RX8Club.com

RX8Club.com (https://www.rx8club.com/)
-   RX-8 Discussion (https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/)
-   -   The myth of the DSC OFF switch (https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/myth-dsc-off-switch-94230/)

NGTMRE 07-12-2006 09:08 PM

WOW, 6 pages of this stuff and you guys are still confused about it...

Who cares? Really!

Just drive the car. And if you want total control with no computer imput, just hold the button down for 7sec. or so and let her scream. End of story.

no abs, ebc, etc...

GOSH!

Paul_in_DC 07-12-2006 09:14 PM

Oy. This thread reminds me of a lousy math teacher I once had. I'd go into class understanding the material, but by the time he finished explaining, I didn't understand it any more.

I track and autox with the DSC switch off (1 sec). I haven't noticed any interference from "the system" at that setting. At my next autox I'll try it both ways and see what happens.

realdeal 07-12-2006 09:36 PM


Originally Posted by dillsrotary
one of the best things about this forum is when relatively new members post threads stating something that everyone else knows. Its obviously not a major offense but it does kinda piss people off, especially when the new member doesn't listen to the opinions of say the autox's who know the answer. Its like me running into an ER surgery and saying,"Hey assholes, you're doing it wrong."


This is EXACTLY how I felt reading the first post!!! :Eyecrazy:

r0tor 07-13-2006 06:47 AM


Originally Posted by Razz1
Funny thing I swear that when TCS is on I can get the wheels to spin but the brakes kick in on the side that is spinning. Hence, controlling traction in a forward movent.

If you have an LSD, the LSD will do its damndest to make both rear tires spin at the same rate during acceleration. Its a mechanical system and could care less about what setting your DSC is on.

The traction control systems are set up to compare the non-drive (front) tire speed with the driven (rear) tire speed... not right rear tire to left rear tire speeds.

Imp 07-13-2006 07:21 AM


Originally Posted by NGTMRE
WOW, 6 pages of this stuff and you guys are still confused about it...

Who cares? Really!

I do. It's the difference between winning and losing in my case. :)

--kC
(PS: Your post was on page 2... n00b settings... sheesh) :angel:

Paul_in_DC 07-13-2006 08:46 AM

^^ :icon_tup:

Umbra 07-13-2006 09:08 AM


If you have an LSD, the LSD will do its damndest to make both rear tires spin at the same rate during acceleration. Its a mechanical system and could care less about what setting your DSC is on.
It DOESN'T have to be a mechanical system. You can get the same effect through controlling braking.

This is soooooo dumb. If you only press it once it does still interfere at some points, you don't have to autox or push the car all that hard to feel that, just go thrash the car on some twisty farm roads in the middle of nowhere. If you press it for 7 it does go away. Personally I think it's way way easier to notice the differences in the settings on the way the front end of the car acts vs. the back end.

Personally when I'm really thrashing the car in public I leave it on in full mode so I don't eat a tree or another car by making a mistake but that's just me using something called common sense.

Paul_in_DC 07-13-2006 09:52 AM


Originally Posted by Umbra
...Personally when I'm really thrashing the car in public I leave it on in full mode so I don't eat a tree or another car by making a mistake but that's just me using something called common sense.

Uh oh, the flame sharks are circling... ;)

EyeBall Fixer...(o)(x) 07-13-2006 12:19 PM


Originally Posted by Paul_in_DC
Uh oh, the flame sharks are circling... ;)

http://www.mattzudweg.com/images/fla...k-fullsize.jpg

http://www.mattzudweg.com/images/bigg-nut-fullsize.jpg

MazdaManiac 07-13-2006 01:30 PM


Originally Posted by r0tor
If you have an LSD, the LSD will do its damndest to make both rear tires spin at the same rate during acceleration. Its a mechanical system and could care less about what setting your DSC is on.

The traction control systems are set up to compare the non-drive (front) tire speed with the driven (rear) tire speed... not right rear tire to left rear tire speeds.

Be careful - there are some bible (owner's manual) thumpers here who will take issue with that statement of fact.

Paul_in_DC 07-13-2006 01:34 PM


Originally Posted by dillsrotary
one of the best things about this forum is when relatively new members post threads stating something that everyone else knows. Its obviously not a major offense but it does kinda piss people off, especially when the new member doesn't listen to the opinions of say the autox's who know the answer. Its like me running into an ER surgery and saying,"Hey assholes, you're doing it wrong."

Sure - and I bet you're not turning your car off right either. :rollingla








(Heh)

Rasputin 07-13-2006 02:19 PM

I've had a similar experience in snow. The car would not move because of the TC. I pressed the DSC button once, problem was the same, TC was still preventing me from moving. I had to press the button for 7 sec to be able to move again by generously spinning the driving wheels.

Fabrice

otherside 07-13-2006 02:39 PM

Hey everyone! Can you hear that thumping sound? Thats sound of someone continually beating a dead horse!! Let it go.......

puch96 07-13-2006 03:22 PM

Yes.... After 91 posts, nobody has shown me imperical data on how this system behaves when you press the button vs. when you hold the button.
Also, there seem's to be a lot of confusion along our fellow rx8 members about how the system operates and what system does what. I mean it is taking 91 posts and it is still going.
In any event, I will shut up now and go ahead an try it for myself... maybe..... and just enjoy the 8.

Paul_in_DC 07-13-2006 03:44 PM

There's quite a bit of empirical data in a number of the posts. Try active listening... asking questions, requesting clarification, etc.

MazdaManiac 07-13-2006 03:54 PM

I love how some people will simply dismiss an issue when the data stacks up against them.

I guess he doesn't like the empirical data beause it is Imperialist?

Puch96, I assume that you dismiss the practical data presented because all those presenting it are liars? That would be the only reasonable explanation for you suggesting that there has been no data.

StealthTL 07-13-2006 04:02 PM

PuchGuy....
 
"The empiricism of the empirical is a tautological tautology." - Alexei Sayle.

Empirical evidence has been presented in many of these posts - once you write it down it becomes unacceptable to you?

People have said "I feel the difference..."
You reply "It doesn't SAY that in the manual..."
You are both right.

S

Winfree 07-13-2006 04:17 PM

I don't plan to park on any beach sand - but if some one does do this with an 8 what is the sequence for getting yourself out of the situation? ( for the old 323, you throw stuff in front the wheels, or carry a couple of blankets that can be fed under the wheels and you get your self slowly out of the situation - for the neighbors SUV, you put chicken wire under the wheels and keep him from digging himself in deeper, and finally get a god tractor to pull him out)!

puch96 07-13-2006 04:54 PM


Originally Posted by MazdaManiac
I love how some people will simply dismiss an issue when the data stacks up against them.

I guess he doesn't like the empirical data beause it is Imperialist?

Puch96, I assume that you dismiss the practical data presented because all those presenting it are liars? That would be the only reasonable explanation for you suggesting that there has been no data.

1) No... The data is not stacking up against me.... I just didn't see any data yet. All I heard was personal experiences and opinions

2) NO.

3) I am not calling anybody a liar. The only thing is that I get mixed explanations on how DSC/TCS really works. Furthermore, I don't really know who to follow because there will always be someone that contradicts somebody else.

Moostafa29 07-13-2006 05:08 PM


Originally Posted by puch96
Yes.... After 91 posts, nobody has shown me imperical data on how this system behaves when you press the button vs. when you hold the button.
Also, there seem's to be a lot of confusion along our fellow rx8 members about how the system operates and what system does what. I mean it is taking 91 posts and it is still going.
In any event, I will shut up now and go ahead an try it for myself... maybe..... and just enjoy the 8.

If you give me your email addy or aim sn, I'll send you a vid from best motoring that shows you how each of them function, and how they effect the handling. I haven't read any of this, so if this has been posted, please disregard.

dmp 07-13-2006 05:13 PM


Originally Posted by puch96
1) No... The data is not stacking up against me.... I just didn't see any data yet. All I heard was personal experiences and opinions

2) NO.

3) I am not calling anybody a liar. The only thing is that I get mixed explanations on how DSC/TCS really works. Furthermore, I don't really know who to follow because there will always be someone that contradicts somebody else.

By preponderance of the evidence, your initial thoughts about the system are wrong.

So are so caught up in 'how' the system works, you refuse to learn 'what happens'.

Follow MazdaManiac - he's right 98% of the time.
Zoom44 - he's right 98% of the time.
rotarygod - he's right 103% of the time - just ask him. :D
dmp - he's right 95% of the time - but doesn't always know 'why' he's right...but he usually is.

StealthTL 07-13-2006 05:17 PM

No logic at all...
 
"I just didn't see any data yet. All I heard was personal experiences "

...that, my logic impaired friend, would be the empirical data you asked for.


S




*cough*moron *cough*

captain mercury 07-13-2006 05:23 PM

base model rules!!! :eek:

otherside 07-13-2006 05:32 PM

Incredible, must be an engineer.

puch96 07-13-2006 05:33 PM

I appresiate everybody's input on this. To conclude this never ending thread, I must go out there and try it for myself....

By the way StealthTL.... thanks for the insult.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:51 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands