RX8Club.com

RX8Club.com (https://www.rx8club.com/)
-   RX-8 Discussion (https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/)
-   -   RX8 or RX7 Twin Turbo? (https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/rx8-rx7-twin-turbo-138557/)

23109VC 02-21-2008 02:11 PM

RX8 or RX7 Twin Turbo?
 
Here is a question to throw out to the bulk of you here.

I have owned two RX7s in the past. A LONG time ago I had a 79 RX. I did a lot of fun work to that car, ported motor, upgraded carbs... back in the day it was fairly quick.... it got into a wreck and I sold it.

Later, I owned an 87 Turbo II. Did minor mods to that car, and it blew the motor, I was a poor college student and couldn't afford to fix it so I sold it.

Now I'm older, have some $$...and am looking for a toy. I have test driven several RX8s and I love the car. I like the rotary motor, lov the high revs, and the handling is phenomenal. The ONLY thing that I dislike is that the car lacks serious horespower. The rear seats are nice, but I don't HAVE to have them. the perfect car would be to get the hp/torque levels from teh FD into the chassis of the rX8...that would be great...but that's a discussion for another thread... :)

I remember when the FD was out and was new. I was in college... and I kept a picture of a red FD over my desk - sort of as motivation - thinking that I'd buy one when I got out of school. by the time i got out of school, they ddin't sell it anymore..i didn't make enough to afford one anyway..blah blah..married..blah blah...kid #1, kid #2, kid #3....now i'm 36, make good money, and am thining of doing a third car. for me. for fun. as a toy.

the one car I lusted after back when I was young was the FD. it would be fun to finally get one. even though it is a 10+ year old car...it is still a unique and timeless looking car. a nicely conditioned, well modded FD would turn heads today as it would back then..at least to me... nice wheels, lowered, one of the TASTEFUL body kits, or the japanese OEM kit.... and the thing looks beautiful.

It's been a long time since I have had a rotary...but I researched the heck out of FDs back in the day and my recollection was that while they wre phenomenal cars in terms of power/handlng...that they were very tempermental, and had a reputation for blowing motors, and in general, having lots of little issues...

I'd like to spend $15-20k on the car and not have a pile of repair costs. which is why I'm leery of the RX7.

I think I could find one in that price range...and maybe even a well maintained one, but I really have no idea what I"d get hit with or should expect to get hit with in terms of operating costs - i.e. REPAIRS.

I figure I can easily find a low mileage 05-06 in that price range...and have a warranty..a new car..and probably few or no problems.

I've also never seen or heard anyone do a head to head comparison of the RX8 and RX7. I drove an rX7 like TEN years ago...and remember thinking it was on rails..but that was 10 years ago. last time I drove an 8 it was on rails to me too.... but i've never done back to back road tests. i'm sure someone here HAS.

maybe the 8 actually handles BETTER...or maybe the 7 is still the overall king of rotaries..if you can afford to pay/play...

My gut tells me I migth be safer going with an 8. it will be newer, warranty...and just enjoy it for what it is.

the RX7 is tempting though...

Anyone car to chime in on their thoughts? is buying a used RX7 really a roll of the dice/ russian roulette.... basically getting into a situation taht will eventually wind up costing me a ton of money.... b/c if it is, i'd rather just avoid it. but if the real truth is that wit the right mechanic...and a good car...it would be a dream to drive..maybe it's worth looking into...

and the other question is...how do the two cars compare? i know power it's kind of a no brainer. but what about cornering, handling, etc?

for those of you who have had both, or driven both back to back...for a sunday drive on a twisty road, or a track day (novice track day...I would just be doing it for $hits and giggles..to screw around and have fun not to try and beat anyone or win any races).... just about having fun...would they both be just as good as the other??

thanks.

Jethro Tull 02-21-2008 03:04 PM

When I was 20, I bought a BN '80 RX-7 (late '79). I agree with you that those cars were special. I loved that car and have always regretted parting with it. FWIW, my buddy had a 280ZX and the 7 was every bit as fast...thanks to being nearly 1,000 lbs. lighter!

I love my 8 and intend on keeping a long time. I'm not as into raw horsepower as you and think the car has plenty of muscle as-is, but to each, his own. I love it just as it was designed. And I do think it handles better than my first gen 7.

I have also been thinking of buying an old, first-generation 7 to rebuild as a project car. Keeping my eyes open for just the right one. No rush.

I think it would be a ground-up project and my aim would be to restore it to as close to factory condition as possible...concours material. Mostly a trip down memory lane.

So I enthusiastically say "go for it" if you are prepared to spend some money. Especially if you go with the turbo version.

CyberPitz 02-21-2008 03:32 PM

Personally, I'd say hit the RX-8, and if you were wanting to get that "turbo" feel with it, you could drop a turbo kit in there after the warranty is up. Getting the RX-7's is just begging for the little problems that will prevent you from fully enjoying the cars...*electrical gremlins, gotta make sure the engine is in good standing, etc*.

If you really want to get back to your nostalgic self, get the RX-7, no questions about it. But you are wanting to enjoy the car without worrying about it giving you a problem with anything soon after you purchase. That's what makes me say the RX-8.

Jethro Tull 02-21-2008 03:34 PM

^^He's right. That's why I intend to have both... :)

JRichter 02-21-2008 03:39 PM

It's been a while since I've driven an FD RX-7 but I'm pretty sure a stock FD RX-7 would easily out handle a stock RX-8. In fact I think it would out perform it in just about every performance category but for every day driving it would be fairly close. The two cars are in two different classes.

The RX-7 was more hard core being lower to the ground with stiffer suspension and I would think less suspension travel in general. It was also quite a bit lighter and more "pure" meaning it was a no-compromise sports car. The RX-8 obviously has more room and I would say more comfort which was Mazda's intention to appeal to more people. This may not matter to you but their is some big differences between the two.

But... with that being said, it would be more wise to spend your $15-20k on a much newer car with some sort of factory warranty left. The RX-8 isn't that far off performance wise (for every day driving) for the peace of mind of having something much newer and can be easily modified to run with the 7.

It's hard to find an unmodified FD RX-7 these days and if you do find one that is in good condition you will pay quite a bit of money for a relatively low mileage car that has been properly maintained and comes with all records of service. The complex sequential twin turbo system would be costly to replace/repair as would many other components in the car. I know there is clean/good running modified RX-7's around but your gonna pay some bucks and spend a lot of time looking. A lot more research would be involved.

If your into doing this kind of work yourself more power to you but if your looking for simple, worry free rotoring then a newer low mile RX-8 would be the obvious choice.

Get you an 8 now for a daily driver and later get you a RX-7 for a project.

CyberPitz 02-21-2008 03:42 PM


Originally Posted by Jethro Tull (Post 2309575)
^^He's right. That's why I intend to have both... :)

Pssh, Jerk!

:bowdown:

jones75254 02-21-2008 03:47 PM

hmmmm, i dont know man. You have lusted over the FD for a long time, what could be sweeter than to own your very own? 15-20k should get you a damn nice FD. I have seen some very nice one in that range. You would just need to do your homework on the cars history, owner, ect...
As much as i love the 8 and know you would too, if i had that kind of $ to spend, my ass would have an FD! You sound well established enough that im sure there are at least 2 vehicles in your household right now, so, you would at least have one other car for bulk of the driving and the beautiful FD for daddy!! Get the FD and live out your dream....man it seems i am living through you right now, LOL.

rx820bna 02-21-2008 03:54 PM


Originally Posted by Jethro Tull (Post 2309575)
^^He's right. That's why I intend to have both... :)


Or merge it into one.

http://www.autotechmotorsports.com/project-rx8.htm

CyberPitz 02-21-2008 03:59 PM


Originally Posted by rx820bna (Post 2309613)

Now THAT is awesome....

