundreds of track miles. I'm kind of curious to see how long they last given the torture they endure every day.
#6
My first post
I think buying used coilovers is not the best thing to do becuase you never know how they were abused / used etc. Unless of course maybe you are buying them from a friend and a trustworthy source.
Another thing to consider is the type of coilover. Is this a twin tube or a monotube?
A monotube will at some point fail becuase of the higher gas pressure, which in turn puts more pressure on the seals, which are typically the first thing to go. To help know if this is the case, take the spring off of the coilover, wipe the piston rod shaft clean and then compress the shock. When it returns to normal positioning, see if there is any oil on the piston rock, if so, not a good sign.
A twin tube has low gas pressure and there fore will not have the potential problem of blowing seals like mentioned above. The ride characteristics of the twin tube will be more comfortable and life of the shock should have better durability. In comparison, a monotube will be a more stiff harsher ride.
When a coilover manufactuer makes coilovers they ideally have to reach the same standards or exceed that of the OEM parts. So the life of a coilover is either equal to the life of the OEM parts or somewhat better. But at some time all parts will digress in performance that could be 60K later though. And if you paid $1500 for a set of coilovers that lasted 60K, you got a very good deal.
I would suggest to save your money and buy new. Hope this helps.
Justin
I think buying used coilovers is not the best thing to do becuase you never know how they were abused / used etc. Unless of course maybe you are buying them from a friend and a trustworthy source.
Another thing to consider is the type of coilover. Is this a twin tube or a monotube?
A monotube will at some point fail becuase of the higher gas pressure, which in turn puts more pressure on the seals, which are typically the first thing to go. To help know if this is the case, take the spring off of the coilover, wipe the piston rod shaft clean and then compress the shock. When it returns to normal positioning, see if there is any oil on the piston rock, if so, not a good sign.
A twin tube has low gas pressure and there fore will not have the potential problem of blowing seals like mentioned above. The ride characteristics of the twin tube will be more comfortable and life of the shock should have better durability. In comparison, a monotube will be a more stiff harsher ride.
When a coilover manufactuer makes coilovers they ideally have to reach the same standards or exceed that of the OEM parts. So the life of a coilover is either equal to the life of the OEM parts or somewhat better. But at some time all parts will digress in performance that could be 60K later though. And if you paid $1500 for a set of coilovers that lasted 60K, you got a very good deal.
I would suggest to save your money and buy new. Hope this helps.
Justin
#8
Administrator
iTrader: (7)
Justin, that's a hell of a first post. WELCOME!
#9
No means yes
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Jersey City NJ
Posts: 1,507
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks, Justin, nice post! I am looking at Tein Flex (I want EDFC, and feedback for street applications is good) which are not monotube.. If you can get around 60k miles out of a set of coilovers (that haven't been abused), then buying a used set with 5-10k miles could be a good value, since you're likely paying half of retail price but have something like 80% life left in them..
Disassembling them wouldn't really be an option when buying used, but I guess checking for fluid leaks is a good start? That or tossing them on a pogo stick
Disassembling them wouldn't really be an option when buying used, but I guess checking for fluid leaks is a good start? That or tossing them on a pogo stick
#10
Thanks, Justin, nice post! I am looking at Tein Flex (I want EDFC, and feedback for street applications is good) which are not monotube.. If you can get around 60k miles out of a set of coilovers (that haven't been abused), then buying a used set with 5-10k miles could be a good value, since you're likely paying half of retail price but have something like 80% life left in them..
Disassembling them wouldn't really be an option when buying used, but I guess checking for fluid leaks is a good start? That or tossing them on a pogo stick
Disassembling them wouldn't really be an option when buying used, but I guess checking for fluid leaks is a good start? That or tossing them on a pogo stick
Coilovers are made to equal or best the OEM standards of the suspension. I think that OEM suspension would last around 25 to 30K before you would change out shocks and that would be with no lowering springs. If you were to install lowering springs, the life of the shocks would be much shorter because of the shorter stroke and with time the bottoming out of the shock, therefore needing replacement.
Of course this is just my opinion. Perhaps the life of the OEM shocks is much longer than I perceive them to be.
J.
Last edited by Endura-Tech; 02-20-2008 at 02:16 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
jasonrxeight
RX-8's For Sale/Wanted
2
09-30-2015 01:53 PM