Rotor Balance Test vs Compression Test
Rotor Balance Test vs Compression Test
I'm preparing to purchase an 8 sometime this spring, after I graduate and start my full-time in 4 weeks. I've been looking into local costs of things like rebuilds and compression tests.
I found a credible rebuilder in Toronto, and I'm about 45 minutes out of the city, so worst case scenario I can get it done there at an estimated $3,200 with reusable core.
I was also looking into compression tests, and this is where I had a question. I contacted Budds Mazda (Budds is a well regarded dealer around here, they have Mercedez, Jaguar, Mini, BMW, and other lots). When I contacted them regarding a compression test, I was told
"With the rotary engine we would do what is called a rotor balance test as opposed to a compression test – the cost would be $199.95 + tax and would take about 2 – 2.5 hours to complete."
I've never heard of a rotor balance test, I'm assuming that this will only catch things like misfires or something that might be off-balance. I don't see this helping determine engine health like a compression test would, though.
Has anyone heard of a rotor balance test?
I found a credible rebuilder in Toronto, and I'm about 45 minutes out of the city, so worst case scenario I can get it done there at an estimated $3,200 with reusable core.
I was also looking into compression tests, and this is where I had a question. I contacted Budds Mazda (Budds is a well regarded dealer around here, they have Mercedez, Jaguar, Mini, BMW, and other lots). When I contacted them regarding a compression test, I was told
"With the rotary engine we would do what is called a rotor balance test as opposed to a compression test – the cost would be $199.95 + tax and would take about 2 – 2.5 hours to complete."
I've never heard of a rotor balance test, I'm assuming that this will only catch things like misfires or something that might be off-balance. I don't see this helping determine engine health like a compression test would, though.
Has anyone heard of a rotor balance test?
I sort of got that feeling 
I think there are one or two more Mazda dealers within a reasonable distance, although that one was likely the largest of the bunch.
What does the rotor balance test really check? Does it offer any kind of benefit

I think there are one or two more Mazda dealers within a reasonable distance, although that one was likely the largest of the bunch.
What does the rotor balance test really check? Does it offer any kind of benefit
If by the "balance test" they mean 3 numbers on each rotor at a given rpm, then that should be ok. Maybe they are referring to the allowable differences between chambers and sides as "balance". It is called out in the service manual.
i think they just have a fancy way of saying compression test
Yep, by someone who doesn't know what they're talking about to someone they think won't know any better
Welcome to the typical Mazda service center ...
Rotor balance test? maybe they are talking about the rotor @ the braking system ? 
ok, run away, as fast as you CAN.
hell, someone should call that stealerSHIT up just to humiliate them.
sad ... and that's coming from a Mazda dealer ... Rotary Engine (Mazda corporate) should say "thanks! *******!" ...

ok, run away, as fast as you CAN.
hell, someone should call that stealerSHIT up just to humiliate them.
sad ... and that's coming from a Mazda dealer ... Rotary Engine (Mazda corporate) should say "thanks! *******!" ...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
gwailo
New Member Forum
38
May 14, 2024 06:57 AM




