RX8Club.com

RX8Club.com (https://www.rx8club.com/)
-   RX-8 Discussion (https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/)
-   -   5w oil question (https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/5w-oil-question-168376/)

exsequor 03-06-2009 02:50 PM

5w oil question
 
Is it true that 5w oil doesn't really exist and it's only created by diluting 10w with additives?

Is this piece true?..stumbled upon this


I spoke with Kelly Tidwell for over ninety minutes. And during that phone call, he schooled me with the truth about oil and filters.

I asked him about my GMC’s manual advising me to use 5w30 oil. He chuckled and told me that there is no such thing as real 5 weight oil. They get 5 weight oil by diluting a 10 weight oil with solvents. He went on to tell me that every consumer vehicle should only use one of two grades: either 10w30 or 15w40 – PERIOD. 20w50 is too thick and too full of additives. 5 weight is too thin and full of solvents. He told me that the greater the distance between the first and second number of the oil grading, the more additives in the formula. This man had my attention.

I asked him if the climate affects the nature of the oil. He told me that all oils break down from heat and usage. 5 weight oil is not protecting your engine like it should for any real length of time. A 20 weight oil is too think and slows down the engine’s ability to move, making the engine work harder and getting you fewer MPGs.

He told me NEVER go to one of those oil change places because they use “mystery oil” from a barrel that they mass purchase. This oil is re-refined. You never know what you’re getting in that scenario because unlike food and drink, there is no set of rules or labels that show their formula. It’s best to learn how to change your own oil. When I told him I have always changed my own oil, he commended me.

All oils start as a base oil. What changes the characteristics of oil are the additives. He told me that if I wanted to make my oil brand of oil that there are companies that will sell me barrels of oil with my formula of additives in it. Once I get my labels slapped on these barrels, I’d be in business. That’s more or less how the oil companies operate. For this reason, he suggested buying major label oils like Shell or Chevron – or I could buy his oil. He didn’t push his brand and I’m pretty sure he did that so as to not come off as a salesman. This man is the real deal, let me tell you.

I dont think this piece is true..I don't honestly know.


I asked him about synthetic oil. He laughed and told me that there is NO SUCH THING AS A TRUE SYNTHETIC OIL. He went on to tell me that synthetic oils are their way of stealing your money legally. It’s a game of, “How can we get the people to spend $6-$7 per quart? If there was a true 100% synthetic, it would be a lot more expensive. He went on to tell me NEVER use Synthetic oil. I laughed and told him I changed my oil the day prior with Mobil 1 synthetic. He told me that synthetic oils put plastics (polymers) in the formula. Under heated conditions, these plastics separate from the oil and attach to the metal in your engine. Synthetics are also highly acidic and that’s not good for your engine at all. He also informed me that Pennzoil sued Castrol because Castrol used to claim they made 100% synthetic oil. That was not true and look at Castrol’s Syntec oil label now. I asked him if there’s any truth to the myth that once you put synthetic in your motor, you can never switch back to conventional oil. He chuckled and told me that is totally false. It’s the oil companies perpetuating the lies to force you to continue to buy synthetics at $6-$7 a quart.

He suggested I use a good “commercial grade” oil and a good filter and I’d be fine. I asked how to decipher what a good commercial grade oil is. He told me to look at the back of a bottle of motor oil. There are codes on the rear label like SM, SG, SL, CI4, CG4, etc.

As a rule of thumb, if the “S” is before the “C”, it’s a lower grade oil and do NOT use it. If the “C” is before the “S” it’s good commercial grade oil. He told me (and it’s public record) that Mobil 1 oil has been removed from the aviation industry altogether and it’s been in and out of the consumer market NINE times. Wow, that’s an eye opener

exsequor 03-06-2009 02:51 PM

found here
http://www.epinions.com/content_5153071236

StealthTL 03-06-2009 02:53 PM

Just bullshit.

diluting a 10 weight oil with solvents
The solvents would be gone the first time you drove.

there is NO SUCH THING AS A TRUE SYNTHETIC OIL. He went on to tell me that synthetic oils are their way of stealing your money legally. It’s a game of, “How can we get the people to spend $6-$7 per quart? If there was a true 100% synthetic, it would be a lot more expensive. He went on to tell me NEVER use Synthetic oil. I laughed and told him I changed my oil the day prior with Mobil 1 synthetic. He told me that synthetic oils put plastics (polymers) in the formula. Under heated conditions, these plastics separate from the oil and attach to the metal in your engine. Synthetics are also highly acidic and that’s not good for your engine at all.

This tool obviously knows zero about oil. I've spent the last 25 years refining synthetic oil, and I can't even begin to correct all that drivel, except to say that EVERY statement in EVERY sentence is 180 degrees wrong.....Plastics that separate out?.....Wow.

Porsche, Ferrari, Corvette - all put synthetic in as factory fill 'just for fun' and 'to steal your money'.

A 20 weight oil is too think and slows down the engine’s ability to move, making the engine work harder
Does anybody on this forum - anybody - think this is correct?

If the “C” is before the “S” it’s good commercial grade oil.
I don't care who you are - that there's funny!

S ...........currently using 0w30, and yes, 100% PAO (full synthetic)

exsequor 03-06-2009 02:58 PM

Okay I'd rather it be bullshit lol

ZoomZoomH 03-06-2009 03:01 PM

and people say they believe the internets! lol

TheWulf 03-06-2009 03:09 PM


Originally Posted by StealthTL (Post 2900820)
A 20 weight oil is too think and slows down the engine’s ability to move, making the engine work harder
Does anybody on this forum - anybody - think this is correct?

Now THAT makes me want to :banghead:

exsequor 03-06-2009 03:10 PM

ty guys..you prevented me from absorbing this "knowledge" lol

exsequor 03-06-2009 03:12 PM

I actually didn't even read the full stupidity of that article just the bit on 5w mostly hahah

nycgps 03-06-2009 05:36 PM

Rofl

what a f-ing idiot.

I really wanna slap him in the face.

cajunrx8 03-06-2009 07:09 PM

Where in the hell did you find this information???? I would like to read the whole thing and see how long I could keep from laughing.

cajunrx8 03-06-2009 07:10 PM

Never mind, saw the link.

philipchan 03-06-2009 07:19 PM

I'm using Motul 15W50 ... running good...

DOMINION 03-06-2009 07:39 PM


Originally Posted by StealthTL (Post 2900820)
A 20 weight oil is too think and slows down the engine’s ability to move, making the engine work harder
Does anybody on this forum - anybody - think this is correct?
I don't care who you are - that there's funny!

S ...........currently using 0w30, and yes, 100% PAO (full synthetic)

:rofl: yea 20w is way to thick. Thats why I use 15W50 :lol:

shazy 03-06-2009 08:02 PM

FFS, rx-7's were recommended with 20w50 and people still went HIGHER!

rux 03-06-2009 08:57 PM


Originally Posted by StealthTL (Post 2900820)
A 20 weight oil is too think and slows down the engine’s ability to move, making the engine work harder
Does anybody on this forum - anybody - think this is correct?

I LOL'ed so hard on this one. Thanks for making my day.

tubingchamp 03-06-2009 09:53 PM

The safest and cleanest oil you can use in your motor is Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

http://img243.imageshack.us/img243/7...3374530ir2.jpg

DOMINION 03-06-2009 09:58 PM

^Can I get a Martini?

tubingchamp 03-06-2009 10:09 PM

^ Here you go, I put one of those olives in it for you too.

http://www.restaurantwidow.com/images/martini.jpg

cajunrx8 03-06-2009 10:33 PM

You all need to go to the Jeepforum.com and read the post - would you spend $200 on a oil filter.
It is a total hoot and shows what good marketing can do for ya! Some of the replys are too damn funny.
The guy who "quote" got that info from a 90 minute talk with the folks at Purepower also does a shit load of reviews on Epinions web site. Check him out if you want his handle is Criteeker.
How can a so called oil expert who has a secret oil that is the shit and filters that never need replacing spread crap like the "S" which is a gasoline oil in a SJ rating means it is trash but a "C" which is for diesels is ok.
What a total waste of air that one is.

nycgps 03-07-2009 01:00 AM


Originally Posted by tubingchamp (Post 2901420)
The safest and cleanest oil you can use in your motor is Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

http://img243.imageshack.us/img243/7...3374530ir2.jpg

IMO, EVOO is only good for salads. not even that great for cooking(boiling point too low) I prefer Peanut oil for cooking. Yum.


Originally Posted by cajunrx8 (Post 2901473)
You all need to go to the Jeepforum.com and read the post - would you spend $200 on a oil filter.
It is a total hoot and shows what good marketing can do for ya! Some of the replys are too damn funny.
The guy who "quote" got that info from a 90 minute talk with the folks at Purepower also does a shit load of reviews on Epinions web site. Check him out if you want his handle is Criteeker.
How can a so called oil expert who has a secret oil that is the shit and filters that never need replacing spread crap like the "S" which is a gasoline oil in a SJ rating means it is trash but a "C" which is for diesels is ok.
What a total waste of air that one is.

Rofl. I want to slap him. seriously.

alz0rz 03-07-2009 01:53 AM

I think only one word is acceptable here.

Fail.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:27 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands