The Best Oil Money Can Buy
04-05-2008, 06:28 PM
#76
road warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Oakland and Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 1,861
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Next time I change my transmission oil, I'm thinking about perhaps going to a mineral oil formulation as we don't seem to have a ton of luck with the synthetics. Does anyone have any experience using the conventional mineral oil gear lubes?
Also, what about Synchromesh oils? We seem to be having issues with the synchros spinning up to speed and Synchromesh would seem to be just the ticket to solve that. Perhaps a half or full quart cocktail mixed into our gear oil would be a solution?
Also, what about Synchromesh oils? We seem to be having issues with the synchros spinning up to speed and Synchromesh would seem to be just the ticket to solve that. Perhaps a half or full quart cocktail mixed into our gear oil would be a solution?
04-06-2008, 02:11 AM
#79
Next time I change my transmission oil, I'm thinking about perhaps going to a mineral oil formulation as we don't seem to have a ton of luck with the synthetics. Does anyone have any experience using the conventional mineral oil gear lubes?
Also, what about Synchromesh oils? We seem to be having issues with the synchros spinning up to speed and Synchromesh would seem to be just the ticket to solve that. Perhaps a half or full quart cocktail mixed into our gear oil would be a solution?
Also, what about Synchromesh oils? We seem to be having issues with the synchros spinning up to speed and Synchromesh would seem to be just the ticket to solve that. Perhaps a half or full quart cocktail mixed into our gear oil would be a solution?
04-06-2008, 02:19 AM
#80
Metatron
iTrader: (1)
I used MT-90 as my first oil change and the shift quality went right out the window - slow like mollasses in January.
Mixed about 1/3rd 'MTL' with the 90 weight for a silky smooth shift.
I hear the RP and Syncro stuff is a little thinner, right out of the bottle......
S
Mixed about 1/3rd 'MTL' with the 90 weight for a silky smooth shift.
I hear the RP and Syncro stuff is a little thinner, right out of the bottle......
S
04-06-2008, 08:25 AM
#82
Rex8
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My favorite oil.......
My favorite oil, now don't beat me up over this, take it in the spirit in which it was meant. My favorite oil is, are you ready for this ??????? Here goes...................................Extra Virgin Olive Oil. ( pun intended )
04-06-2008, 01:26 PM
#85
I have no plans to ever use maxgear in my transmission again. Maxgear is still in my diff however.
04-06-2008, 11:02 PM
#86
road warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Oakland and Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 1,861
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
RP Max Gear 75w90 is a GL5. It worked great for a while. However after a while each time I changed transmission fluids the issues with 3-4 upshift grinding at high rpms got gradually worse till my transmission was replaced by Mazda. By that time, it would grind anywhere around 4.8k rpm. When the issues first started, it was intermittent at close to 7k rpms.
I have no plans to ever use maxgear in my transmission again. Maxgear is still in my diff however.
I have no plans to ever use maxgear in my transmission again. Maxgear is still in my diff however.
04-06-2008, 11:09 PM
#87
Registered
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Florida
Posts: 703
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yeah, when I did my first change at around 50k miles, using MT-90 really didn't improve things over the old oem fluid. Going to probably go a 50/50 mix of MT-90/MTL next time.
04-07-2008, 02:06 AM
#88
Registered
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: California
Posts: 416
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If i take my 8 to the track about 7~9 days a year (probably every other month or so), and wanting to stick with amsoil, what do you recommend, jax_rx8?
according to teamrx8's previous post in this thread, using a 50/50 mix doesn't seem like a good idea if i'm pushing the car at the track. I'm not racing like he is, but i know track days can be hard on the car.
i'm guessing, amsoil svg(gl-5) for the rear diff. and mtg(gl-4) for the trans?
according to teamrx8's previous post in this thread, using a 50/50 mix doesn't seem like a good idea if i'm pushing the car at the track. I'm not racing like he is, but i know track days can be hard on the car.
i'm guessing, amsoil svg(gl-5) for the rear diff. and mtg(gl-4) for the trans?
AMSOIL Severe Gear is a GL-5 lubricant that is great for your rear diff - and will absolutely, over time kill the syncros in your trans.
For your trans, you want AMSOIL MTG (Assuming you want to use AMSOIL products)
http://www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/mtg.aspx
or for better shifting, you can mix 50/50 with AMSOIL MTL
http://www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/mtf.aspx
As for your other question on trans fluids, Charles is right in that GL-5 fluids do not have the right "grabbiness" (a technical term) for syncros to work efficiently - they do tend to be too slick as they have many Friction Modifiers (FMs) in addition to the EP additives.
But the real issue with GL-5 fluids in a trans with syncros is that syncros use softer metals and GL-5 fluids have way too much Extreme Pressure (EP) additives that actually wear out these softer metals over time, reducing the ability of your syncros to function properly until they just eventually fail.
