RX8Club.com

RX8Club.com (https://www.rx8club.com/)
-   Series I Trouble Shooting (https://www.rx8club.com/series-i-trouble-shooting-95/)
-   -   It finally happened (https://www.rx8club.com/series-i-trouble-shooting-95/finally-happened-150825/)

09Factor 07-24-2008 09:53 PM

I was going to plumb in a another oil cooler near the back of the car. since I have all this space where the other exhaust tip would be.
Any guesses on what kind of oil pressure loss I may see?

olddragger 07-24-2008 10:14 PM

significate it maybe--be careful with that
od

Easy_E1 07-24-2008 10:36 PM

And here I thought I was the King of Overheating.

Anyway,, my latest engine has about 30,000 miles on it. It (the car) has been overheating since the three prior engines. The new engine is from Japan, not a REMAN. It (latest engine) has been overheating in the summers down here since the temps hit 105 degrees and up for the last year and a half.
Recently (a couple of weeks ago) MM and I did a compression test on the car. After we visited Phil and did his. I was concerned that the same thing might be happening to mine.
Well,,,, we did the compression test, did the rpm calculations and the end result was,

120psi across the board. Go figure. This is an engine that has seen temps (recorded) as high as 243 degrees. And more than likely higher.

So it baffles me to see an engine like Phil's fail at 15,000 miles.
I really find it hard to understand that overheating his car has caused low compression.
I don't have the cooling upgrades that Phil has, BHR Rad, Mazmart waterpump. I have kept mine stock in the cooling dept for warranty reasons.

I feel that it is caused by other factors. I'm unable to determine what at this point. After we get it apart maybe it will become more evident.

So all you rocket scientists ponder that.

Brettus 07-24-2008 10:45 PM

simple
overheating + FI = apex pwnage

Phil , what ratio were you premixing at and has your oil consumption been stable lately ? Thanks

Easy_E1 07-24-2008 11:23 PM

Overheating is not going to effect the Apex seal. It's holding combustion gases already and is going to be hotter than the coolant already.
There is nothing the Apex seal is going to transfer the heat to. Apex will run just a bit under combustion temps.
Only thing that is going to cause Apex premature wear is a lack of lubrication.
Side seals also should be considered, but the only way for them to fail is to break. That didn't happen. End play against the corner seal? Have to be ALL twelve of them to have such even compression numbers.
So you are left with rotor housing grooving due to foreign material entrance through intake, or all six Apex seals worn down unevenly due to lack of OMP flow/spray.
Or it's a boost issue. Which I doubt.

I'm going with the Apex oiling scenario.

Brettus 07-24-2008 11:36 PM

yeah - i'm thinking a lubrication issue more logical as well - hence the question .....

Phil's 8 07-25-2008 06:54 AM


Originally Posted by Brettus (Post 2566391)
simple
overheating + FI = apex pwnage

Phil , what ratio were you premixing at and has your oil consumption been stable lately ? Thanks

I started premixing at 1000 miles and used Pettit premix and their recommended 4oz to a tank, later I started using Idemitsu in the same amount per tank (4oz). I have been consistent with it's use and at that ratio thru today. My oil consumption thru the metering system has been inconsistent until I had the Cobb AP installed. That is one reason I went premix. When the car at 1000 miles did not conform to recommended oil use I started to premix immediately. The dealer at that time was going to talk to Mazda to find what caused the inconsistency but they closed up and left me with another dealer that was more antagonistic than helpful.

olddragger 07-25-2008 11:20 AM

Phil, I know the compression test is the holy grale kind of thing , but what were your vacumn numbers and is the car idling ok?
This is strange. I have never heard of a 15k engine with low compression. Blown---yes. But not nearly equal-- low compression in all faces in both rotors. Even high milage ones usually have a face or 2 left that have fairly good compression.
It would be interesting to see if a pre mix of 2 oz per gal on a test run would make any difference.
OD

Phil's 8 07-25-2008 11:52 AM


Originally Posted by olddragger (Post 2566982)
Phil, I know the compression test is the holy grale kind of thing , but what were your vacumn numbers and is the car idling ok?
This is strange. I have never heard of a 15k engine with low compression. Blown---yes. But not nearly equal-- low compression in all faces in both rotors. Even high milage ones usually have a face or 2 left that have fairly good compression.
It would be interesting to see if a pre mix of 2 oz per gal on a test run would make any difference.
OD

I can't tell you my vacuum numbers cuz I only logged the vacuum from the intake at supercharger cuz we were having that problem with the bypass valve and were trying to blame the terrible idle on it. Jeff or Ray may remember them but at the time we were sure the problem was the valve. The car presently idles very low and Jeff has trouble getting more idle RPM from it. It really picks up when boost enters the picture

The low mileage is the main reason we tried to blame my ongoing problems on other things. We did find problems elsewhere but they never fixed the main problem of the idle.

Can't hurt to try a one time trial of 2oz per gallon. Not real sure what that would prove but hell I'll try anything. I was the one in the group that thought the compression check was a waste of time, shows what I know.

Brettus 07-25-2008 02:32 PM

Premix at 4 oz per tank is not enough to do anything helpful (especially given that you are FI'd) in my opinion .
If your MOP was playing up then there is a posibility that premix was the only lubrication you were getting at times so lack of lubrication does sound like the likely cause .
have a look at the oil delivery lines - are there any bubbles in the lines ?

MazdaManiac 07-25-2008 02:58 PM

His OMP is working (and jacked up via the AP).

Brettus 07-25-2008 03:02 PM

I know it's pretty difficult to actually guage this but he did say it was inconsistent .......

olddragger 07-25-2008 06:33 PM

the high amount of premix will not hurt anything for just a short run and if it helps seal --well the idle should be affected and you should be able to tell a difference in the engine. it will not cure anything.
od

Phil's 8 07-25-2008 07:22 PM


Originally Posted by Brettus (Post 2567351)
I know it's pretty difficult to actually guage this but he did say it was inconsistent .......

It was inconsistent before the AP.
I would have a problem with the smog cops if I tried burning more than 4oz per tank. It smokes too much. Already tried increasing it and got stopped. Luckily he did not check for a cat but I had trouble explaining premix to him. The smog cops have no sense of humor.

Brettus 07-25-2008 07:38 PM


Originally Posted by Phil's 8 (Post 2567722)
It was inconsistent before the AP.
I would have a problem with the smog cops if I tried burning more than 4oz per tank. It smokes too much. Already tried increasing it and got stopped. Luckily he did not check for a cat but I had trouble explaining premix to him. The smog cops have no sense of humor.

perhaps the damage was already done :dunno:

I've put in as much as 20oz per tank (at the track) and didn't notice the smoke - not that I would I guess ....

MazdaManiac 07-26-2008 02:39 AM

Yeah, that is strange.
I've never gotten smoke from premix, either.

olddragger 07-26-2008 11:00 AM

bingo.
make sure your dip stick is sealing:)
od

Phil's 8 07-26-2008 11:32 AM


Originally Posted by Charles R. Hill (Post 2568123)
My hunch is that we will have some interesting engine pieces to show all of you on-line and at SSXI this year. Probably apex seals with ruts in the sides of them as deep as horse troughs and pix of them wobbling in the rotor tips.

Your making it sound really bad - Are you sure you want to drive it back to Phoenix? :dubs: :rl:

DOMINION 07-27-2008 04:12 AM


Originally Posted by MazdaManiac (Post 2565607)
Spraying water on the rad does nothing.

What about oil cooler fans like the ones the guys use in Japan?

DOMINION 07-27-2008 04:13 AM


Originally Posted by Brettus (Post 2567298)
Premix at 4 oz per tank is not enough to do anything helpful (especially given that you are FI'd) in my opinion .
If your MOP was playing up then there is a posibility that premix was the only lubrication you were getting at times so lack of lubrication does sound like the likely cause .
have a look at the oil delivery lines - are there any bubbles in the lines ?

So with all that pre mix in there, what do your map readings read like? VS no pre mix?

Brettus 07-27-2008 05:02 AM

do you mean my A/F ratios ?
I'm not sure what difference premix makes but I don't think it is significant .

AJ's Shinka 07-27-2008 09:46 PM

This is a sad day for all 4-port AT's. I used to brag to everyone that I knew someone with a badass FI'd Tiptronic RX8 that killed Porches on the track. I hope it comes back better than ever.

flip 07-28-2008 06:26 PM

:( me sad too...

olddragger 08-02-2008 07:00 PM

any news Phil? I just added a second radiator -i will send you what i did if that could be of use to ya. you are in a different worls.
od

nycgps 08-02-2008 07:11 PM


Originally Posted by Phil's 8 (Post 2567722)
It was inconsistent before the AP.
I would have a problem with the smog cops if I tried burning more than 4oz per tank. It smokes too much. Already tried increasing it and got stopped. Luckily he did not check for a cat but I had trouble explaining premix to him. The smog cops have no sense of humor.

thats strange. like any others. I premix as much as 12oz for a long while and I never notice any increased in smoke. hmm

I use Idemitsu.

Phil's 8 08-02-2008 11:14 PM


Originally Posted by olddragger (Post 2579269)
any news Phil? I just added a second radiator -i will send you what i did if that could be of use to ya. you are in a different worls.
od

I never hurts to have more information and tested alternatives. Send it on and lets see what you have done.


Originally Posted by nycgps (Post 2579291)
thats strange. like any others. I premix as much as 12oz for a long while and I never notice any increased in smoke. hmm

I use Idemitsu.

I too use Idenitsu but any mixture more than 6oz causes me to smoke excessivley. I tried the 2oz per gallon mix that olddragger mentioned and had lots of problems: excessive smoke and fouled plugs. I will not try that again.

olddragger 08-03-2008 09:01 PM

thanks for trying phil-- to me it doesnt sound good my friend,--at that ratio it may smoke a little but it should run ok and start ok and idle ok. actually should be smoother
are your coils ok?.
Ok this is what i have done. Summit racing has a trans cooler that is 21x7 x 1 1/2 inch deep. you can do a 2 inch recessed mounted from the bumper support -- i made some wrapped around hangers from 1 inch wide aluminum strips from Lowes. Drilled a hole for each mount through the bumper support. i supplied the cooler from the return heater hose. take that little oem restrictor out of the heater hose when you do this..
i opened up 2 more rows off the oem front grill also and i added a small fan (puller) to use during those fast food lines and bumper to bumper.
this puts about 2 more quarts of fluid into the system. limited testing has me on a 95F ambient 50 % humidity, with a/c on,no fans, during 30-45 mph driving, fast food stop and stop light to stop light--at 185F. oil is about the same. my temp did not rise during the fast food stop(it was not fast:). i did turn the small fan on for that. having had enough time with it yet but t this point i would have to say it is working for me.
olddragger

Phil's 8 08-04-2008 06:47 AM


Originally Posted by olddragger (Post 2580406)
thanks for trying phil-- to me it doesnt sound good my friend,--at that ratio it may smoke a little but it should run ok and start ok and idle ok. actually should be smoother
are your coils ok?.
Ok this is what i have done. Summit racing has a trans cooler that is 21x7 x 1 1/2 inch deep. you can do a 2 inch recessed mounted from the bumper support -- i made some wrapped around hangers from 1 inch wide aluminum strips from Lowes. Drilled a hole for each mount through the bumper support. i supplied the cooler from the return heater hose. take that little oem restrictor out of the heater hose when you do this..
i opened up 2 more rows off the oem front grill also and i added a small fan (puller) to use during those fast food lines and bumper to bumper.
this puts about 2 more quarts of fluid into the system. limited testing has me on a 95F ambient 50 % humidity, with a/c on,no fans, during 30-45 mph driving, fast food stop and stop light to stop light--at 185F. oil is about the same. my temp did not rise during the fast food stop(it was not fast:). i did turn the small fan on for that. having had enough time with it yet but t this point i would have to say it is working for me.
olddragger

Coils are new but will only be in there for another week or so. BHR coils should be ready for the rebuild.
I will pass this on to Ray. He's taking my 8 to Phoenix for the rebuild. He tells me that in 7-10 days he will have it complete and staying cooler.

olddragger 08-05-2008 10:07 AM

Good luck friend--please keep us informed
D

Phil's 8 08-11-2008 02:46 PM

We had a little meet in Vegas over the weekend and when Ray left he took my car for the rebuild. I have not yet heard if they made it in one piece or not (is no news good news?). I asked Ray and Jeff to post their findings on this thread - so lets see what happens.

