View Full Version : Greddy Turbo and White Smoke?


zoomzoom_8
09-10-2005, 06:27 PM
Hey, been boosted for around 3 months with no problems other than a little rough idle and having to reset the ecu to combat the ltft.

Yesterday, I was at a stoplight, had just started the 8 a few minutes ago and looked behind me, there was tons of white smoke behind me. Light turned green and I went ahead, smoke gone so I just thought maybe it was someone else smoking, not me. Drove down the road, no smoke, did not happen again.

Started the car this morning, pulled out of the garage and white smoke everywhere! It was me.

Car runs fine besides a rough idle everynow and then, no cels, drives smooth, has power. Just after it sits for a few minutes and I start it, it smokes then goes away. The longer it sits, the more it smokes, but it always goes away. i do smell a kind of oil burning smell while it smokes :(

So, this is my first rotary, so I have very limited experience with them.

Are my apex seals now busted? Oil metering pump going bad? turbo leaking oil in the exhaust?

Any input is great, i am thinking i may be doing some intensive work soon, got that bad feeling about this. I have had some knock a few weeks back because of the ltft but once I learned about that and started reseting the ecu, everythng seem to be fine.

Thanks

Chris

two rotors
09-10-2005, 06:38 PM
Usually with a broken apex seal you feel a rough idle all the time(based on my RX7s).Also there is no smole associated with an apex seal failure,unless you have big time damage to an oil cotrol seal.White smoke is usually indicative of coolant seal failure,but it has the peculiar odour of burning glycol.If the smoke has burning oil odour,then turbo oil seal failure or casting crack in the turbo would be my best guess.

MadDog
09-10-2005, 06:42 PM
Is the smoke actually coming from the tail pipes, or under the car?

zoomzoom_8
09-10-2005, 07:01 PM
from the actual exhaust itself.

How could i check to see if it is the turbo oil seal or casting crack in the turbo, just look at it? Would I see any indications?

two rotors
09-10-2005, 08:07 PM
Yes,you can remove the inlet hose,outlet hose and the exhaust pipe ,if you see oil swilling around then the turbo is the problem.Note that a lite oil film on the turbo air outlet
is normal.

zoomzoom_8
09-10-2005, 08:27 PM
Got under the 8 a little while ago while it was running to see if i saw anything different.

The first thing I notice is that I had oil leaking from the downpipe/cat connection, a real drip there!

Second thing, turbo housing has a good amount of oil around it. Airinx is coated with oil as well as the bottom tray under the airinx.

Sounds like a blown oil gasket on the turbo?

Im_DANomite
09-10-2005, 08:49 PM
sounds like your turbo is gone/going bad. if it's white smoke, check your coolant level.

zoomzoom_8
09-10-2005, 09:18 PM
yea, that is what i am thinking, it is white/grayish smoke but it is definetly oil in the exhaust. I am running royal purple engine oil so maybe it burns lighter in color. I don't think i have any coolant problems though even though the color of the smoke is light.

Guess i will be taking the turbo off soon and sending it to Greddy for a replacement. At least this gives me a chance to finally tap and drill the exhaust manifold for my egt. Just trying to look at the brightside.

Anyone have any ideas on why the turbo itself would go bad so quick?

two rotors
09-10-2005, 09:26 PM
Do you have a blow off valve or recycle valve?If not spiking pressure is always good for destroying compressors.

zoomzoom_8
09-10-2005, 09:37 PM
bov and boost controller on mine, never noticed any spikes although i do get the horse sound once in a while, had it a bunch the first few weeks before i could get the bov adjusted.

greddy should cover this, don't you think?

two rotors
09-11-2005, 07:06 AM
Other possibilities-----not allowing the turbo to cool off before shutting motor off;this cooks the oil big time and carbonised oil particles wear the seals.
----manufacturing defect
----driving the turbo too hard.

EZZY
09-11-2005, 07:20 AM
white smoke = running too lean
go to the workshop and get it checked out

Gomez
09-11-2005, 07:44 AM
This has happened heaps of times. Had it serviced recently? Topped up the oil recently? It's overfull with oil, I reckon. Pumps out heaps of white smoke when it's overfull.

Drain some out and there'll be no dramas.....if that is the problem.

zoomzoom_8
09-12-2005, 12:42 AM
in the process of pulling the turbo off, checked the oil level, it was about a half of a quart low, so definetly something going on with the turbo itself in my opinion. i will post some pictures of the oil leak from the cat joint and the oil all over the turbo itself tomorrow.

Don't think it had anything to do with fuel mixture at all, definetly oil related, I can see the leaks but thanks for the input.

Can we start chanting on here to get my 8 back on the road? I miss her :(

adrian-1
09-14-2005, 06:22 PM
Did you get the turbo off? any pics. Also, did you ever get ahold of Greddy to see about warranty?

Im_DANomite
09-14-2005, 06:35 PM
this is my guess to why your turbo is going bad...

you don't have an oil catch can?? therefore blow-by oil (which has increased because of the turbo) is now shooting into the compressor housing. excessive oil in the compressor housing has caused the bearing inside the turbo to go bad causing oil to leak out of the turbine side. which leads me to the assumption that there is oil at the exhaust tips.

take off the intake to the compressor housing and see how much oil is laying in the turbo. then, by hand, wiggle the compressor shaft to feel any play. minimal play is normal...but i'm talking really small. also, check around the BOV and see if you can detect oil mist. make sure you prime the new turbo when you get one. i'd do a compression test just for kicks.

zoomzoom_8
09-16-2005, 12:58 AM
Sorry for the delays guys, we had a small huricane here and have been preocupied with that. have the down pipe off as well as well as some of the other small parts, should have the turbo off completely by tomorrow evening or so.

will put some pics up tomorrow hopefully too. The turbo itself, once the fan was exposed, told a few stories. When i spin the fan by hand, it scratches and you can also wobble it back and forth. So the problem sounds like the turbo to me. BTW, I do have an oil catch can so that should not be a problem. i have a tt and when it was not used I let it idle for at least 3 minutes and if i had ran hard then longer.

Have not talked to greddy yet, got to get the turbo out to get the serial numbers off. Looks like they should cover this though, i certaintly hope so!

Got one small problems, the nuts holding the turbo housing to the down pipe are very hard to get off, seem to be seized. One is starting to round off so I left off there as it was getting late then also. Any pointers on how to get that off, I sprayed some "pentrating blaster" on it but that did not help. Would a small handheld tourch work or is that a no-no?

Thanks guys,

I miss the 8 and the boost so bad! :(

YZF1000R
09-19-2005, 03:33 PM
Hi there zoomzoom_8. Sorry to read about your turbo probs and hope you get the 8 fixed soon.

Over here, UK, there is only one officially Greddy Turbo'd 8 and one more being converted at this time - we get every thing WAY later than you guys!!

Just wondering how long youv'e had the turbo fitted and if you had the same problem the UK guy's had with the ECU?? If so, what was the fix, as I am told that Greddy are doing an ECU for the UK problems. Did the US 8 have this problem too?

Sorry to ask all this when your mind is on more important things.

Regards,

Ian.

zoomzoom_8
09-19-2005, 09:16 PM
No prob, turbo was only in for about two and a half months, i think just a bad turbo compressor and nothing else cause no one else has had this exact trouble. Turbo is finally out now, took a couple of nights, lots of seized bolts from the heat i guess, i will be using anti seize for sure, should have in the first place! calling greddy tomorrow for replacement information, i will post on here what goes on with that.

What problems did the uk 8 have? We have trouble with long term fuel trim and the stock ecu but the interceptor seems to be the fix for us as it takes complete control of fuel and ignition, planning to get that as soon as i get this problem staight.

YZF1000R
09-20-2005, 06:29 AM
Thanks for your reply and I'm glad things are moving on for you.

The UK problems have been ecu related as far as I know, and I'm told that Greddy have now got their own ecu now.

TBH the best people to ask are ; Tim, he owns the first tubo'd uk 8 here's his website www.rxmotors.co.uk the guys who helped fit the turbo are at www.reworks.com What any these guys don't know about rotaries aint worth knowing!

Also, if you are interested, look at www.mazdarotaryclub.com (I'm a member).

To enter as a guest just click on the opening picture then look in the rx8 topics, there's some threads in there regarding Tim's turbo etc. Perhaps you could consider adding your experiences to the threads? I guess a lot of brits will be interested.

Cheers aagain.

Ian.

zoomzoom_8
09-20-2005, 04:55 PM
Update on the turbo issues. called greddy usa today, was informed that there is no warranty whatsoever on their products. The turbo has been in for only around two months, so it is apparent to me that the turbo was faulty from the beginning, weak bearing or oil seal that finally gave way.
I always let the turbo cool, really did not boost that much, keep the engine oil clean, watched all the oil temp/pressure gauges (which I have two of those) so i cannot see anyway that I did anything to this turbo. Their recommendation was to pay someone to see why it went bad but no matter what they would not cover it.

So my options now are to count my losses, gather the parts and go back n/a (which i will never do), rebuild the turbo at my cost, buy another greddy kit or go with ptp or another vendor. Either way there is more money out of my pocket.

I asked to speak to someone higher than the person i was speaking with at greddy usa, he informed me that he was the sales manager. He got someone else to come on the phone but that person also said he was the "sales manager". So greddy usa has a lot of chiefs but no indians evidently.

they gave me the number to greddy japan, which of course is closed at this hour with no voicemail. i will be calling them tonight to speak to whoever is above the greddy usa company which they would not tell me the name.

Needless to say, I am upset. I voided the factory warranty which really is no big deal cause i have not had any warranty claims but when i think that the product greddy sells is not even covered by manufactoring defects and all the money we all spent to go turbo, it really burns me up.

Broke apex seal says that the emanage ruin his engine, which i don't doubt because of all the problems with the emanage. Now my turbo is burnt. But there are some on here that has not had any trouble but take note, if you trust the "trust company" like i did, you may get burnt! Isolated problems do occur and most reputable companies stand behind those problems, not Greddy evidently.

i will not be doing any business with them again if they continue this practice of business.

So does anyone recommend anyone to rebuild a turbo or a good replacement to get that mitsubushi out of there?

PUR NRG
09-20-2005, 05:04 PM
Sorry to hear about your problems. Do you remember the names of people you spoke to at Greddy USA? Check your state laws regarding express and implied warranties. You may have some legal recourse there. As far as rebuilding the turbo, you could always call Mazmart to get the Interceptor-X and their turbine upgrade...
________
Magic Flight Launch Box Review (http://mflbvaporizer.com)

fray
09-20-2005, 05:13 PM
Many states have an automatic implied 90 day warranty. The only way around that implied warranty period is to specifically include with the item itself a warranty card with "alternative" warranty information. (Some states it's only 30 days..)

two rotors
09-21-2005, 04:38 PM
Well I would have thought this turbo would have lasted longer than it did.However it is a fact that the factory turbos on RX7s are water cooled.The reason for this is that heat soak on shutdown with none water cooled turbos on rotary engines is horrendous.Mazda supplied data showed a temperature difference on shutdown of 302F between water cooling and only oil cooling.Given that oil fries easily you can see the necessity for very careful temperature management.

two rotors
09-21-2005, 05:02 PM
I found the data.

PUR NRG
09-21-2005, 05:03 PM
Mazda supplied data showed a temperature difference on shutdown of 302F between water cooling and only oil cooling.Given that oil fries easily you can see the necessity for very careful temperature management.Are you sure it's a 302F temperature difference? Synthetic oil has a burn point around 450F.

For what it's worth, under normal driving my water temp reads 190F and my oil temp in the pan is 140F. If in fact the oil returning from the turbo was 300F+ I would expect to see random spikes and fluctuations in the oil temp as the hotter turbo oil mixed unevenly with the colder engine oil. Given that is not the case I suspect your hypothesis is incorrect.
________
Mercedes-Benz Specifications (http://www.mercedes-wiki.com/wiki/Mercedes-Benz)

two rotors
09-21-2005, 05:55 PM
1.It is not hypothesis--I merely shared with you data PROVIDED by Mazda.
2.I fyou examine the graph you will see that there is NO difference when the engine is running.The difference occurs AFTER the engine is SHUT OFF.Now when I shut off my engine no oil flows and no coolant flows(other than small flows due to gravity and temperature differences(ie hot water rises and cool water sinks.
3Next time I will try to write in Swahili or something!!!

PUR NRG
09-21-2005, 06:15 PM
2.I fyou examine the graph you will see that there is NO difference when the engine is running.The difference occurs AFTER the engine is SHUT OFF.In order to examine a graph I'd need to see it first. Note you posted the graph less than a minute before I posted my response. I was still typing my response when you posted it. In your original post you said "temperature difference on shutdown". Now you've clarified that to after shutdown. Big difference.
________
Difference Between Easy Valve And Solid Valve (http://www.vaporshop.com)

youpey
09-21-2005, 06:30 PM
i think everyone reading this should call greddy tomorrow and ask them about there warrantees on there products. if they say they dont have one, then ask them why they dont stand behind their products and that you should probably buy x companies instead. if they do tell you they have a warrantee, ask them to email you it, and send it to our friend here then he can call them and say he has written consent of a warantee. i was getting a greddy exhaust next week, but now i will buy an RB if they wont warrantee their stuff

two rotors
09-21-2005, 06:39 PM
OK I will have my lawyer check all my future post.

zoomzoom_8
09-21-2005, 09:21 PM
i think everyone reading this should call greddy tomorrow and ask them about there warrantees on there products. if they say they dont have one, then ask them why they dont stand behind their products and that you should probably buy x companies instead. if they do tell you they have a warrantee, ask them to email you it, and send it to our friend here then he can call them and say he has written consent of a warantee. i was getting a greddy exhaust next week, but now i will buy an RB if they wont warrantee their stuff
My point exactly! Thanks! Please do! :)

I am researching my choices, guess since they will not stand behind their product I will have to pay for a new turbo, rebuilt one, or upgraded one like mazsport is doing. But either way, I will never buy anything greddy again. They have really stuck me hard.

