Just here for research
#7
RX-Heaven
iTrader: (6)
At the end of the day it's your car and you do with it what you want. It's not a swap I would ever do as I am a rotary purist, but it is a swap that people have done and seem to like doing. Best of luck with your project!
#8
What am I doing here?
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: 2017 Miata RF Launch Edition
Posts: 3,606
Received 649 Likes
on
510 Posts
The whole car is the excellent chassis which is pretty completely let down by the motor.
#9
Registered
Last edited by CaymanRotary; 01-21-2020 at 08:31 AM.
#10
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Have you driven one?
I haven't an 8, but I have a V8 Miata and it was fine. It might have lost a bit of subtlety, but it was still predictable.
Since our cars are basically stretch Miatas, we should be able to do just as well.
Obviously if someone swaps the engine and nothing else, there will not be success, but if you approach it as an engineering project and design the appropriate shock/spring to handle the weight distribution change, there's no reason it shouldn't approximate original handling with far more power for a net faster car.
I haven't an 8, but I have a V8 Miata and it was fine. It might have lost a bit of subtlety, but it was still predictable.
Since our cars are basically stretch Miatas, we should be able to do just as well.
Obviously if someone swaps the engine and nothing else, there will not be success, but if you approach it as an engineering project and design the appropriate shock/spring to handle the weight distribution change, there's no reason it shouldn't approximate original handling with far more power for a net faster car.
#11
Registered
#12
Registered
Have you driven one?
I haven't an 8, but I have a V8 Miata and it was fine. It might have lost a bit of subtlety, but it was still predictable.
Since our cars are basically stretch Miatas, we should be able to do just as well.
Obviously if someone swaps the engine and nothing else, there will not be success, but if you approach it as an engineering project and design the appropriate shock/spring to handle the weight distribution change, there's no reason it shouldn't approximate original handling with far more power for a net faster car.
I haven't an 8, but I have a V8 Miata and it was fine. It might have lost a bit of subtlety, but it was still predictable.
Since our cars are basically stretch Miatas, we should be able to do just as well.
Obviously if someone swaps the engine and nothing else, there will not be success, but if you approach it as an engineering project and design the appropriate shock/spring to handle the weight distribution change, there's no reason it shouldn't approximate original handling with far more power for a net faster car.
edit: coming back to this, you mentioned the other issue with a swap like this. The amount of money and time to source parts simply to accommodate the engine. You would need to swap out so much stuff the time and effort it took you could have just bought something already good to go. I'll just never see the sense in it I suppose. Yea, its cool and you get a unique car out of the deal but that's about it.
Last edited by CaymanRotary; 01-21-2020 at 11:37 AM.
#13
Registered
Sometimes the project is so interesting to the person doing it that it's worth whatever effort and pitfalls might be involved. Cayman, I'm a bit in your camp, just don't have the time, and to be honest the skills, for huge projects. But, I keep my sanity with smaller ones. I have a friend that just completed a Duramax install in a Hummer. The amount of work is huge, he did a body off frame sandblast and paint, so much engine bay and drivetrain work. But, at the end of it he has a super cool truck that only a very few people have done, so for him it's well worth it.
#14
Registered
Sometimes the project is so interesting to the person doing it that it's worth whatever effort and pitfalls might be involved. Cayman, I'm a bit in your camp, just don't have the time, and to be honest the skills, for huge projects. But, I keep my sanity with smaller ones. I have a friend that just completed a Duramax install in a Hummer. The amount of work is huge, he did a body off frame sandblast and paint, so much engine bay and drivetrain work. But, at the end of it he has a super cool truck that only a very few people have done, so for him it's well worth it.
#15
I put an LS1 into a Porsche 968 and the balance was about the same as the 3 litre. The same swap into the RX 8 will really change balance as it will add about 100 lbs and that weight will have to come forward somewhat to allow the valve covers to clear the firewall, on the 968 I had a hell of a time getting headers to fit, especially around the steering shaft. After several tries and a lot of scrap SS tube I got custom headers from Kooks. They look so good it’s almost a waste as theyre hidden deep in the hole.
