RX8Club.com

RX8Club.com (https://www.rx8club.com/)
-   Series I Aftermarket Performance Modifications (https://www.rx8club.com/series-i-aftermarket-performance-modifications-23/)
-   -   Drop-in high flow Intake Filters (https://www.rx8club.com/series-i-aftermarket-performance-modifications-23/drop-high-flow-intake-filters-16838/)

tommy12g 12-18-2003 08:00 AM

K&N Drop in Filter
 
After going on the K&N Website, all you have to do is measure the stock filter element size and you can get the drop in from their vast selection of drop ins, I dont think anyone has taken the time to measure it, if you do please post the dimensions on this thread because then we can all just request that drop in size.

djantlive 12-18-2003 08:15 AM

Keep in mind that if it's not a perfect fit, you can have unfiltered air seeping through the side, which would be a big problem. I wouldn't buy one if it's not made specificatically for my car and I had to have it custom made.

K&N drop in only gets you 2-3 hp. I have it on my FD and don't really notice the difference. The filtering element is very thin. I can see thru the filter if I hold it against a light, whereas I can't do that with an OEM filter. So, I don't think it'll filter as cleanly as OEM. Nevertheless, it's nice that they're reuseable.

AlexCisneros 12-18-2003 09:03 AM

it's like 14.5 by 9.5

Already tried to measure and they told me it would not be available for another 3 months


I think they want to sell the typhoon kit

tommy12g 12-18-2003 09:17 AM

True, the typhoon would be better if it was heat shielded, cause it has a bigger filter than the RE!! I feel that by looking at the OEM filter and the RE filter that the OEM has a bigger surface area than the RE i dont know that is my feeling, thus the OEM will allow more air to pass through

XeRo 12-18-2003 10:08 AM

BUT tommy...the engine can only handle so much cfm coming in to the intake so bigger doesn't always mean better...RE intake even with smaller surface area still allows the correct maximum amount of flow though to the MAS and intake...

hppy4u 12-18-2003 11:57 AM

>Keep in mind that if it's not a perfect fit, you can have unfiltered air seeping through the side, which would be a big problem. I wouldn't buy one if it's not made specificatically for my car and I had to have it custom made.

I don't think it would be too much of an issue (no flames intended) but the few drop-ins I have installed have never fit as well as OEM filters. They were always slightly off...however when you clamp the OEM cover down the filter rests nice and snug.


>K&N drop in only gets you 2-3 hp. I have it on my FD and don't really notice the difference. The filtering element is very thin. I can see thru the filter if I hold it against a light, whereas I can't do that with an OEM filter. So, I don't think it'll filter as cleanly as OEM. Nevertheless, it's nice that they're reuseable.

I believe all K&N-like filters (whether they be conical, flat, donut shaped etc) use their proprietary oiled gauze filtering element. So that would mean that most afterrmarket filters would be susceptible to filtering issues. In fact with most cone shaped filters increasing the surface area, the aftermarket ones would run a higher risk of improper filtration.

-=Zeqs=- 12-18-2003 11:58 AM

Too much airflow and the lack of capacity to efficiently utilize it all, will cause bottle necking and air flow disturbances as XeRo has mentioned. Unless some more extensive porting was to be done on the RENESIS, it is unlikely that a substancial amount of gains will be noticed. A few ponies will still show up, but unlike that much more will show up.

tommy12g 12-18-2003 12:26 PM

OK, that I can understand and makes sense
thanks for the clear up

Rotary Extreme 12-18-2003 03:15 PM

The filter used by K&N typhoon is a super over kill. That filter is big enough to support 1000 rwhp.

The filter we use is big enough for this NA application.

I use a smaller filter than the RX8 one on a 3rd gen single turbo and got 400 rwhp.

Chuck Huang

Genom 12-18-2003 04:15 PM

Pardon the silly question then, but why use such a large filter if it's not necesary? Wouldnt it have been better to use a smaller filter element and maybe separate it a bit more from the box to improve airflow around it?

tommy12g 12-18-2003 04:15 PM

Ok fair enough!!

Gord96BRG 12-18-2003 04:59 PM


Originally posted by Genom
Pardon the silly question then, but why use such a large filter if it's not necesary?
Bragging rights in the parking lot.

(Disclaimer - I don't believe in K&N filters, I don't buy the vague and misleading hype that is all over their marketing material, and I don't believe that the intake and factory filter/airbox is a significant restriction on the stock engine. More specifically, you could very likely remove the stock air filter completely, ie run with no filter at all, and make the same hp on a dyno. Hard to see how any drop-in filter could make any additional power then, isn't it? ;) All the K&N drop in would do, then, is filter less efficiently. Who needs more dirt in their engine?)

Regards,
Gordon

Rotary Extreme 12-19-2003 02:11 AM

I don't why they did that. Maybe it's marketing strategy? Just look at this thread, how many people have said the bigger filter will give more HP.

Chuck Huang



Originally posted by Genom
Pardon the silly question then, but why use such a large filter if it's not necesary? Wouldnt it have been better to use a smaller filter element and maybe separate it a bit more from the box to improve airflow around it?

Rotary Extreme 12-19-2003 02:16 AM

Did you do the dyno test on taking off the filter inside the air box and see if it gives the same HP? I don't think you did, otherwise you will find out without the filter, the car makes more power.

Chuck Huang


Originally posted by Gord96BRG
Bragging rights in the parking lot.

(Disclaimer - I don't believe in K&N filters, I don't buy the vague and misleading hype that is all over their marketing material, and I don't believe that the intake and factory filter/airbox is a significant restriction on the stock engine. More specifically, you could very likely remove the stock air filter completely, ie run with no filter at all, and make the same hp on a dyno. Hard to see how any drop-in filter could make any additional power then, isn't it? ;) All the K&N drop in would do, then, is filter less efficiently. Who needs more dirt in their engine?)

Regards,
Gordon


Genom 12-19-2003 06:40 AM

I was also wondering why you decided to use a larger filter Chuck. You mention that you used a smaller filter on a much mroe powerfull 7. So why not make this one smaller as well, to allow better airflow around it? Also separating the surface from the hot engine even further?

XeRo 12-19-2003 07:36 AM


Originally posted by Genom
Pardon the silly question then, but why use such a large filter if it's not necesary? Wouldnt it have been better to use a smaller filter element and maybe separate it a bit more from the box to improve airflow around it?
You would think so...The only logical explanation i can think of is the one previously stated about the MARKETING propaganda...

I mean really....go hang out in Pep Boys or whereever for a while and take a poll..."if you were going to change the air filter element in you car/truck, which company would you go with?" you will either get a dumb, blank look or i bet the majority of the folks would answer with K&N....I do alot of offroad rig building in my limited spare time and 90% of the guys that have me work on their Jeeps and FJ's ask about a drop in K&N replacement becuase they want those extra 8-10 horses...i'm like WHAT!! are you outta your mind...8-10 from a drop in...IDIOT!!...K&N in my book...their getting a little like Bose in a way...moving away from quality and relying on their established name to carry the weight...kind of explains why they didn't research a heat shield...

Genom 12-19-2003 08:49 AM

I was asking Chuck that question because he's pointed out you didnt need such a big filter, and then basically says he coulda used a smaller one as well. I'm wondering why.

I ask this since Chuck at least doesnt have products at my local Pep boys, so marketing didnt seem like a good enough reason.

Brando 12-19-2003 12:10 PM

Has it occured to anyone here that this product has yet to be tested either on a track or dyno to see what kind of gains are to be had. All of this talk is speculation. Educated speculation but speculation none the less. Who cares if the filter is overkill as long as it puts out the power advertised. I ran stock exhaust for a while on my 450rwhp Z28. It was able to support that kind of power, but that doesn't mean that there was not power to be gained by swapping it out....I've heard that the fit and finish of this K&N piece(typhoon) is quite good and the power gains have yet to be proven so I would suggest that we not bash it until we have a foundation to do so. I will add though that no more than 2-3hp if any will be picked up with a drop-in.

XeRo 12-19-2003 12:47 PM

not bashing it...speaking from past experience....although results remain to be seen...hey..I'm all about being proven wrong...

Rotary Extreme 12-19-2003 08:30 PM

K&N only makes certain sizes for the 3.5" flange filter and the one I am using is the best one for this application. If you look at my intake setup, you will see there is a lot of room around the filter.

Chuck Huang


Originally posted by Genom
I was also wondering why you decided to use a larger filter Chuck. You mention that you used a smaller filter on a much mroe powerfull 7. So why not make this one smaller as well, to allow better airflow around it? Also separating the surface from the hot engine even further?

mdw33333 12-23-2003 03:36 PM

Green Filter has drop in!
 
Green filter has a drop in filter for the stock air box. K & N is still months away from introducing their drop in filter. Their typhoon is probably a hot air sucker. For now I'm sticking with the Green Filter. I'm going to wait and see what comes out in cold air systems over the next few months.

mikeb 12-23-2003 05:06 PM

got any info
price, picture, links????

Sin 12-24-2003 12:13 AM

?????????????

mdw33333 12-24-2003 07:20 AM

The part number is #2476. It's a new number, and it's not on the web site yet. Any internet distributor can get the part.

bobclevenger 12-24-2003 06:26 PM

Just what is the benefit of having a green air filter?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:24 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands