Yes or no...
 

2011 R3. Velocity red. 1871 miles. 27.5k. Too pricey?

yes and no.

Msrp was $32k I think. so yes
I got mine brand new with 80 miles for $25. so no.

Go for it.

Do it

I can't stop thinking about it. I have the money I just wish it was in the 26.5k range. 8's are super cool cars...

Yes
 

Offer something in the low $20ks and see what they say. These cars are heavily discounted due to their gas mileage.

The price your quoting would be a high NEW price. As a used car it should go for less.

I bought my new 2010 GT with 40 miles for $26k and I might have gotten it for less .

You can offer less. The worst that can say is no, or counter

Agreed, you can definitely go lower. Remember that many dealers find the 8 very hard to sell with everyone bitching and moaning about gas. You may have found just the dealer that is looking to get rid of the car and will give you a good price.