MazdaManiac 08-11-2008 02:50 PM

Its sitting outside my house at the moment.

chickenwafer 08-11-2008 02:59 PM

So when is the rebuild happening? Be sure to let me know, Jeeph!

MazdaManiac 08-11-2008 03:17 PM

Dunno. Its up to Ray.

Easy_E1 08-11-2008 03:24 PM

Should be the beginning of next week from what I hear from Ray.
But hey what do I know. Just what I read in the papers.

RK 08-11-2008 03:28 PM


Originally Posted by Easy_E1 (Post 2592010)
Should be the beginning of next week from what I hear from Ray.
But hey what do I know. Just what I read in the papers.

Another episode of Live Reality TV from the garage of MazdaManiac?

Easy_E1 08-11-2008 03:36 PM

I'm thinking it will be from the garage of Charles R. Hill. But hey it could be at MM's.
I don't think we've decided on where yet.

MazdaManiac 08-11-2008 03:43 PM

There will be live video for sure.

Phil's 8 08-12-2008 10:20 AM

Well it made it in one piece. My understanding is that Ray's possessions will be in Arizona on Wednesday or Thursday. He has found his abode and giving him time to put boxes in all the rooms - he should start my car on Monday or so.

Brettus 08-12-2008 03:43 PM


Originally Posted by Charles R. Hill (Post 2593061)
The three of us spent a bit of time discussing the rebuild strategy last night .

Translation : sank a few cold ones .....

MazdaManiac 08-12-2008 03:51 PM

lol
Indeed.

heyarnold69 08-12-2008 03:53 PM

ill help here on my end by drinking until the statue of liberty takes her clothes off

09Factor 08-12-2008 05:17 PM


Originally Posted by Easy_E1 (Post 2592026)
I'm thinking it will be from the garage of Charles R. Hill. But hey it could be at MM's.
I don't think we've decided on where yet.

When you guys do decide to tear into it, make it a weekend Por favor.

MazdaManiac 08-12-2008 05:24 PM

Will, almost definitely, be during the week.
There simply isn't any time on the weekends.

olddragger 08-12-2008 06:16 PM

adding additional radiator? Dont forget to take the restrictor out of that heater hose, get a 180F aftermarket therm high flow like miloderm--drill 3 holes in it THEN block off the bypass. you will be happier. may need extra oil cooler also or upgrade. you can move the fogs and move the oil coolers over. just talking here guys.
coat the exhaust ports?
phenolic intake spacer for lower intake while you are at it?
water meth system double port!!!
fin your oil pan with cool fins--dont laugh--well--allright laugh-- then look it up.
doing the oil pill mod?
hell just drop a six port engine in!!!
olddragger

Easy_E1 08-12-2008 06:22 PM


Originally Posted by Brettus (Post 2593458)
Translation : sank a few cold ones .....

Was that you peeking over the wall? :uhh:

MazdaManiac 08-12-2008 06:24 PM


Originally Posted by olddragger (Post 2593665)
Dont forget to take the restrictor out of that heater hose

You don't want to do this.

Unless you intend to use the HVAC system as an additional cooling circuit, taking the restrictor pill out will just result in less cooling efficiency because you are reducing the flow through the rad.

tajabaho1 08-12-2008 06:27 PM

you know, take a measure from the honda guys? 2 radiators? stacked? would be a good option

Jedi54 08-12-2008 06:28 PM

oh man, NOW Phil's car is doomed. Taj is making recommendations....

;)

MazdaManiac 08-12-2008 06:28 PM


Originally Posted by tajabaho1 (Post 2593686)
you know, take a measure from the honda guys? 2 radiators? stacked? would be a good option

Already did that.

tajabaho1 08-12-2008 06:34 PM

^ pics? pls?

when can you come to CA? I'm ordering the AFR gauge from Ray tmr yo pls come tune my car:? kkthxbye


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:10 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands