Nubo

If there was any hard documentation for any aspect of this never-ending debate, there wouldn't be 2000 posts in this thread.

The service life of the Renesis is short enough that any benefit or detriment from synthetic oil is lost in the noise.

RIWWP

iTrader: (2)

And there you are making the assumption that the owner's manual choices/instructions are made in the best interest of vehicle mechanical parts

You would be wrong. Certainly they try to, but for example why aren't coil changes listed at all in the scheduled maintenance? Maybe they didn't know at the time. Or how about any reference to redline or driving it hard? Lawyers and liability there.

All sorts of reasons why the "official" documentation for anything as liability prone as a car won't actually be the correct true story.

And actually, yeah, the owner's manual IS still on the internet

Emery_

iTrader: (8)

Your argument is flawed, if you choose to believe everything the manual tells you and recommends to the t, then by all means go ahead. Various people on the forum are and have been running synthetic fluids with no negative impact on the car whatsoever. On the other side, people running 5w-20 oil like the manual RECOMMENDS have seen pre-mature bearing failure due to running that thin of an oil. Why is it recommended? Like other said, for emissions reasons in the U.S only. Hence, why other weights are recommended in other parts of the world, for the same exact engine. Synthetic oils are a much better oil than conventional oil, and that is a fact. Many people believe it makes no difference and combusts the same as conventional oil, and does no harm. You can do whatever you like, no one is telling you to use synthetic. But your argument of believing what the manual tells you is ridiculous, RIWWP and others have brought up a good point that everything that is stated in the manual is not what the engineers are exactly recommending or what they would really recommend. Just like they cannot tell you that you should redline the car to prevent carbon build up because its a liability issue.

Carbon8

iTrader: (4)

^Owned and Agreed +2

usnidc

Aren't most synthetics now days just highly refined (hydrocracked) Dino oil anyway? If that is true then using a group III synthetic is just putting in really good Dino oil. The question should be what do group IV synthetics do in our engines?

Iluvrevs

I’ve read and been told that group IV base stocks create harder deposits than the others including I and II, but that doesn’t appear to be the case in this test and Id imagine that this has improved over time. Some group Vs such as the veggie derived will deposit more than a polyolester from what I’ve been told. Case in point on both of these is the Mobil 1 0w weight oils which while showing some deposits weren’t bad at all and they contain some Group IV and Group V (AN and maybe polyolester) by most reports.

What that means for us is beyond my ability to quantify but I’m inclined to think that this test is at least somewhat relevant.

Ramart

I'm not actually arguing the point, merely saying I'd prefer to put my faith in the owner's manual and the car's manufacturer rather than in a bunch of random guys on a website, some of whom are assumed to have a godlike omniscience about rotary lubrication science. Sure I could be wrong, but so might you be.

nycgps

iTrader: (1)

First off :


You amused me.

and second :



and finally (for now) :


Strike out! Oh yeah,They are the one and ONLY company to have their car inside Mazda show room in Japan. I'm sure Knight Sports knows better than you!


and you do know that why we have OMP right? because the MARKETING DEPARTMENT SAID SO! NOT Engineering department.

RIWWP

iTrader: (2)

I edited your post NYCGPS

Your valid passion doesn't always get recognized as such. No need to get personal.

RIWWP

iTrader: (2)

NYC, take a breather man. No need to get personal. I really don't want to hand you something more serious.

I get it, i really do. Yelling at him won't change his mind and will only derail the thread.

ASH8

Hey J cool it man...

Gee, I would like to close this thread...take a vote ???..

Just thinking out loud.

9krpmrx8

iTrader: (46)

Let's Vote.

Emery_

iTrader: (8)

I'd vote, but what exactly would we vote on? "What kind of oil do you use?" Or "Do you think it's safe to use?"

It's still an opinion technically, so the discussion will always be open really. Just saying. :D

Posted From RX8Club.com Android App

wcs

iTrader: (2)

Close the thread

9krpmrx8

iTrader: (46)

I concur.

shadycrew31

iTrader: (6)

The discussion is over, shady has spoken.

ASH8

ATTENTION ALL MEMBERS

General Notice.

I am posting this here so that most active members will receive an email notice ..

I suggest all re-read the forum rules to re-fresh some attitudes...

Please pay particular attention to # 1 to # 18 inclusive.

RX8Club.com - FAQ: RX8Club.com Forum Rules


ALSO THE FOLLOWING....

Attacks on moderators will not be tolerated, and may result in an immediate permanent ban.

Moderators sometimes have to make difficult judgment calls, but remember we *are* human.

Hopefully we'll make decisions that are considered "correct" by the majority of the community.

Do not post complaints, criticisms, or moderation questions on the forum.

These posts will be deleted and no explanation will be given.

If you have a concern about a particular moderator (person), send a private message to a Super Moderator or Administrator.

If you have constructive suggestions on improvements that can be made to the forum or its moderation (not personalities), please post them in the Suggestions area.

POSTING.....

Some older and experienced member behaviour has been disgraceful, particularly to NEW Members with little to no experience either in Rotaries or Forum use.
Unless you have forgotten this FREE to use Forum can ONLY survive with having an active (large) member list with active Vendors and Advertisers.

Yes, we can all at times become frustrated with the same questions being continually asked, however, if you are
not prepared to respond with a helpful or kind approach with positive contributions, then please DO NOT reply at all....simple.

POST EDITING BY MODERATORS.....

If ‘’non-contributing’’ messages are posted and or harassing, post trolling, abuse, or anything that breaks Forum Rules (see link above) then these posts will either be edited or removed.
If severe enough, such posts will be reported and infractions will be allocated to those members who continue to repeat offend.
Once a number of Infractions are accumulated then either a Holiday (time out from forum use 1 to 30 days), or permanent ban WILL BE GIVEN.
Repeat offenders (mod editing) also has their infraction (what posted or said) archived as a future reference.

FINAL....

We (Staff) have had enough of new members being insulted, harassed, even bullied, or put off from asking questions about their RX-8 or associated problems from other members..
Staff are annoyed that we have to continually ‘edit out’ such posting behaviour.
We are all here to learn and help out, even to enjoy.

This Forum is not here for anyone's “private or group amusement of others”.

Thank you for reading..

Ash

olddragger

iTrader: (3)

i concour close thread.

paimon.soror

iTrader: (15)

Has anyone had any experience with Amsoil Signature 0/30? I considered giving the Sustina 0/50 a shot, but over the past few days I came across a few threads where people sent in virgin samples to the labs and the numbers that came back were drastically lower than advertised. Little too expensive for my taste when it isn't as stable as expected.

Gunna be sending in a sample of the newer formula german castrol (the "SPT" series 0/30) to see if it does as well as its "older formula" did.

So far on my engine the M1 0/40 came back with praise from the labs.

ronnydingding

i have had my 04' 8 from 07' and have been using AC Delco supreme plus 5/30 , with specs API sl/cf ACEA A3-02/B3-98hash2/B4-02 . VW 502.00/505.00 . MB229.3 .
I only know the API 's relevance ,but i have had no problems with using this oil and an added bonus is the price at £24 for 5 litre can . Anyone else using cheaper oils?

ronnydingding

and another thing , is the difference betweeen mineral and synthetic that syn's maintain their lubing qualities much longer than mineral oil's , and s far as syn's not burning off in the combustion chamber this should only change things on the exhaust side of the engine and i've not had any blue smoke out of the back of my 8 yet .

sweatr

This might help?.

sweatr

I have not used Amsoil , yet, I am at 2000 miles and ready to dump the Royal Purple and send it to "Lubrication Engineers INC. at 1-800-537-7683 if you want to reach them. They will due and engine oil analysis although we haven't worked out what I want from the test and I am open to suggestions as to what all to include in the analysis beyond the normal information. I am open to suggestions as to what analysis would be helpful to the thread that is specific to the rotory. My next 2000 mile test will be with Amsoil 5w-30. The royal purple is 5w-30. If interested I will post the official paper work they send me for the analysis of each brand.

RIWWP

iTrader: (2)

Nothing to add to look for, but be sure to post the results in the used oil analysis thread.

nycgps

iTrader: (1)

F synthetic ! Itz garbage ! Cuz my friend's friend's friend's friend's friend's friend's neighbor's dog told me so ! Boooyea !