Btw, my oil temps usually ran around 180 and on hot days reached 210. is that too hot or typical?

thanks guys, i will keep ya posted.

chris

zoomzoom_8
09-21-2005, 09:24 PM
btw, please everyone email or call them and express your feelings! might not help me but maybe someone else!

thew
09-21-2005, 09:49 PM
If you bought it from MazdaPArts.com than any thing that you think is a bad Greddy part you need to send to me with your invoce. I will sendit to Greddy and get them to make the call. They will not do anything without the part. I have a Guy in Greece that has a Cracked Exhaust manafold out of the box! Same deal. He has to send it back to me so i can send it to Greddy.. I dont like that way of doing things , but thats the Greddy way.

swoope
09-21-2005, 11:22 PM
did you buy it with visa????

they have coverage for almost everything you buy.

i have used it once. some paperwork, but well worth it.

beers


btw, please everyone email or call them and express your feelings! might not help me but maybe someone else!

OfficerFarva
09-26-2005, 08:54 PM
check this out zoom zoom, it says clearly right here warranty 1 year with the greddy turbo kit. http://www.turbo-kits.com/rx-8_turbo_kits.html. Maybe i'm being an idiot and that warranty comes from turbo-kits.com, but it sure looks like it's a greddy warranty to me. hope it helps.

philodox
09-28-2005, 03:24 AM
With a turbo, the crank case is under pressure. If you have a catch can, make sure the line running from your oil fill to the catch can is not blocked. If it is, there is nowhere from the pressure to release. This will cause oil from the turbo to leak both into the exhaust and into your intake system. Check your BOV if you have one for excessive oil. If it's there, that's your culprit.

zoomzoom_8
09-29-2005, 08:01 PM
Thanks philodox, I thought about that too but the turbo itself looks bad, the compressor wheel moves and actually touches the housing, which I think is way too much play. The turbo is in michigan now at bullseyepower waiting for nick there to assess it so I will keep you all posted. But if anyone else has the troubles I have, check that first or you will be wasting lots of money :)

I MISS MY 8!

PUR NRG
09-30-2005, 12:11 AM
I MISS MY 8!Given the turbo is off the car, couldn't you reattach the stock airbox and exhaust manifold to make the car drivable again? Forgive my ignorance but while it takes a lot of work to get everything installed, it doesn't seem like it would take that much to make it drivable sans turbo.
________
Vapir Air One 5.0 Review (http://vaporizer.org)

swoope
09-30-2005, 12:46 AM
way more to it than that.

beers

adrian-1
09-30-2005, 02:38 AM
way more to it than that.

beers

Not much more.
Like PUR NRG said...
Install stock intake (you'd have to remove piping to the airnix filter and piping to the throttle body.)
Remove exhuast manifold and put stock one back on.

plus.....
Cap off the oilpan drain
Cap off the oil supply line that was going to the turbo
Plug the intake manifold nipples.
That should do it.

You can leave the intercooler and emanage alone (it won't see boost so it shouldn't affect anything).

I'm guessing zoomzoom8 has a second car.

PUR NRG
09-30-2005, 10:06 AM
Just because you have a second car doesn't mean you prefer driving it. :)
________
Coach Handbags (http://icoachhandbags.com/)

MadDog
09-30-2005, 02:02 PM
I've taken the whole kit off once and put it on twice -=on jackstands=-.The second time around, the install was about 6 hours. You could save a little time by leaving the intercooler in place, but everything else has to go. I checked into a new turbine housing for the GReddy. Nobody, I mean NO BODY has this thing, or has even heard of it. Parts for it will have to come on board a ship from the Land of the Rising Sun. You're in it for the long haul if you need a new part. I'd say, wait for the diagnosis. If you need a new housing or bearing, etc., then go ahead and put it back to stock for the 2 months that you will be waiting.

zoomzoom_8
10-02-2005, 10:39 PM
Yea i could put go back n/a, but don't really feel like doing the work, that is no fun after you have been turbo. Got a second car and no, it is not fun to drive at all, a SUV. :(

God, i hope you are wrong maddog :) I have not heard bck from my guys yet on the turbo, I was hoping to be back on the road by mid october!

youpey
10-04-2005, 11:40 AM
i still cant believe greddy wouldnt warantee this, especially since this is on their site
---
Warranty You Can Count On

At GReddy we take our image seriously and back our products with a real warranty you can count on. In most cases, after examination of the item we will elect to give you a complete new product as opposed to repairing a defective one. We do this for two reasons, first of all to make you a completely satisfied customer, and secondly and warranty items are fully examined to find the cause of a defect and if necessary make running changes to the product line in the future. This is why GReddy maintains one of the lowest warranty claims percentage in the industry.

