Value of a 77k 2004 with bad compression?
03-12-2014, 01:37 PM
#1
Value of a 77k 2004 with bad compression?
Got some bad news today my daughters 2004 Grand Touring 6speed has low compression and the dealer suggests replacing the engine. The quote is $5400 to do this. The car has 77k miles, silver/red interior, new tires, good overall condition.
From what I can tell the book on this car is maybe $7500.
Need some advice from the you experts which direction to take.
1. Do I repair the car?
2. Do I fire sale it and put the proceeds and the $5400 into something else?
3. Part out the car?
4. Any other suggestions would be appreciated.
Give me the good the bad and the ugly.
Thanks in advance.
Z
From what I can tell the book on this car is maybe $7500.
Need some advice from the you experts which direction to take.
1. Do I repair the car?
2. Do I fire sale it and put the proceeds and the $5400 into something else?
3. Part out the car?
4. Any other suggestions would be appreciated.
Give me the good the bad and the ugly.
Thanks in advance.
Z
03-12-2014, 01:39 PM
#2
Registered
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 16,684
Likes: 0
Received 239 Likes
on
109 Posts
Essentially the same question asked here yesterday: https://www.rx8club.com/purchasing-f...d-tips-251631/
You can do better on the dealer's quote. Under $4,000 is entirely doable, under $3,000 is possible.
A 2004 with a dead engine is typically worth $2,000 or less. Sorry 
Generally, working backwards, a 2004 with a brand new engine and everything else in good shape is worth $6,000-$7,000. So subtract the cost of a replacement engine for the buyer, and you land in the $1,500-$2,500 range. You would be able to get the most amount of money out of the car if you parted it out, and you just might be able to get that $5k number. It is going to take time and work to do that, plus space and tolerant friends/family.
Generally, working backwards, a 2004 with a brand new engine and everything else in good shape is worth $6,000-$7,000. So subtract the cost of a replacement engine for the buyer, and you land in the $1,500-$2,500 range. You would be able to get the most amount of money out of the car if you parted it out, and you just might be able to get that $5k number. It is going to take time and work to do that, plus space and tolerant friends/family.
You can do better on the dealer's quote. Under $4,000 is entirely doable, under $3,000 is possible.
03-12-2014, 05:10 PM
#5
Rotary Evolution
$3k+ still isn't out of the realm of possibility. anything that cheap and relative age of the car people are going to drop figures until you get one that sticks. the last 8 i picked up with a bad engine i paid $2900(he added in the free tow) with more miles than that and he already had offers of that same price. except i actually diagnosed it on the spot and told him the engine was 99% toast, verified later as a spun rotor bearing causing the rotor to touch the housing(an audible knock, which is extremely rare for a rotary engine).
for me i guess i don't mind paying a few extra bucks to be first in line, since i can probably repair it for less than $1k in parts not including labor and resell it for ~$7k. other generic mechanics will try the same, except most will be in too deep once they realize the engine does need to come apart or be replaced with the still rather expensive/questionable used ones available($1500 for a used renesis with no guarantee is ridiculous, putting it lightly).
basically what i'm saying is while RIWWP is close he isn't 100% on with the figures, because once you go that low the scavengers will hike up the price to a small degree. so a $1500 figure would be a giveaway fire sale price if you needed money within hours, the title is salvaged or the car needs other substantial work. $2500 is usually bargain basement price but sometimes you can get it, less than that and i'd feel too guilty to pay so little if the car is in decent shape.
for me i guess i don't mind paying a few extra bucks to be first in line, since i can probably repair it for less than $1k in parts not including labor and resell it for ~$7k. other generic mechanics will try the same, except most will be in too deep once they realize the engine does need to come apart or be replaced with the still rather expensive/questionable used ones available($1500 for a used renesis with no guarantee is ridiculous, putting it lightly).
basically what i'm saying is while RIWWP is close he isn't 100% on with the figures, because once you go that low the scavengers will hike up the price to a small degree. so a $1500 figure would be a giveaway fire sale price if you needed money within hours, the title is salvaged or the car needs other substantial work. $2500 is usually bargain basement price but sometimes you can get it, less than that and i'd feel too guilty to pay so little if the car is in decent shape.
Last edited by Karack; 03-12-2014 at 05:49 PM.
03-14-2014, 01:19 PM
#6
Registered
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I paid 2950 for my 04 with a "bad" engine. 117k. I had planned to send out the engine for a rebuild, pulling and installing myself. If you don't have the tools or space to pull it yourself, labor would most likely push the cost over the value of the car.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post