23109VC 02-21-2008 05:20 PM

I have a 2007 MDX for wife/family driving and an older but dependable volvo (and PAID OFF) for my to/from work commuting.

the RX8 or RX7 would be a toy. I want something that is fun. If it breaks, or has a problem, I can park it in the garage and deal with it later. the car I buy will NOT be for routine transportation. It would be for weekend joy drives, occasional track day (maybe once or twice a year) and driving it to/from work once a week, like on Friday for fun.

the RX8 would proably be less hassle. it would be newer. the RX7 would be more ofa raw true sports car...but would be in/out of the shop here/there with the kind of stuff that old cars deal with...but then the 7 might also blow up and cost me $5k on a new motor. which would suck.

I also toyed with the idea of just getting a C5 Z06 and be done with it. not my cup of tea in terms of a car, but it's the "end" I"m looking for. i'd really love to have some slick,sleek bad a$$ looking car that not only corners well but goes like all hell. and unique. I don't want an EVO or some other generic rice burner.

the rx8 is a unique car. it looks good. it's fun as all hell.

i ought to find some used RX7s and go check them out, try a test drive and see if it still makes me feel the way it did 13 years ago. :) I've seen some so cal dealers that stock them, or keep a few on hand and seem to specialize in them.

there is one in San Diego called Sahara that seems to have like 5-6 FDs on their lot. high teens to low 20s pricing.

If I found one that was mostly stock...I'd get it checked out, make sure all the basics were in good condition, and then maybe do new shocks/springs sway bars, strut bars, new wheels/tires, source a nice body kit, and then do some mild tuning. an ECU tune, full exhaust, intake, and tehy are pretty fast. I'd try to keep the motor stuff mild enough that it wasn't going to blow up....but with an FD..who knows..maybe even a stock motor would be at risk of failure....

i could easily be more than happy with an RX8. i drove a few of them, it is fast enough. just not super fast. i woul dnever get tired of the handling once I put some stiffer shocks/springs/sway bars in it. but the power might be somethign that eventually I'd want to improve..and absent goin FI, it's hard to get more power out of the 8.

$$ is the issue though. I want to keep it reasonable. $20k is a fair amount to spend ona "toy" car...but I don't want to get nickel and dimed to death on repairs and maintenance.

rglbegl 02-21-2008 05:40 PM

If I were in your situation . . . ..

FD for sure.
You have the time, money, and know how to keep one working properly.
The FD is WAY more of a sports car. Way faster with a little work.
And if you dont need a commuter or a family car . . .hands down winner

But

The RX8
Has a back seat
Warranty
and reliability.

JRichter 02-21-2008 05:53 PM


Originally Posted by 23109VC (Post 2309757)
I have a 2007 MDX for wife/family driving and an older but dependable volvo (and PAID OFF) for my to/from work commuting.

the RX8 or RX7 would be a toy. I want something that is fun. If it breaks, or has a problem, I can park it in the garage and deal with it later. the car I buy will NOT be for routine transportation. It would be for weekend joy drives, occasional track day (maybe once or twice a year) and driving it to/from work once a week, like on Friday for fun.

Well Hell! That changes everything.

I would get an FD then. If you've always wanted one (like me) and it would be a toy or something you can park and work one then it's a no-brainer. Plenty more parts available for the FD then the RX-8 as of now and easier to build up.

You can always get an RX-8 years from now (they'll probably be dirt cheap) and build it up next.

I agree with rgbegl. It's definitely more of a "toy" and more of a hard core sports car.

Sunlight_Silver_RX8 02-21-2008 06:02 PM

I have owned both and without a doubt the RX7 is the better car. I miss my Twin Turbo terribly. The RX8 looks good but it does not compare.

I should have bought a Corvette but the 2007 RX8 I bought was practically given away so I had to take it.

Detrich 02-21-2008 06:20 PM

both are great choices.

the FD is a "purest" sports car, whereas the 8 is more of a "practical" sports car. and, the difference totally shows.

if you HAVE to have wHP & torque and don't mind paying for it, along with the additional headaches of higher maintenance, then the FD is the way to go. personally, i absolutely love the unique tone of the FD engine. it's truly one-of-a-kind. and, when properly tuned, the ferocious power in FD is a thrill to enjoy.

if you are OK trading off some wHP for better cornering capability, more comfort, and higher car reliability, then the RX-8 is the way to go. personally, i am not one who likes spending $ & time when my car breaks down all the time. so for me, the RX-8 is a better choice, even if i have to watch the FD burn by me on the road.

try to weigh the 2 and see what better fits your budget & lifestyle. and, let us know what you get and upload some pix!