The power is going to come on differently from what the chassis is designed for too. Huge gobs of torque starting at 2200 rpm up through to 4000 rpm is going to want to twist it into pretzel and for openers the spring rates will need to bump up hugely. Likely 450lb up front and 600 at back. It will be a totally different machine.
Id look to swap in a BMW N series engine as theyre a compact inline 6, very light and friendly to FI. Also readily available. The difficulty with all these swaps though is the ECUs.
The power is going to come on differently from what the chassis is designed for too. Huge gobs of torque starting at 2200 rpm up through to 4000 rpm is going to want to twist it into pretzel and for openers the spring rates will need to bump up hugely. Likely 450lb up front and 600 at back. It will be a totally different machine.
Id look to swap in a BMW N series engine as theyre a compact inline 6, very light and friendly to FI. Also readily available. The difficulty with all these swaps though is the ECUs.
Last edited by JimV8; 01-21-2020 at 12:13 PM.
The following users liked this post:
CaymanRotary (01-21-2020)
#16
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Yeah of course buying a vette or even new Camarro or Mustang would be more cost-effective, especially given how they keep value. At the same time, rotary ownership is rarely the product of sound budgetary decisions
I mean yes you have to drive it differently, but torque is a function of your right foot and rear tire, you can manage it on the fly. With a V8 power deliver is linear and predictable.
All depends on what the owner wants to do with it.
I mean yes you have to drive it differently, but torque is a function of your right foot and rear tire, you can manage it on the fly. With a V8 power deliver is linear and predictable.
All depends on what the owner wants to do with it.
The following users liked this post:
mazdaverx7 (01-22-2020)
#19
Not to many coupes support room for four, a rigid chassis, decent factory suspension geometry and a curb weight <3k.
In a performance car, you want the power plant to have character. However in this example the character comes with some durability and design issues.
The following users liked this post:
CaymanRotary (01-21-2020)
#20
Registered
If I was buying the car strictly for torque and acceleration, I wouldn't have bought an RX-8. I believe my 2500HD crew cab Duramax truck will best the RX-8 0-60, and my 5.7 Durango will also beat it I think. But the overall experience of the rotary, the quick smooth revs and power coming on above 5000 rpm, coupled with the handling makes this car extremely satisfying for me. Sure, 400 HP would be nice, but that's just not what it is. From point A to point B on a curvy road it will beat the other 2 vehicles and I'll have time to eat a PB&J sandwich before they finally arrive!
#21
Registered
This is closer to where I am.
Not to many coupes support room for four, a rigid chassis, decent factory suspension geometry and a curb weight <3k.
In a performance car, you want the power plant to have character. However in this example the character comes with some durability and design issues.
Not to many coupes support room for four, a rigid chassis, decent factory suspension geometry and a curb weight <3k.
In a performance car, you want the power plant to have character. However in this example the character comes with some durability and design issues.
#22
I don't think anyone can disagree that the Renesis was an underwhelming engine. If Mazda had made it 300hp with a small turbo, using a lower compression rotor design and better exhaust porting it would have been near perfect. Just a bit more juice and the RX8 would have been an instant classic car imo.
I know its not a rotary but what about the MZR engine that came the in Speed 3 and 6. 270 hp and 270 tq??? Not too bad plus its already in the stable.
#23
I don't think anyone can disagree that the Renesis was an underwhelming engine. If Mazda had made it 300hp with a small turbo, using a lower compression rotor design and better exhaust porting it would have been near perfect. Just a bit more juice and the RX8 would have been an instant classic car imo.
#25
I'm thinking an aluminum 5.3 engine (L33 code) so I can keep the weight a little less in the front, adding at least a roll bar/half cage to put some weight in the rear, and maximizing tire size on the front and rear before any trimming or more custom Fab parts need to be made to fit wider stuff
I basically want Corvette handling and performance but without the high insurance rate of the Corvette