GL-4 fluids, like the ones I linked above, have some EP adds, but tend to be formulated for the "right" friction for the syncros to work properly and also have much less EP additives (usually different ones as well) to keep from prematurely wearing out the syncro soft metals.
Also, there are many GL4/GL5 combo fluids, like RPs Max Gear, BG Ultraguard, etc, etc, that claim to work in manual trans and diffs. Some use and seem to have successwith these fluids in manual transmissions, but I would shy away from these combo fluids in a manual trans as they will still have too many EP and FM additives (which are required to meet the GL5 spec) for good syncro operation and wear - not all agree with this, but I would rather be safe than sorry as trans rebuilds are not cheap as most of our trans failures seem to be from the syncros failing (or being so slow in operation that we grind the trans gear teeth or break them off completely).
For your trans, you want AMSOIL MTG (Assuming you want to use AMSOIL products)
http://www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/mtg.aspx
or for better shifting, you can mix 50/50 with AMSOIL MTL
http://www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/mtf.aspx
As for your other question on trans fluids, Charles is right in that GL-5 fluids do not have the right "grabbiness" (a technical term) for syncros to work efficiently - they do tend to be too slick as they have many Friction Modifiers (FMs) in addition to the EP additives.
But the real issue with GL-5 fluids in a trans with syncros is that syncros use softer metals and GL-5 fluids have way too much Extreme Pressure (EP) additives that actually wear out these softer metals over time, reducing the ability of your syncros to function properly until they just eventually fail.
GL-4 fluids, like the ones I linked above, have some EP adds, but tend to be formulated for the "right" friction for the syncros to work properly and also have much less EP additives (usually different ones as well) to keep from prematurely wearing out the syncro soft metals.
Also, there are many GL4/GL5 combo fluids, like RPs Max Gear, BG Ultraguard, etc, etc, that claim to work in manual trans and diffs. Some use and seem to have successwith these fluids in manual transmissions, but I would shy away from these combo fluids in a manual trans as they will still have too many EP and FM additives (which are required to meet the GL5 spec) for good syncro operation and wear - not all agree with this, but I would rather be safe than sorry as trans rebuilds are not cheap as most of our trans failures seem to be from the syncros failing (or being so slow in operation that we grind the trans gear teeth or break them off completely).
04-07-2008, 06:46 AM
#89
Got Another Rotary
If i take my 8 to the track about 7~9 days a year (probably every other month or so), and wanting to stick with amsoil, what do you recommend, jax_rx8?
according to teamrx8's previous post in this thread, using a 50/50 mix doesn't seem like a good idea if i'm pushing the car at the track. I'm not racing like he is, but i know track days can be hard on the car.
i'm guessing, amsoil svg(gl-5) for the rear diff. and mtg(gl-4) for the trans?
according to teamrx8's previous post in this thread, using a 50/50 mix doesn't seem like a good idea if i'm pushing the car at the track. I'm not racing like he is, but i know track days can be hard on the car.
i'm guessing, amsoil svg(gl-5) for the rear diff. and mtg(gl-4) for the trans?
You could even consider AMSOILs Severe Gear 75W110 for the diff as well for that little extra protection (I assume you were referring to the 75W90), with your tracking and especially if you are in a warmer climate zone
04-07-2008, 09:14 AM
#90
RP Max Gear 75w90 is a GL5. It worked great for a while. However after a while each time I changed transmission fluids the issues with 3-4 upshift grinding at high rpms got gradually worse till my transmission was replaced by Mazda. By that time, it would grind anywhere around 4.8k rpm. When the issues first started, it was intermittent at close to 7k rpms.
I have no plans to ever use maxgear in my transmission again. Maxgear is still in my diff however.
I have no plans to ever use maxgear in my transmission again. Maxgear is still in my diff however.
Have been using RP Maxgear in my tranny since 5K miles
hmm ... but still I think I will try MT-90 b4 I go try Amsoil or anything else
04-07-2008, 09:17 AM
#91
no doubt the maxgear feels better / smoother than the stock oils. If you search my old posts under mysql101, you'll see I recommended maxgear for many years too.
The issues started up after ~20,000 miles with maxgear in the transmission. And it wasn't a constant thing, the grinding happened once in a while. Infrequent enough that I thought I wasn't clutching far enough. It's also interesting that with each oil change (I changed tranny fluids once a year) it seemed to get worse. Perhaps results would be different if I only changed the oil once every 50k miles.
My personal recommendation is to switch to something else ASAP.
Last edited by mysql; 04-07-2008 at 09:19 AM.
04-07-2008, 11:33 AM
#92
Got Another Rotary
no doubt the maxgear feels better / smoother than the stock oils. If you search my old posts under mysql101, you'll see I recommended maxgear for many years too.
The issues started up after ~20,000 miles with maxgear in the transmission. And it wasn't a constant thing, the grinding happened once in a while. Infrequent enough that I thought I wasn't clutching far enough. It's also interesting that with each oil change (I changed tranny fluids once a year) it seemed to get worse. Perhaps results would be different if I only changed the oil once every 50k miles.
My personal recommendation is to switch to something else ASAP.
The issues started up after ~20,000 miles with maxgear in the transmission. And it wasn't a constant thing, the grinding happened once in a while. Infrequent enough that I thought I wasn't clutching far enough. It's also interesting that with each oil change (I changed tranny fluids once a year) it seemed to get worse. Perhaps results would be different if I only changed the oil once every 50k miles.
My personal recommendation is to switch to something else ASAP.
This is the problem with GL5 or combo GL4/5 gear oil use - everything can seem fine for quite a long time as the additional wear to the syncros happen slowly, but surely.
By the time the symptoms start showing from the additional wear, it is too late and the damage is done. Then you are left with nursing the trans as far as you can until your eventual rebuild.
04-07-2008, 11:52 AM
#94
no doubt the maxgear feels better / smoother than the stock oils. If you search my old posts under mysql101, you'll see I recommended maxgear for many years too.
The issues started up after ~20,000 miles with maxgear in the transmission. And it wasn't a constant thing, the grinding happened once in a while. Infrequent enough that I thought I wasn't clutching far enough. It's also interesting that with each oil change (I changed tranny fluids once a year) it seemed to get worse. Perhaps results would be different if I only changed the oil once every 50k miles.
My personal recommendation is to switch to something else ASAP.
The issues started up after ~20,000 miles with maxgear in the transmission. And it wasn't a constant thing, the grinding happened once in a while. Infrequent enough that I thought I wasn't clutching far enough. It's also interesting that with each oil change (I changed tranny fluids once a year) it seemed to get worse. Perhaps results would be different if I only changed the oil once every 50k miles.
My personal recommendation is to switch to something else ASAP.
)I agree.
This is the problem with GL5 or combo GL4/5 gear oil use - everything can seem fine for quite a long time as the additional wear to the syncros happen slowly, but surely.
By the time the symptoms start showing from the additional wear, it is too late and the damage is done. Then you are left with nursing the trans as far as you can until your eventual rebuild.
This is the problem with GL5 or combo GL4/5 gear oil use - everything can seem fine for quite a long time as the additional wear to the syncros happen slowly, but surely.
By the time the symptoms start showing from the additional wear, it is too late and the damage is done. Then you are left with nursing the trans as far as you can until your eventual rebuild.
Ok, Im gonna change The tranny fluid out this wednesday to Pure MT-90. (I have to change my winter tires out + Autoexe Under brace in anyway
)Lets see how shitty the shifting will be lol
Last edited by nycgps; 04-07-2008 at 11:54 AM.
04-24-2008, 01:22 AM
#95
road warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Oakland and Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 1,861
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
The NB 6-speed guys seem to like the Motorcraft Full Synthetic Manual Transmission Fluid quite a lot. Since that tranny is a close cousin of ours, I'm wondering if it'll work well for us as well. It's very expensive though, but if it's a good cure it might be work it. Jax?
Thread here: http://forum.miata.net/vb/showthread.php?t=270393
Thread here: http://forum.miata.net/vb/showthread.php?t=270393
04-24-2008, 07:37 AM
#97
I'm using Redline Heavy Shockproof for the tranny. It has film thickness similar to a 75W250 grade, while providing the same low fluid friction as an SAE 75W90. Also, it looks like a strawberry smoothie. A couple of other members here uses the same thing and it feels great.
06-25-2008, 07:13 AM
#98
<3 Rotary
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This blows. After a while of silky smooth shifting with MT-90, it's starting to feel rather knobby and hard to shift.
**** this. I'll need to swap into something else as soon as I get back from my summer vacation.
I've read all the recommendations till now..., and quite frankly, it's left me more confused than before. Everyone has their own "trick" and "secret".
So do tell me if you think my new choice is gonna cause problems.
I'm going to try Redline MT-90 again, except this time I mix it 1/3 with MTL.
**** this. I'll need to swap into something else as soon as I get back from my summer vacation.
I've read all the recommendations till now..., and quite frankly, it's left me more confused than before. Everyone has their own "trick" and "secret".
So do tell me if you think my new choice is gonna cause problems.
I'm going to try Redline MT-90 again, except this time I mix it 1/3 with MTL.
06-25-2008, 07:36 AM
#99
Hummmmm...
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Brooklyn, NY
Posts: 979
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
^ won't be a problem.. I'm using about a 60/40 ratio MT-90 / MTL.. shifting is great.
Also, the first tranny change with a certain fluid is basically a rinse cycle- on the 2nd one you'll see most of the benefits
Also, the first tranny change with a certain fluid is basically a rinse cycle- on the 2nd one you'll see most of the benefits