:)

jones75254 02-21-2008 08:19 PM


Originally Posted by Sunlight_Silver_RX8 (Post 2309850)
I should have bought a Corvette but the 2007 RX8 I bought was practically given away so I had to take it.

LOL, coulda woulda shoulda, if i had a nickle............

911SC 02-21-2008 09:34 PM

I was in a simular situation a few years ago. No debt, other than a small mortgage, good income, and no kids. So I felt it was time to get another "fun car"
Years ago I had a Fiat X1/9 and an "83 RX7.
This would also be a car that could sit for awhile if it needed repairs and I didn't have the time at the moment to work on it. The FD was at the top of my list. Couldn't find one that hadn't been messed with. All had issues, and if not, they were too far away or over priced. Somehow I ended up with a 1980 Porsche 911SC Targa. I guess what I'm trying to say is since it's going to be a toy, get something you really like. For $15 to $20K there are a lot of nice classic cars out there. Also insurance and taxes could be very cheap depending on where you live.

delhi 02-21-2008 10:38 PM

Japanese cars don't age well. Get a 993. But if pop-up lights and kamikaze wing are your thing, then get the FD.

Cody Red 02-21-2008 10:46 PM

the fd is one of the greatest mazda's ever made, imo.

to me, this car is a super car because you can make it crazy fast and handle like a god. think: Twins Turbo

although, the fd is older, the aftermarket area is much larger. if you can get a great deal on the most stock fd you can find, i say go for it (if it's not a daily driver)

the rx8 is still fairly new, aftermarket isn't AS large as the fd, and is much more reliable (chances are the 8 will have warranty). since it's new, parts are expensive. I say if it's not as expensive, the 8 is a little less pricey (depending on how far you wanna go with the fd, and what it's being used for i.e. drag, grip, drift. the 8 isn't the fastest of the two, nor can it be made AS fast (unless 20b is an option), but handling can be as good, if not greater due to the engine being a bit further back. but then again, the fd can be made much lighter than the 8.

so yeah. it all comes down to how far you wanna go with it, and what it's being used for.

I say fd since you had a TII, and the fd is a sports car like no other, like all other rotary-powered cars. but the fd is WAYYYY more sexier, and more rare (Depending on area). then you can always build an rx8 later down the line :)

g/l

either way, fd/fe for the win.

gregs 02-21-2008 11:36 PM

cant go wrong with either, i was in the same boat but i chose the rx8 because i wanted to be the first owner and i knew i wanted to turbo the 8 as well...not sure how a turbo 8 will compare to a twin turbo 7 but i didnt get to compete with 7 just mostly to have fun at track days and still load up some friends and go for a drive comfortably

CyberPitz 02-22-2008 10:42 AM

We need a poll :P

The more he talks, the more I think he really needs that FD :D

kersh4w 02-22-2008 11:56 AM

get a cayman.

seriously.

also, vettes are kinda passe. not unique at all.

23109VC 02-22-2008 12:29 PM


Originally Posted by delhi (Post 2310333)
Japanese cars don't age well. Get a 993. But if pop-up lights and kamikaze wing are your thing, then get the FD.

ha! funny you say get a 993. a porsche 911 is the ONE other car that I really would like to get. My brother in law has a 1998 996 and it's a lot of fun. his has the aero kit, it's a manual (NOT a tip). not blazingly fast, but it looks VERY cool, sounds VERY cool, handles nice, and is a blast to drive. problem is to find/buy a NICE 996 (which are cheaper than 993s BTW) you're looking at 30-35k realistically. that's to get a clean one that has relatively low miles. I don't know if a used 911 or an FD would be more or less problematic/high maintenance than the other???

i like the idea of another rotary. it would be a fun car to work on. I am one of those people that likes to have a unique car. my last "toy" project car was a 2004 S60R. I tricked it out with a lot of stuff froma company named EVOLVE. it had a full body kit, suspension, ECU/dp/exhaust... here is a pic

http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/4...06109BaM27Zy2k

i loved that car, but it got $$ to maintain and i really needed a more dedicated family car..so i sold it and bought the wifey an MDX. i drive our "Older" car to/from work but it still runs fine for commuting. now it's my turn to get somethign fun. i really dont' want to spend 30-40k on a toy car. i make decent money...but i don't make enough to justify spending THAT much on someting I'll drive "sometimes".

spending 15-20k would be more along the lines of what I want to spend. and keep in mind, i have to convince my wife to go wtih the program....and 30-35k for a toy is out of the question. so the 911 is probably not a reality.

given that I like unique cars...just look at my volvo...while not an "exotic" by any means, it was VERY unique. it turned heads wherever I went...and it was fun to have a car that literally NO ONE else had... i had looked at selling my commuter and buying somethign like an Acura TL-S.... something *sort* or quick and fun but basically ultra reliable and "sensible"..but geeeez you see a TL every where you look it's so generic. i decided i'd rather drive my older car to/from work every day and have something more unique and cool in the garage for fun drives.

an RX8 is a very affordable sports car. i've seen clean low mileage ones for 20k and given the current car market, i'm sure you'd find someone or some dealer that would negotiate and you'd get it down in the 15k range. take a few grand and buy a cat back exhaust, suspension, and the car would be FUN. not a rocket sled, but it would handle amazing and look COOL. and you would not see one at every stop light. i could do track days once in a while..and the upside the the 8 is my 6 year old son could go with me for fun drives. he could sit in teh back and we could go hang out. i wouldn't drive CRAZY with him in the car, but it would be a fun "father/son" thing to do to take him out for a nice drive on a twisty road - stop along here and there and take pictures.... with airbags, or safety concerns...it's not really a good idea to put little people in the front seat... so I could take him with me if I was going to go for a sunday drive...keep in mind not doing anythign reckless with my kids..i'd save my insane driving for a track day.. but there are times where you can go out and have a really fun drive, take some turns a few mph over the "suggestion" on the signs...and have a blast and enganger no one. or nice scenic drives with lots of twists and turns...here in so cal there are a lot of fun drives... palomar mountain, malibu canyon, julian.... palms to pines... ortega highway... i can go on and on..there are a lot of cool roads that we could "explore" together. i really need to see whether you can legally or safely put a booster seat in an FD and have a 6-7 year old in there. by the time he is large enough to not need a booster...it will be a few years....

anyway... for pure driving excitement, I think an FD would be a more purpose built car. you can find nice ones with not too bad of mileage in the 15k range...and then it would bea n ongoing project. honestly...in some ways..for a car that I would keep a long time, i kinda see the FD as more of THAT car. an RX8, while nice, is more of a "regular" car...the kind you would drive around but I don't see myself thinking "i'm gonna keep this car for 15 years"...whereas an FD is , at least within car nut circles..somewhat of a legend... it's the kind of car you could drive and it will turn heads, people who know cars wil know what it is..and if you had one that was fixed up nicely... it would get a lot of attention.

for fun..it would probably be a way better performance car.

the ONLY fear I have with the FD is that I'd end up spending 15-20k to BUY one...and I'd wind up with a car that was not modded and hopefully in decent condition...then I'd end up spending another $5k to make it lke I want..and then I run the risk of a motor or turbo problem.. and bam. i've got antoerh 5-10k in repairs. so then i'm basically into the car for 30-35k.... and when you factor in all the hassle of having the car in/out of the shop, paying for it, but not getting to drive it.. i might start saying to myself, you should have just bought the 996!

:)

if i could find a nicely modded FD that was not a "problem"...and it would run relatively trouble free.. like one where the motor had recently been done, maybe the owner is selling due to financial issue...not "the car is a problem and I want to dump it on someone"...then i migth be able to find a nicely modded car..the way I would want to mod it...and in good condition.. in the 20-25k range... and have something that would not requrie a ton of $$ to mod, and it would run ok for a few years w/out major repair $$. that would probably be the ideal setup. find someone else who modded it..TASTEFULLY and PROFESSIONALLY. not some guy who slapped on parts here/there in his garage, and it's a mess and out of tune..but a nice car that was done RIGHT> problem is those cars are going to be very rare..i'd have to be willing to fly to find it and drive it home or ship it.

i saw one FD on autotrader that was 60k.. ha!@ not gonna spend that kind of money.

ok...so i go onto autotrader. i search for 93-95 RX7s and search the ENTIRE county. only 145 cars. go search for RX8 and do the WHOLE COUNTRY... it turned up ** 3000 *** hits. so you can see finding a good 7 is NOT going to be nearly as easy.

here is a nice looking one. no major engine mods (new turbos) but nice wheels, lwo miles. 25k... OBO

http://www.autotrader.com/fyc/vdp.js...=&cardist=2318

another relatively low mileage car, very clean looking..

http://www.autotrader.com/fyc/vdp.js...=&cardist=1178

here SHE is... this is about what I'm looking for. right price. looks AWESOME...

http://www.autotrader.com/fyc/vdp.js...=&cardist=1700

this last one..the photos i linked below are from the ad above..the last ad I posted a link to. $20,000. 69,000 original miles. for a car made in 1993 that's LOW. of course it's gonna need work..it may need new bushings, brakes, fluids...blah blah...there could easily be $5000 in "tune up" type repairs and TLC... but oh how sexy..

http://images.autotrader.com/images/..._A.565x379.jpg

http://images.autotrader.com/images/..._A.565x379.jpg

that's about as far as I want to mod the car. factory lips, nice wheels, lowered on nice suspension. looks good, but NOT ricey or "fast & furious"... not after that look.. but his one looks nice.

that would be an awesome toy.

but buying out of state would be a major drag. imagine flying out to see it and realize it's not what the seller represented.... talk about major disappointment.

RotaryPower7 02-22-2008 02:15 PM

20k for 69k miles.. eh a little to much

ShAdOwFoX 02-22-2008 02:20 PM


Originally Posted by 23109VC (Post 2311191)
but buying out of state would be a major drag. imagine flying out to see it and realize it's not what the seller represented.... talk about major disappointment.

but it would be a fun vacation though :uhh: hehe

911SC 02-23-2008 09:24 PM

I told you finding a nice FD was hard. Nice ones are either expensive or for some reason on the other side of the country. If your budget is $15000 and you like 911's look for a nice 3.2 Carrera. I know people have a hard time buying a 20 year old car but the SC's and Carreras are reliable and sturdy cars. Mine is 28 years old and has been very reliable. Take your time, get a PPI on anyone you consider and all should be good. They are also fairly easy to work on if you have some talent. The Pelican Parts web site is great. Full of tech info and a bunch of great people that will help you with any issue.

Mpoumpou rx8 02-25-2008 04:09 PM

of course rx7

23109VC 02-25-2008 05:14 PM

i'm starting to lean away from the FD.

I've been searching/researching websites...and my main fear is the reliability issue. even though it would be a third car, I want to have time to ENJOY it, and if it's constantly being worked on - it won't be enjoyed..it will be more of a project car and less of a toy. another fear is the $$. if i find a good one for 15-20k... and the motor did blow, to rebuilt it right...given that I can't do it.. i'm looking at 5-7k in rebuild fees/labor..

an RX8 would be way slower, but if I got a new enough one, i'd have a bumper to bumper warranty. i could spend a couple grand and put on some mazdaspeed suspension parts, NOT void my warranty, and have a fun car that handles like it's on rails.

the 911 fantasy is a lot like the FD. it would be fun, but repair costs could kill me.

honestly, the one alternative i'm toying with - S2000. honda lease rates now are pretty cheap. i believe with about 1500 down...i could be out the door, with tax, for as little as $370/month for a lease. full warranty.. and i've driven a bone stock 2008 S2000 at the local dealer and it's quick enough to keep my happy and bone stock it needs no suspension mods. it's firm/harsh and corners nice. might be the best compromise in terms of fun/affordable and reliable. totally impractical..but i have my 4 door for those days.

we'll see. i still want a rotary... :(

Detrich 02-25-2008 05:32 PM

reliability is a big issue for FDs. you really want to find one that hasn't been tinkered with and that is truly bone stock. and, that is very hard. :(

well, i've already made my recommendations n my earlier post re: FD vs. FE :)

Re: s2000. Never driven one, so i can only comment on observations as a non-owner. best motoring seems to love it, as it performed really well in slolem + skid pad tests. it's a bit more expensive than the rx-8, smaller, and more common on the road. style-wise, personally i like the rx-8 better. but, everyone's taste is unique. :)

p.s. on that red FD- it looks nice, but i don't like the wheels. they don't look aggressive enough. :)

delhi 02-25-2008 05:43 PM

It sure ain't fun when your car sits in the garage over a puddle of oil. Fast is not defined by how fast the flatbed truck is carrying the FD to your local rotary mechanic before the shop closes. The local rotary mechanic will be very happy that you are paying his kid through college and his weekend sail boat. And it is no fun when each time you want to start up the car you say a little prayer. ;)
If you want a nice unreliable car, get a 964. But if you want to relive Vin Diesel days, then can't beat an FD.... or a Supra... or a Talon.

islanders_rx7 02-25-2008 07:58 PM

I own a 93 fd3s + a fc3s(89 gtu) and love them to hell! I bought my FD from a Mazda dealer for 5,500 with a blown motor. $16K and a lot of sweat and tears I would never sell it well maybe if Mazda comes out out w/the new 7. Buying a fd from someone you dont know is a crap shoot. Plus not to mention you better have some sort of ad fd fund cause your going to need it.
I just recently bought brand new 8 and man this out handles the fd not by power though. I dont know why I waited this long to buy one. My wife is not afraid to drive 8 like she is w/ the fd.
I would say go with the 8 less maintenance and heartaches.

N rider89 02-25-2008 09:31 PM

hmmmm you have two great cars here, short answer get the Rx-8 .

the fd is an amazing car, its great when its all in order and i think that the reliability issues are a little over blown, granted things will break with age and things will go bad if you don't stay on top of things. if you keep the 7 relatively stock you should be ok. but if things go bad (old part breaks, bad previous owner, just bad luck) you dont want to be put in the situation of having to shell out the extra money to get it all fixed up. if i could have an Rx-8 or a Rx-7 brand new, i would take the Rx-7.

that being said the Rx-8 will be most likely the easier of the two to deal with. one of the main factors being the existing warranty. its not the all out sports car that the 7 is but it still is a great car in its own right. it has good power, handles very well, has very good brakes and is fun to drive. also it is comfortable to drive daily if need be. also the 4 seats is an advantage when it comes to non performance, i allows you to take some friends to dinner or something. the interior will be nicer and more comfortable. its just easier to deal with.

you seem to be worrying about reliability a bit, so i cant really recommend the fd. i love mine but it really hasn't been all that reliable ( i dont care personally, its all fun to me). many 7 owners get a strong bond with their car because of the money and hours and sweat that they put into it, and i kinda feel it too. i love the Rx-7 but you should get the 8. its the better choice for you because of the reliability of a newer car along with the factory warranty.

Renesis07 02-26-2008 05:59 PM

RX7 FD- If you want a project car and a weekend toy and have $$
RX8- if youre wanting practicality and reliability.

Pretty easy summary of my opinion

23109VC 02-26-2008 07:01 PM

thanks guys. in my fantasy I want the super cool FD. it would be fun. but part of that is the illusion that it would be all roses...driving around in this super cool super fast car. then if I think about the likely REALITY of what would happen if I bought an FD,I think of driving it, and then having the motor blow, or it won't start, etc...and then i go to the mazda dealer and they can't fix it...having to source a rotary specialist for an FD.. and then more and more $$$ out the door to keep it running. i'd spend more time fixing it, and repairing stuff and less time just having fun with it.

an RX8 would not be as fast, would still be fun, and since i could get a much newer car, i'd have hte warranty. since the RX8 gets little to NO power gain with power mods, i'd probaby do no mods, but more maybe some mazdaspeed suspension stuff to make it allthe more a canyon carver on rails.

911SC 02-26-2008 09:53 PM

I really thought you were on to something there for awhile.
Sure an RX-8 will problably be more reliable. But you already have reliable transportation. If you have some extra $$ go ahead and buy yourself what you really want. You only live once. Sure when an older car breaks you have to fix it. But some of these cars are more reliable than you might think. I've had my 911 for five years. 1 clutch and just regular maintance is all it's ever needed. Sure I was frightened about all the repair costs I had read about. Mostly from people who had never owned one. If you lived nearby I'd gladly give you a ride in my 28 year old, tail heavy, smelly, loud, crude Porsche. By the way, get the Targa.:)

Renesis07 02-27-2008 02:11 PM

correction......with time and $$ the RX8 CAN BE FAST.......Look into FI or a 20B. You would have spent the money on an FD, put that cash into the reliable practical RX8 and MAKE it fast........

quantum 02-27-2008 02:25 PM

My last RX-7 was an 88; my new RX-8 handles much better. When the time comes, I may work on it. But the 8 is a better platform, IMO.

Renesis07 02-27-2008 02:44 PM

Theyre two completely different cars IMO. Way different, different purposes and platforms. But that doesnt mean an RX8 doesnt have the potential of being a beast like an RX7. Thats the point Im trying to convey, Ive always had a bad spot for people who bash RX8s and call them slow. They werent meant to be fast but can still be land rockets if you have $$. Is there anyone here who honestly disagrees with that? lol

TheWulf 02-27-2008 03:05 PM

Put it this way: I have an 8 and now I want both :)

T-von 02-27-2008 10:44 PM


Originally Posted by 23109VC (Post 2315991)
i'm starting to lean away from the FD.

I've been searching/researching websites...and my main fear is the reliability issue. even though it would be a third car, I want to have time to ENJOY it, and if it's constantly being worked on - it won't be enjoyed..it will be more of a project car and less of a toy. another fear is the $$. if i find a good one for 15-20k... and the motor did blow, to rebuilt it right...given that I can't do it.. i'm looking at 5-7k in rebuild fees/labor..

:(


The reliability issue with Fd's is more year based than what most people think.

Here's my background. I've owned a total of 4 different Rx7's since 1991. An 81 GSL 12A.....84 GSL 12A....91 vert---and my 94 touring. I bought my Fd used back in Jan 2003 with 65,000 original miles. It was a two owner garage kept vehicle. I paid $13,500 off ebay for it. Currently this car has 108k and a blown engine. I blew it back in Nov 2006 due to over boosting (my fault). I currently have a 20b sitting in the engine bay that should be running next month. Up until blowing the engine, I had to replace the clutch, put in new pillow ball bushings, and new diff mounts. That's it! Earlier in it's life, my car had the Mazda factory recall done on the vacuum lines. Up until me blowing the engine, everything worked as it should. Seq turbo transition and everything. The key with these Fd's and even Rx8's is the year you choose to purchase used. 1st model year cars always have the most problems and sometimes never receive all the updated parts from the newer versions that come out years later. I compared my cars warranty history with that of a 93 model fd and was shocked at how much longer the pages where. :eek: Easily my car had 1/4 the problems of the 93 model. You know the same can be said about the Rx8's. 04 and 05 Rx8's aren't very reliable either. I should know as I manage a Mazda parts department and have access to vehicles service history. I have yet to have 06 or newer Rx8 come to the dealer for the average problems you find on the earlier models.



With that said, if you still wanna consider an Fd, find a 94-95 model. Since these versions cost nearly 40k brand new, these models typically have original owners that keep them longer. These will mostly be garage kept and in much better/un-abused shape. My car still has soft leather thx to my original owners. Now for an Rx8, I would strictly go with the 06 and newer models.

NaarLeven 02-28-2008 02:05 AM

the fd's reliability problems were often blown out of proportion. With the appro. mods you could easily have a good, relativly reliable oil burning supra killing monster.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:25 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands