Costco Gas VS Shell or BP?
08-02-2012, 06:24 PM
#51
Banned
Thread Starter
this is what I don't understand about the gasoline debate: originally in 04 or so, Mazda required 87 but RECOMENDED 91+...now it REQUIRES 91+.....did they change the car AT ALL? or just the requirement?? I think that the keeper question right there...because if they changed the car you could make an argument that 91 is necessary, if it is the same car, or even MORE EFFICIENT when it comes to preventing knocking, detonation etc,...then by logic 87-89 should be safe...
08-02-2012, 07:03 PM
#53
After I had my car tuned with 100Ron fuel the difference with 95 got pretty consistant. Before that you could only feel a difference during hot summer days.
I wouldn't overthink the fuel choice too much, just use the right octane rating for your car and make sure that the mileage you get out of it is steady.
Fuel chemistry is very complex so it gets hard for us average joes to determine what works best. I tend to use Agip\Eni, Shell or Total fuels here because they're the main distributors (along with Esso\Exxon which sucks) so their stock is always fresh. That's pretty much it.
I wouldn't overthink the fuel choice too much, just use the right octane rating for your car and make sure that the mileage you get out of it is steady.
Fuel chemistry is very complex so it gets hard for us average joes to determine what works best. I tend to use Agip\Eni, Shell or Total fuels here because they're the main distributors (along with Esso\Exxon which sucks) so their stock is always fresh. That's pretty much it.
08-02-2012, 07:49 PM
#54
Rotary Powered Countryboy
I've found through tuning and general performance(not all on rx's. Mostly FI imports) that Sunoco seems to have the most.consistent octane quality. However shell and BP aren't terrible but have seen cars knock on that gas more times than Sunoco. Just my 2cents
08-03-2012, 09:22 PM
#55
Banned
Thread Starter
what would happen if you filled up half with premium, half with regular...what would that do??
Also I've heard people talk about adding octane booster to their fuel tank. What if you bought regular but added a few drops of that octane boost!?!?
Also I've heard people talk about adding octane booster to their fuel tank. What if you bought regular but added a few drops of that octane boost!?!?
08-03-2012, 09:31 PM
#56
Registered
Ken
08-04-2012, 08:27 AM
#58
Oh, it does prevent gas line freeze in the winter. You don't here about that like you used to 25 yrs ago. It even happened to me once back in the mid-80's. The change to plastic tanks from the rusty metal ones, at the gas stations, probably helps with that too.
08-04-2012, 09:02 AM
#60
Registered
I always thought octane ratings were obtained with some other additive. Ethanol just lets them use less. And the tanks held either premium or regular.
Ken
08-04-2012, 11:12 AM
#61
That would mean 87 has less alcohol than 93. So either regular has less than 10% (violating some state rules and the lobbying efforts of corn growers) or premium has more (violating most auto makers limits). That does not compute.
I always thought octane ratings were obtained with some other additive. Ethanol just lets them use less. And the tanks held either premium or regular.
Ken
I always thought octane ratings were obtained with some other additive. Ethanol just lets them use less. And the tanks held either premium or regular.
Ken
08-04-2012, 11:28 AM
#62
Registered
More cracking is one way. Higher octane used to be done with tetraethyl lead. (Are there any pump jockeys old enough to know what you mean if you say "Fill it with Ethyl?") Amoco did it without lead because they had refineries with the capability of higher refinement. When lead was banned, the majority went to other additives. No idea if Amoco still has their capabilities.
I'll let someone else cover the topic of whether higher octane has more energy or burns cleaner.
Ken
I'll let someone else cover the topic of whether higher octane has more energy or burns cleaner.
Ken
08-04-2012, 11:56 AM
#63
More cracking is one way. Higher octane used to be done with tetraethyl lead. (Are there any pump jockeys old enough to know what you mean if you say "Fill it with Ethyl?") Amoco did it without lead because they had refineries with the capability of higher refinement. When lead was banned, the majority went to other additives. No idea if Amoco still has their capabilities.
I'll let someone else cover the topic of whether higher octane has more energy or burns cleaner.
Ken
I'll let someone else cover the topic of whether higher octane has more energy or burns cleaner.
Ken
Higher octane actually doesn't have more energy (in fact they have less heating value) it is just easier to combust.
08-04-2012, 03:31 PM
#65
Registered
08-04-2012, 06:44 PM
#67
pure gas does make a pretty good difference in the gas mileage and the performance of your car.
Ethanol is "OK" but it does have less btu's than gasoline--hence why it doesnt give you as good of gas mileage. It does have some advantages as Team insinuated, but the trick is that stations dont handle it properly at times ( it really likes water), the percentage is never exactly the same and basically when you use it you are running a duel fuel car. It doesnt make tuning any easier.
There are other ways to increase octane. But, most are impractical for a DD. So tune for what you can get and if you FI dont take the fuel at the pump too casually.
Ethanol is "OK" but it does have less btu's than gasoline--hence why it doesnt give you as good of gas mileage. It does have some advantages as Team insinuated, but the trick is that stations dont handle it properly at times ( it really likes water), the percentage is never exactly the same and basically when you use it you are running a duel fuel car. It doesnt make tuning any easier.
There are other ways to increase octane. But, most are impractical for a DD. So tune for what you can get and if you FI dont take the fuel at the pump too casually.
10-01-2012, 07:03 PM
#69
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Mobile, AL
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I use shell when I can. Their gas is of good quality, and their 87 grade (which I use) has a higher octane rating than the reported 87 on the pump, and is calculated before the addition of ethanol. That might be true for all companies, but I know for certain that is how shell determines their 87 grade.
10-02-2012, 10:26 AM
#70
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Dearborn Heights, MI
Posts: 229
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I switch between shell and sunoco. My butt dyno tells me that the car feels better with the sunoco fuel, but I dunno. It seems to rev smoother after a full tank of Sunoco 93 + premix.
My question is, what effect does premix have when it's mixed with the ethanol and or water which could be in the fuel?
My question is, what effect does premix have when it's mixed with the ethanol and or water which could be in the fuel?
10-04-2012, 11:57 PM
#73
I always, inevitably-- no matter what-- get at least 10% better fuel economy with Shell gasoline than any other, and I'm not exactly some sort of cheerleader for Shell.
A full tank of Shell gasoline (13.5 gallons) typically yields 300 to 310 miles. With competitors, it's consistently 270 to 280.
A full tank of Shell gasoline (13.5 gallons) typically yields 300 to 310 miles. With competitors, it's consistently 270 to 280.
10-05-2012, 09:11 AM
#74
CostCo has been converting its stations to mix additives at the pump at 5x the required limit so one might infer that they are using Shell's additive and they do have a business relationship with Shell in some areas through the sale of Formula Shell oil. I suppose it could be Chevron too as they sell their oils in other areas too. Either way it would be a win win and I doubt they doing anything otherwise given the ease of sourcing the additive.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
nferguson88
RX-8 Parts For Sale/Wanted
1
10-06-2015 12:45 PM
