View Full Version : Megasquirt 3 on rx-8
Brandonien 10-13-2010, 04:04 AM I'm looking for ANY AND ALL links to .msq files, wiring info, work arounds, anything usefull....
Also looking for someone with experience to help make a fairly well laid out guide to setting up a MS3 on the renesis, please and thx!!! ^_^
(ONLY LOOKING FOR REPLIES THAT WILL HELP WITH THE PROGRESS OF THIS PROJECT, NO CRITICISM OR RANDOM COMMENTS *unless it's praise :P*)
Will be starting this project in mid to late November and I'm trying to build my knowledge on this AS MUCH as possible before hand.
PS. 2005 grey 6spd manual
Brandonien 10-13-2010, 04:12 AM cars stock, except I`m looking at a ignition coil amplifier (2 stage) for stronger sparks and my cat is hollow if that makes any different, I`m mainly doing this because I know I will be switching my engine for the 16x when it`s released and I want to start preparing by ditching the stock ecu and learning how these systems work before I go and drop a brand new engine in it...
dannobre 10-13-2010, 10:54 AM Are you planning on using the stock trigger wheel...or going with a different trigger wheel?
Brandonien 10-14-2010, 12:33 AM the trigger wheel is 36-2-2-2 to my understanding (*rotarygod had a thread on this*) however in MS3 36-2-2-2 is an option now so I should be able to use the stock trigger wheel
Brandonien 10-14-2010, 12:35 AM the problem I keep coming accross is the throttle body since MS3 doesn't support drive by wire I need to find a suitable replacement for that..
You can buy a throttle body from a pro formula Mazda car, star race cars I believe. Then a second gen rx7 pedal with cable, fits very nicely. You need to fab a bracket for the cable, I had mine done for me and it looks oem. The throttle body comes with the tps.
Brandonien 10-15-2010, 02:39 AM That site is amazing! Thx, I wish I'd known about it MUCH earlier!
TeamRX8 10-15-2010, 05:28 AM How are you planning to control the APV function?
bse50 10-15-2010, 05:33 AM cars stock, except I`m looking at a ignition coil amplifier (2 stage) for stronger sparks and my cat is hollow if that makes any different, I`m mainly doing this because I know I will be switching my engine for the 16x when it`s released and I want to start preparing by ditching the stock ecu and learning how these systems work before I go and drop a brand new engine in it...
Why didn't you buy an ECU that supports direct injection then?
Brandonien 10-16-2010, 01:13 PM O.o I'm fairly sure megasquirt 3 does support direct injection and I haven't bought it yet! :P which is why I posted this thread, to find out all of the things I may need to work around ^_^
bse50 10-16-2010, 01:22 PM In the end they're still injectors so you're right :)
I was just pointing out that getting an ecu before even knowing the future engine's specs may be overkill! The new megasquirt looks like a fun tool though, swap or not if all you want to do is having fun programming it then why not?
Isn't it better to get an accessport though and download the free tuning application to get started? MazdaManiac's web seminars are a good specific starting point too!
TeamRX8 10-16-2010, 02:23 PM This exercise in pointless foolishness might be better appreciated on the MS3 forum ....
Brandonien 10-17-2010, 12:30 AM I'm actually ordering the accessport right now, and the MS3 will be piggybacking the stock ecu since it won't try to change the maps after the AP gets at it! :P later in the year I'm switching my fuel lines, pump, and injectors and adding a flex fuel alcohol sensor, so the MS3 will take over when it detects anything other then normal fuel ^_^ this engine is like my test bed for tuning before the 16x gets released (*because I'm DEFINATELY swapping engines when that comes out >: ] *) PS. decided to keep the stock ecu in as well, my initial concern was not being able to piggyback it and then I was told to research the AP
sblethen 10-17-2010, 10:52 AM This exercise in pointless foolishness might be better appreciated on the MS3 forum ....
Please keep posting here! I find it interesting but I don't want to join a million forums. I am now subscribed to this thread and I would love to here what you need to do, and what challenges you face while exploring the application of the ms3 on the rx8.
Stephen
PS: if you start a thread elsewhere specific to the ms3 (and the rx8) please share it here. Thanks!
TeamRX8 10-17-2010, 11:23 AM Why be fixated on an MS3 when it's not the right choice from the start?
Even if we ignore the 16x BS and "I'll buy one some day" dreamer fantasies the fact that you've chosen an efi system without doing the basic research first is an automatic fail.
sblethen 10-17-2010, 12:29 PM Why be fixated on an MS3 when it's not the right choice from the start?
Even if we ignore the 16x BS and "I'll buy one some day" dreamer fantasies the fact that you've chosen an efi system without doing the basic research first is an automatic fail.
What are you using?
What have you tested?
What are your dyno results?
I am keeping my stock engine based on the ruleset of the class I am racing in. ECU and everything that goes with it for sensors (other than injectors and throttle body) is "free" to change per the rules as written. Most people that race are using the megasquirt system or the motec. I am open to both and megasquirt "if it will work) is significantly cheaper. If it yeilds 5hp and better tourque its probably investmentfew thousand $$ investment. (For me anyway) the motec is about 10k!
Stephen
Brandonien 10-18-2010, 07:48 AM Well at the moment I'm in Afghanistan, So if your going to tell me the money I'm putting aside EVERY paycheck for that engine is BS then please don't post on this thread, cause I don't feel like having someone tell me that the work I do in the INFANTRY doesn't pay well enough to fund my ideas. And really... IS PLANNING AHEAD A BAD THING, this thread is for MY RESEARCH, if I deem it's not worth my time I'll stop but as of yet theres nothing to prove it's not a worthwhile project..
Brandonien 10-18-2010, 08:54 AM sorry to be rash but I don't much appreciate you telling me my ideas are childish or bs
also I haven't bought this system as of yet, so yeah I should have researched other systems, however I have a friend who uses MS2 on his fi neon and has shown me the basics of the program and some of the features its capable of, so considering I don't want to spend 10K on an ems unless I have too and the low cost of this system even if it turns out to be a failed project I will be down less then 1K so I'm not too concerned
Brandonien 10-18-2010, 08:57 AM all in all it will be an interesting experiment
and I'm not going forced induction right now because I would rather save that money for the new engine, and all the fun times that will be had trying to get that to work in an 8... (*haha*) I guess you could say the 13b is my learning platform for tuning so I have a base when I do start dropping money on the bigger things
Brandonien 10-18-2010, 09:01 AM you say I'll buy one someday fantasies, gee maybe the reason I HAVEN'T is because it's not out yet! (*light bulb appears above head*) how arrogant can you be!
sblethen 10-19-2010, 12:17 AM I assume your talking about teamrx8 and not me. I honestly am interested in your findings. I race against several people using the megasquirt system but I know nothing about it and I was thinking the motec was my only option. I am starting to read up on this type of stuff.
And don't let post addicts get to you... I ignore them. In reality a post addict can't help it (honestly) and will post something rather than just move on to something they are more interested in.
Stephen
Brandonien 10-19-2010, 01:31 AM good point, ^_^ unfortunately this will be a slow moving project as I'm about to get my hands on an accessport and plan to find it's limitations before I start wih the MS, however as winter comes to an end this year you'll start to see some actual progress :P figure I'll take the winter and plan my attack of wiring and make sure I have everything I need
Salamanth 10-26-2010, 06:49 PM Bradonien, what team is saying does have some merit.
You seem to be jumping into this half-cocked without doing much research... for example, ignition amplifiers are nigh-on worthless on our cars, and in fact, cause more problems than they solve.
A hollowed out cat most certainly does make a difference as well.
These are basic facts anyone should know before starting on a project of this magnitude.
My personal advice would be to buy an FC (they can be had rather cheaply these days) and swap that over to a megasquirt if you want something to play with. It is not a project I would want to undertake on an RX-8.
This advice is coming from someone who is currently 'squirting a turbo 2 swap done into an FC vert.
However, if you choose to continue down this path, though I and others think it's foolish, there is a wealth of information to be had on the rx7club forums in the megasquirt ECU section. In addition there is a lot of info over on aaroncake concerning the MS2.
http://aaroncake.net/RX-7/megasquirt/index.asp
There are many things to consider:
- How will you handle the piggybacking of the stock ECU and the MS3(X)
- How are you going to deal with the fact that the stock renesis has 6 injectors that it stages and the MS3X only supports primaries and secondaries in staged mode
- How are you going to control the APVs
- How are you going to control the oil metering pump
I have answers to some of these questions, however (as asshole as this may sound) I want to know what your thoughts are, if you've even considered these.
I would encourage you to stay on this path, just be aware of the challenges you are likely to face and know the limitations of your knowledge if you're determined to continue.
TeamRX8 10-26-2010, 06:53 PM Ahhhhhh, the sweet sound of reason ..... :)
Brandonien 10-27-2010, 07:02 AM Hey SWEET! Someone finally presents some encouragement :P Anywho Yes:
-I will be using a wiring harness as per RG's thread for all my splicing to make a clean and convenient setup that allows room for error..
-primaries on one stage, and the remaining four on the second stage, it's been done and works
-well I was thinking of mixing oil in with my gas initially although I would like to use a mechanical OMP once I research it a little more...
-throttle body issue is sorted out as I plan on using a gm tps and tucking my stock tb away somewhere
-and since both secondary and auxiliary injectors will be going at the same time, so will the apv
I know this is going to be a steep learning curve but I've got nothing but time for it, I also figured I would play with the 13b-msp before I go and F*** up a brand new 16x engine... only problem I can see with switching from one to the other on the MS3 setup will be the trigger wheel and the injector and spark timing since it will be a DFI engine... but I guess that means I'll just have to wait out till then... Still getting it regardless since I can use e85 with MS :P
Brandonien 10-27-2010, 07:09 AM and yeah hollowing out my cat was one of my first modifications... in reaction to melting half of it though, it seems reasonable *shrugs*
also Ignition amps got canned, I will be using Okada Projects Direct plasma coils instead, probably should have fixed that part of my post sooner..
bse50 10-27-2010, 07:19 AM Okada coils are a waste of money. Either go with BHR's system or stay stock ;)
Flashwing 10-27-2010, 07:20 AM I think you could benefit from looking at currently used and supported ignition mods rather than stuff that has been shown to be over priced and not provide the benefits necessary.
TeamRX8 10-27-2010, 09:49 PM apparently you haven't tested a set ....
MazdaManiac 10-27-2010, 09:55 PM apparently you haven't tested a set ....
Had a set here for a few months a few years ago. They are, essentially, the same current output as stock coils, but with a shorter discharge time.
Brandonien 10-28-2010, 01:32 AM hmmm! DEBATE :P Ok so I will look up the BHR system, although I would like to here MM's points on the Okada coils if possible, and TeamRX8's points on BHR...
First hand experience is always good to hear about as opposed to reviews where everything sounds awesome...
mperformance 10-28-2010, 02:14 AM Hello! I have an FC turbo II with megasquirt. I also would suggest having some before hand practice on another rotary. The fact that there are so many more parameters to control on the rx-8 will make your learning curve much more longer.
The RX8 intake system is much more complex. Now my words of encouragements are that I am certain that it can be done (megasquirting the renesis) so that most of the functionalities or systems will work accordingly.
Now, unless you manage to improve over the design of the intake or the fuel curves I dont see a benefit for using and aftermarket ECU on the renesis. I would personally do this if I was to turbo the renesis or do something more aggressive. I am currently installing a P2000 haltech in a 13BEW powered rx-8 which will be a nice challenge because there are still many "functions" that need to be addressed.
I say keep posting your comments here, but I can assure this is no easy task and you will not find too many answers. For stand alone rotary support you also have to remember that you need to consider trailing ignition and staged fuel parameters. Not a lot of tuners are capable of doing this, you will be on your own once you have the basics done as far as the installation. If its a piggyback installation there is really no point in doing this, a reflash is much more productive.
Brandonien 10-29-2010, 01:30 AM well it's a play ground for future mods, FI will be done MUCH later... :P I wanna get my new engine before I worry about FI and I'll use this engine for practice so it'll go smoothly while tuning for the new engine, or smoother anyways, as I'm sure it's going to be VERY different from the renesis, although it'll also be usefull for an e85 setup since MS can use a flex fuel sensor :P
warwickben 03-04-2012, 07:30 PM I've been looking in to this . So will ms3 control rx8spark? With stock crank wheel.
All you need to do is run it pararell.
Ms just dose fuel and spark all the other stuff will work the same.
|