What fuel is best for an RX8?
#26
Lawyer in training :)
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 913
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Point taken, 8 is enuf. Although your open-ended sentence did leave me confused about its meaning, I apologize.
I think the thing that confuses me the most about the RX-8 is the inconsistency in performance. Some people get good gas mileage; some people get poor gas mileage. And, as here, a lot of people do not experience problems with low-octane fuel use; others, like myself, are utterly confused b/c the loud knocking and the drag in acceleration are markedly noticeable. For me, I wish I was making up the symptoms under 87-octane fuel. I would love to save money anywhere I can. Having read other threads, and I myself not being an expert in engines, I defer to earlier posts(i.e., posts #9 and 10 in this thread) that provide a more sound explanation than I could ever provide.
I think the thing that confuses me the most about the RX-8 is the inconsistency in performance. Some people get good gas mileage; some people get poor gas mileage. And, as here, a lot of people do not experience problems with low-octane fuel use; others, like myself, are utterly confused b/c the loud knocking and the drag in acceleration are markedly noticeable. For me, I wish I was making up the symptoms under 87-octane fuel. I would love to save money anywhere I can. Having read other threads, and I myself not being an expert in engines, I defer to earlier posts(i.e., posts #9 and 10 in this thread) that provide a more sound explanation than I could ever provide.
#28
RX8 RX8!
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Tampa Bay, FL
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Maolin34
I've used 87 and did not notice much difference in power, but my mileage dropped significantly... I only managed 147miles to 14.8 gallons. My fuel light had been on for a little while, and I could not believe when I filled up that I was that close to empty and had only 147 on the trip meter. Thats right....9.8mpg.
#29
RX8 RX8!
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Tampa Bay, FL
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by 8_is_enuf
I would love to swap cars for about 100 miles with someone who is getting really bad mileage just to see if the poor results follow the car or the driver.
#30
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: DC Metro Area, USA
Posts: 1,554
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by aggietiff28
I have been using 87 octane pretty much since I got the car. I live in the red-line zone and have not had any issues, although if I put 93 octane in...it just gets there smoother and what seems like faster (have not clocked this). I get about the same number of miles on the tank (220-260) no matter what I use with the exception of last week and the freezing weather which dropped me down to 160 miles on the tank...this I still don't completely understand.
You experiencing slightly more performance with 93 octane seems on par with the owner's manual suggesting that lower than 91 octane may result in lower performance.
I use Shell gas, what brand(s) do you use most often?
#31
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: DC Metro Area, USA
Posts: 1,554
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by 8_is_enuf
I would love to swap cars for about 100 miles with someone who is getting really bad mileage just to see if the poor results follow the car or the driver.
#32
Mean Green Keeny Machine
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: NRH
Posts: 265
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by rx8cited
I use Shell gas, what brand(s) do you use most often?
#34
Just an observation that I noticed on my car. I may get flamed, but I thought that it would be interesting. My car has 16.4K and I have been getting 19 to 19.6 MPG. Usually I fill up my tank with 91 octane after 240 miles; about a notch or so lower of 1/4 tank mark in the gauge. I do about 80% freeway @ 70 mph and half of the distance with traffic ~30 mph with stop and go in some areas.
Now here is the interesting thing. I normally use 76 gas station and it gives me the mentioned fuel economy. One time I decided to go to Costco and fil up with 91 because I was running low; and besides I was already there anyways to do some shopping. I noticed that my MPG went up to 20.7 MPG. That is strange, so I decided to try it out a few more tanks (5 - 7 ) and indeed my MPG is about that. One time I got close to 22 MPG, and my driving habits has not change nor my route or the traffic. I simply use my car to go to work and back home with a few miles in between for small errants. When I switch back to known brand gas, regardless if is 76, mobil, chevron, etc. My MPG goes back to 19 to 19.6. By the way I keep a close log book about my fuel economy since I got my car. I know that costco gas is not the greatest thing but so far I haven't experience any engine pinging when I do a WOT.
Anyone have experienced the same?
Now here is the interesting thing. I normally use 76 gas station and it gives me the mentioned fuel economy. One time I decided to go to Costco and fil up with 91 because I was running low; and besides I was already there anyways to do some shopping. I noticed that my MPG went up to 20.7 MPG. That is strange, so I decided to try it out a few more tanks (5 - 7 ) and indeed my MPG is about that. One time I got close to 22 MPG, and my driving habits has not change nor my route or the traffic. I simply use my car to go to work and back home with a few miles in between for small errants. When I switch back to known brand gas, regardless if is 76, mobil, chevron, etc. My MPG goes back to 19 to 19.6. By the way I keep a close log book about my fuel economy since I got my car. I know that costco gas is not the greatest thing but so far I haven't experience any engine pinging when I do a WOT.
Anyone have experienced the same?
Last edited by romulus; 12-21-2004 at 05:08 PM.
#35
I spoke to a Mazda Engineer today....I will make a new post with what was said, but part of it fits in this post...
It has been mentioned before, but the engineer confirmed it for me...using full with as little ethanol or any "nol" for that matter will make a measurable difference. I am not sure of the contents or additives used in different areas of the US or world for that matter...but for my area (Michigan) he recommended Sunoco Ultra 94. Typical premium octane is 92 in Michigan.
If you want to know more about what I found out...check my post in the RX-8 Discussions area.
It has been mentioned before, but the engineer confirmed it for me...using full with as little ethanol or any "nol" for that matter will make a measurable difference. I am not sure of the contents or additives used in different areas of the US or world for that matter...but for my area (Michigan) he recommended Sunoco Ultra 94. Typical premium octane is 92 in Michigan.
If you want to know more about what I found out...check my post in the RX-8 Discussions area.
#36
RX8 RX8!
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Tampa Bay, FL
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by romulus
Just an observation that I noticed on my car. I may get flamed, but I thought that it would be interesting. My car has 16.4K and I have been getting 19 to 19.6 MPG. Usually I fill up my tank with 91 octane after 240 miles; about a notch or so lower of 1/4 tank mark in the gauge. I do about 80% freeway @ 70 mph and half of the distance with traffic ~30 mph with stop and go in some areas.
Now here is the interesting thing. I normally use 76 gas station and it gives me the mentioned fuel economy. One time I decide to go to Costco and fil up with 91 because I was running low and besides I was there anyways. I noticed that my MPG went up to 20.7 MPG. That is strange, so I decided to try it out a few more tanks (5 - 7 ) and indeed my MPG is about that. One time I got close to 22 MPG, and my driving habits has not change nor my route or the traffic. I simply use my car to go to work and back home with a few miles in between for small errants. When I switch back to known brang gas, regardless if is 76, mobil, chevron, etc. My MPG goes back to 19 to 19.6. By the way I keep a close log book about my fuel economy since I got my car. I know that costco gas is not the greatest thing but so far I haven't experience any engine pinging when I do a WOT.
Anyone have experienced the same?
Now here is the interesting thing. I normally use 76 gas station and it gives me the mentioned fuel economy. One time I decide to go to Costco and fil up with 91 because I was running low and besides I was there anyways. I noticed that my MPG went up to 20.7 MPG. That is strange, so I decided to try it out a few more tanks (5 - 7 ) and indeed my MPG is about that. One time I got close to 22 MPG, and my driving habits has not change nor my route or the traffic. I simply use my car to go to work and back home with a few miles in between for small errants. When I switch back to known brang gas, regardless if is 76, mobil, chevron, etc. My MPG goes back to 19 to 19.6. By the way I keep a close log book about my fuel economy since I got my car. I know that costco gas is not the greatest thing but so far I haven't experience any engine pinging when I do a WOT.
Anyone have experienced the same?
#37
I remember back in May-June timeframe that there was a discussion regarding the quality of gas from the known brand and the "generic" ones. Based on what I remember that all the gasoline in your area are made in the same local refinery if any nearby. The tankers trucks pulls out from the refinery with the same "basic" gasoline. then they go to their company's formulation station to add their "additives" I am not sure what additives have the gas from costco or other small gas stations. At least I know that they are using the right additives to make 87, 91, etc. octane. My guess that the generic gas does not contain not much detergents like the brand names. But, for me I usually commute 60 miles per day and normally I fill up on Thusday night If I start my commute on Monday with a full tank. With Costco gas I can push it to 280 miles with 1/8 tank left and no low fuel light. And about 13.4 gallons pumped. I am planning to alternate the fuel brands so at least my baby gets all the cleaning additives.
Last edited by romulus; 12-21-2004 at 05:30 PM.
#39
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Montgomery, AL
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In the US, 87, 89, 93 are the general three Octane levels available. I know in the UK, 95 is the lowest! So, my questions is, are the engines made different for the two countires.
I am from the UK but drive my 8 here in Alabama, US. I use 93 but have tried the 89 level a few times. I have noticed a reduction in performance, especially obove 6ooorpm. Due to this I have never even tried to use the 87 Octane. A reduction in performance I can handle at times, but engine damage, I cannot!
I am from the UK but drive my 8 here in Alabama, US. I use 93 but have tried the 89 level a few times. I have noticed a reduction in performance, especially obove 6ooorpm. Due to this I have never even tried to use the 87 Octane. A reduction in performance I can handle at times, but engine damage, I cannot!
#40
Registered
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Richland WA
Posts: 284
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by 8_is_enuf
If the manual says that low octane will work find then guess what. Low octane will work fine. No suprises here.
#41
Originally Posted by quack_p
I read through a bunch of gas threads a while back, and several members swore by Shell V-Power. So that's what I always use.
#42
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: DC Metro Area, USA
Posts: 1,554
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Limey
In the US, 87, 89, 93 are the general three Octane levels available. I know in the UK, 95 is the lowest! So, my questions is, are the engines made different for the two countires. ......
For example, if you look in the owner's manual, they recommend fuel with octane 91 [ (R+M)/2 method] or above (96 RON or above) ..... so US 91 octane is UK 96 octane.
#43
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Montgomery, AL
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for tech info. Bottom line is I do not want to do damage and hear about "Knocking" sounds. It seems to me that if you get to the point where your engine is making these noises, damage may have already occurred. I drive about 4K miles per month and would love to reduce my costs by using lower priced fuel, but is it really worth it?
#44
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: DC Metro Area, USA
Posts: 1,554
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Limey
Thanks for tech info. Bottom line is I do not want to do damage and hear about "Knocking" sounds.
If using 87 octane is guaranteed to cause engine damage, I hope to hell that Mazda would not have said it was okay to use in the owner's manual.
If you try 87 octane and hear knocking or experience any other problems, then switch back. If you're going to try it, I'd suggest starting with Shell. Let us know what happens if you do.
#45
I'm sure somebody has said this before but I'll say it anyway. The purpose of designating different octane levels is a way of measuring HOW the fuel burns. The higher the octane the smoother and more controlled the burn. 87 tends to burn faster thus requiring more fuel and less timing. The PCM takes care of this for you learning between different fuels it can take several drive cycles for the PCM to learn though, so constantly switching is worse than sticking to one octane. For me personally running higher octane is better, there IS less risk of detonation and a performance difference. Probably not enough performance difference for the average person to notice on a close to stock car though.
#46
Originally Posted by Limey
In the US, 87, 89, 93 are the general three Octane levels available. I know in the UK, 95 is the lowest! So, my questions is, are the engines made different for the two countires.
I am from the UK but drive my 8 here in Alabama, US. I use 93 but have tried the 89 level a few times. I have noticed a reduction in performance, especially obove 6ooorpm. Due to this I have never even tried to use the 87 Octane. A reduction in performance I can handle at times, but engine damage, I cannot!
I am from the UK but drive my 8 here in Alabama, US. I use 93 but have tried the 89 level a few times. I have noticed a reduction in performance, especially obove 6ooorpm. Due to this I have never even tried to use the 87 Octane. A reduction in performance I can handle at times, but engine damage, I cannot!
Back West is a little different...
85, 87 and 91 are the available octane levels...so there are really 5 levels depending where you are in the US
And that doesn't include any of the race gas available at some stations...
Last edited by 2ks2k; 01-03-2005 at 01:55 PM.
#47
I have been using 87 octane pretty much since I got the car. I live in the red-line zone and have not had any issues, although if I put 93 octane in...it just gets there smoother and what seems like faster (have not clocked this). I get about the same number of miles on the tank (220-260) no matter what I use with the exception of last week and the freezing weather which dropped me down to 160 miles on the tank...this I still don't completely understand.
#50
non-ethanol (87) vs. ethanol (93)
I spoke to a Mazda Engineer today....I will make a new post with what was said, but part of it fits in this post...
It has been mentioned before, but the engineer confirmed it for me...using full with as little ethanol or any "nol" for that matter will make a measurable difference. I am not sure of the contents or additives used in different areas of the US or world for that matter...but for my area (Michigan) he recommended Sunoco Ultra 94. Typical premium octane is 92 in Michigan.
If you want to know more about what I found out...check my post in the RX-8 Discussions area.
It has been mentioned before, but the engineer confirmed it for me...using full with as little ethanol or any "nol" for that matter will make a measurable difference. I am not sure of the contents or additives used in different areas of the US or world for that matter...but for my area (Michigan) he recommended Sunoco Ultra 94. Typical premium octane is 92 in Michigan.
If you want to know more about what I found out...check my post in the RX-8 Discussions area.