MadDog
10-04-2005, 12:25 PM
I believe the installation instructions have a statement that says ( and I quote) "You are totally f*cked if anything goes wrong. This product has no warranty at all. We are screwing you. Bend over."

twospoons_
10-10-2005, 01:19 PM
i still cant believe greddy wouldnt warantee this, especially since this is on their site
---
Warranty You Can Count On

At GReddy we take our image seriously and back our products with a real warranty you can count on. In most cases, after examination of the item we will elect to give you a complete new product as opposed to repairing a defective one. We do this for two reasons, first of all to make you a completely satisfied customer, and secondly and warranty items are fully examined to find the cause of a defect and if necessary make running changes to the product line in the future. This is why GReddy maintains one of the lowest warranty claims percentage in the industry.

Easy to have lowest number of warranty claims if you dismiss all warranty claims :)

youpey
10-11-2005, 08:45 AM
i emailed them asking about a warantee and it bounced back. anyone have an email address other then info@greddy.com

Spyder_doo
10-11-2005, 10:04 AM
See if you cant get a different garrett turbo to fit. I thought there was talk of another size turbo that fit pretty well.

Rotary Rasp
10-11-2005, 01:16 PM
Take them to court if they don't replace it!

zoomzoom_8
10-11-2005, 07:59 PM
i would love to take them to court but for the $1100 i am spending on getting a custom built replacement turbo there is no way i would come out cheaper, they just get off free an d i have to pay.

my guys are working on the turbo, i will post the specs on here as soon as i get them so everyone can have a chance at this turbo, it sounds pretty awesome so far

YZF1000R
10-22-2005, 09:57 AM
Hi there zoomzoom8. Got any news on progress on the new turbo yet mate? Also, have GReddy changed there 'tune' and decided to warranty their turbo!!?
Cheers ;-).

EZZY
10-22-2005, 10:18 AM
Warranty You Can Count On

At GReddy we take our image seriously and back our products with a real warranty you can count on. In most cases, after examination of the item we will elect to give you a complete new product as opposed to repairing a defective one. We do this for two reasons, first of all to make you a completely satisfied customer, and secondly and warranty items are fully examined to find the cause of a defect and if necessary make running changes to the product line in the future. This is why GReddy maintains one of the lowest warranty claims percentage in the industry.

so did greddy exam the turbo against the manufacturing defect? in most cases, you will have to send it back to them, they exam it and determine the causes.

they will never warranty on the installations, thats should be offered by the installer, but then again, would the installer puts his/her hand up and say, yep, it was my fault, i will fix/replace the part for you? i guess NOT... :wallbash:

alot issues will cause turbo/turbo seals to cease, tuning is one of them. who did the tuning and did he/she tuning it properly..... you will never know now.

im sure greddy will most likely to offer a better warranty if the installation was performed by one of their approved installers..... then again, they can always blame you for not looking after the car...

i think you have mentioned something about BOV and boost controller with your setup in an earlier post.... greddy can always argue that you have over boosted the turbo, and damaged the turbo....

its going to be a long flight... :mad: good luck with it

zoomzoom_8
10-22-2005, 06:15 PM
na, i have exited the greddy turbo realm, check it out here www.bullseyepower.com, the rx8 greddy turbo upgrade, I get mine tuesday or wednesday. The intercooler is next along with the emanage and then all I have greddy is the bov and boost controller and of course intercooler pipes :)

MadDog
10-23-2005, 11:58 AM
I know you needed it because yours went bad, but, what is that center section and compressor housing supposed to do for you?

zoomzoom_8
11-16-2005, 11:05 PM
they upgrade the internals and the turbo stays relatively the same size with the same flange

BlueAngel
11-19-2005, 04:26 PM
sorry to hear about your lost Z,
does anyone w/greddy turbo have the same problem like ZZ, i want to know , before i put the t618z turbo kit on my baby,
i was so excited that im finally going to boost, BUT AFTER READING zoomzoomS, WELL IM WORRIED .
pls reply E N ONE