RX8 Engine Replacement - BAD NEWS
#451
Castrol GTX is basically a poorman's redline oil...its got alot of moly, and is basically a heavily refined Group III oil. Its one of the best cheapest oils out there.
So is Motorcraft 5w-20 semi-synthetic...very cheap, very good wear #'s across the board.
So is Motorcraft 5w-20 semi-synthetic...very cheap, very good wear #'s across the board.
#452
Oil
I asked my rep at Magic Mazda which oil he would use if he was doing his own oil changes.
His answer? CASTROL
What oil would he NOT recommend using? PENZOIL
Rob in Vegas
His answer? CASTROL
What oil would he NOT recommend using? PENZOIL
Rob in Vegas
Last edited by Oktobernv; 08-25-2005 at 10:33 AM.
#456
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Cary, NC
Posts: 20
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just an update about my car...
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen. They said they have seen this mainly in automatics.
But, after all this turmoil, I told them that to avoid litigation, I want them to buy back my 8 and in turn, I would purchase a Mazda 6 (loaded). I know it's not even close to same the car, but I have lost all faith in my 8 after this mess.
I'll let you know what develops....
-Lance
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen. They said they have seen this mainly in automatics.
But, after all this turmoil, I told them that to avoid litigation, I want them to buy back my 8 and in turn, I would purchase a Mazda 6 (loaded). I know it's not even close to same the car, but I have lost all faith in my 8 after this mess.
I'll let you know what develops....
-Lance
#457
Black Cherry 6-Speed
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Columbia, MD
Posts: 149
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by LanceaRoo
Just an update about my car...
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen. They said they have seen this mainly in automatics.
But, after all this turmoil, I told them that to avoid litigation, I want them to buy back my 8 and in turn, I would purchase a Mazda 6 (loaded). I know it's not even close to same the car, but I have lost all faith in my 8 after this mess.
I'll let you know what develops....
-Lance
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen. They said they have seen this mainly in automatics.
But, after all this turmoil, I told them that to avoid litigation, I want them to buy back my 8 and in turn, I would purchase a Mazda 6 (loaded). I know it's not even close to same the car, but I have lost all faith in my 8 after this mess.
I'll let you know what develops....
-Lance
#458
If your getting a 6 ATX, please make sure to get the 6spd. The 5spd ATX's have horrible overheating issues.
For more information on 6 issues/modifications
http://www.mazda6tech.com
(Sorry for the midtopic plug, but I wanted to make sure he doesn't jump one car to land in another problem zone)
For more information on 6 issues/modifications
http://www.mazda6tech.com
(Sorry for the midtopic plug, but I wanted to make sure he doesn't jump one car to land in another problem zone)
#459
Shifty Bastard.
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Melbourne, Australia.
Posts: 4,835
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by LanceaRoo
Just an update about my car...
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen......
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen......
Hmmm...the plot thickens.....
#460
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: michigan
Posts: 295
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i have the marble sound in my engine...usually when cold. i also notice i do not use as much oil as i used to. could the engine be oil starved>?
has anyone noticed these two symptoms together?
has anyone noticed these two symptoms together?
#463
Registered
Originally Posted by kw1k
Wait wait wait , This is complete BS, Doesnt the Lemon law come in affect if this occurs 4 times and the dealer cannot fix it
#464
Registered
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Richland WA
Posts: 284
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I filled my 8 with 87 octane and had mazda see if they could fix the knock issues that it is having. Well, they ran some cleaner throught the engine to remove any carbon and told me it is fixed. They aslo said that I should only use 87 octane from now on and that is what Mazda is now recommending. I dunno about this fix of theirs.
#465
FX8TED on my RX-8
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 815
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by LanceaRoo
Just an update about my car...
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen. They said they have seen this mainly in automatics.
But, after all this turmoil, I told them that to avoid litigation, I want them to buy back my 8 and in turn, I would purchase a Mazda 6 (loaded). I know it's not even close to same the car, but I have lost all faith in my 8 after this mess.
I'll let you know what develops....
-Lance
The dealership called yesterday and told me that the computer module has been pulled out of my car and shipped to Mazda for service. The cooling fan has not been kicking on when it becomes hot and they want to do some adjustments to my computer to make this happen. They said they have seen this mainly in automatics.
But, after all this turmoil, I told them that to avoid litigation, I want them to buy back my 8 and in turn, I would purchase a Mazda 6 (loaded). I know it's not even close to same the car, but I have lost all faith in my 8 after this mess.
I'll let you know what develops....
-Lance
#467
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Sacramento, CA, USA
Posts: 127
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Rick
I filled my 8 with 87 octane and had mazda see if they could fix the knock issues that it is having. Well, they ran some cleaner throught the engine to remove any carbon and told me it is fixed.
Your engine was knocking with 87 octane? That's not good.
My understanding is that 91 octane is recommended by Mazda for performance purposes, not to prevent knock.
They aslo said that I should only use 87 octane from now on and that is what Mazda is now recommending (emphasis added).
Does this mean we should not use anything other than 87? Even higher grades?
It seems like either you misunderstood what you were told, or (probably more likely) the person who spoke to you did a very poor job of explaining things.
Personally, I've been using premium grade since day one because I'm a bit afraid to use anything less, given the credibility of Mazda that has been called into question regarding the whole North American oil grade/EPA thing...
Not trying to be alarmist, just trying to get the record set straight...
#468
Registered
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Richland WA
Posts: 284
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
^I'm just telling you what the man behind the counter said to me. Anyway, I'll run 87 in my 8 A/T like he said and when it knocks again I'll bring it back to them. I took the 8 for a spirited drive tonight and so sar it has not knocked. However, the ambient temperature was only 66 fahrenheit so I'm not surprised. I'll have to wait untill temperatures are 80+ before I will know for sure that 87 octane will work in my 8 with out knocking.
#469
Originally Posted by Rick
I filled my 8 with 87 octane and had mazda see if they could fix the knock issues that it is having. Well, they ran some cleaner throught the engine to remove any carbon and told me it is fixed. They aslo said that I should only use 87 octane from now on and that is what Mazda is now recommending. I dunno about this fix of theirs.
Premium = higher octane and more detergent
What your service writer said doesn't make sense.
--R
PS. more knock resistance should allow the computer a leaner mixture and therefore more performance.
#470
Registered
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Richland WA
Posts: 284
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
^ I know that and I'm sure they do too. I just wanted to know why my 8 knocks on 87 while most other 8s do not. They (the mazda tech)believe that the higher octane fuel leaves deposits (carbon) behind while running at lower RPMs and that is why they "decarboned" it. My wife drives our 8 through town at low RPMs during the week. I'll drive the 8 hard this weekend to see if the engine has carboned up again while using 87. If it knocks I'll take it back to the shop. BTW, I'm talking about the automatic 8
#473
Originally Posted by Rick
^ I know that and I'm sure they do too. I just wanted to know why my 8 knocks on 87 while most other 8s do not. They (the mazda tech)believe that the higher octane fuel leaves deposits (carbon) behind while running at lower RPMs and that is why they "decarboned" it. My wife drives our 8 through town at low RPMs during the week. I'll drive the 8 hard this weekend to see if the engine has carboned up again while using 87. If it knocks I'll take it back to the shop. BTW, I'm talking about the automatic 8
At any rate, it seems unlikely that advice to use lower octane to reduce detonation can be correct, especially since such advice contradicts the owners manual. Maybe there are some here who know more.
--R.
#474
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Sacramento, CA, USA
Posts: 127
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just returned from octane and carbon build-up school -- i.e., I just read:
Regular or Premium?
Is premium fuel worth the premium price?
Can you hurt a high-octane car by running it on the cheaper stuff?
by Frank Markus
Car & Driver
In-the-Octane-Know:
How to tame the octane octopus
by Mike Bumbeck
automedia.com
What's the difference between premium and regular gas?
by Cecil Adams
The Straight Dope
Bad Gas
by Larry Carley
AA1Car Online Technical Library
Summarizing what I've learned from those articles and our owner's manual:Is premium fuel worth the premium price?
Can you hurt a high-octane car by running it on the cheaper stuff?
by Frank Markus
Car & Driver
In-the-Octane-Know:
How to tame the octane octopus
by Mike Bumbeck
automedia.com
What's the difference between premium and regular gas?
by Cecil Adams
The Straight Dope
Bad Gas
by Larry Carley
AA1Car Online Technical Library
- Our RX-8s should run fine* on 87 octane fuel, such that the octane level itself should not cause knocking. (*Fine = not cause damage, though not necessarily with optimum performance)
- A buildup of carbon deposits may occur for a variety of reasons, and if that occurs, that may cause "hot spots" where compression is higher and, thus, the opportunity for spontaneous combustion of fuel (a.k.a. knocking) increases.
- If carbon deposits build up, increasing the octane of the fuel should stop the knocking, but doing that only masks the problem of the carbon buildup. The engine would need to be cleaned, which hopefully can be accomplished with an additive -- otherwise, a more extensive repair would be necessary.
Last edited by sharward; 09-18-2005 at 09:18 AM.
#475
Registered User
Join Date: May 2003
Location: atlanta ga
Posts: 608
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Very good stuff sharwood. This topic is very interesting. I think one of the problems is related to some design dilemmas that Mazda is probably trying to find the best solution (Compromise) for. I think the Renesis is much more prone to carbon buildup in various parts of the motor than previous rotaries but sufficient oil metering must be provided to maintain apex seal life. Sufficient quantities of oil in combustion I believe can lead to increased carbon buildup. A lot of slow driven versions (Often but not limited to automatics) would potentially suffer the most.
One of my suggestions, although maybe not financially practical would be superior apex seal materials which would reduce oil metering needs.
Here's a stange riddle: A prominent engine builder that I know told me he has to to compensate his air/fuel ratios when forced to run higher octanes than necessary for certain races by richening.
One of my suggestions, although maybe not financially practical would be superior apex seal materials which would reduce oil metering needs.
Here's a stange riddle: A prominent engine builder that I know told me he has to to compensate his air/fuel ratios when forced to run higher octanes than necessary for certain races by richening.