Pinoy09

Hey guys, so hopefully if im approaved for a loan i'll be a happy owner of a rx8 04 or 05 model. more than likely it'll be 04.

if my area I've found 2 that around the price i want though the body's could be a bit better its nothing to throw a fit about.

but i need some opinions and advice on which i should go for based on the info and the mazda warranty.

the first one is a silver 04 6spd with 92k miles, motor replaced at 63k miles.
(wasnt sure how the warranty worked towards new motors.)
guy is askin $11,500 (too much) so thought i'd shoot an offer of $8,500 or 9 based on reviews and current standings on kbb, nada, etc.
http://littlerock.craigslist.org/cto/1682927932.html car's plastic rear seems to be falling off a bit. (noticable on up close look.)

and the second option is a 04 red 6spd with 75k miles. MS package. slight hail damage and minor front end damage. priced at $9,200
http://littlerock.craigslist.org/cto/1691686933.html

What do you guys think?
Thanks.