RX8Club.com

RX8Club.com (https://www.rx8club.com/)
-   New Member Forum (https://www.rx8club.com/new-member-forum-197/)
-   -   Lowering Fan on Temperature (https://www.rx8club.com/new-member-forum-197/lowering-fan-temperature-249502/)

pelensky 11-12-2013 08:00 PM

Lowering Fan on Temperature
 
I am looking at installing a Mazmart 170 deg stat. I have read about the options to program the ECU for the fan temperatures, but that does not seem like a great options. I also read the rx8performance.com had a kit that could be installed to modify the fan temps.

What are the options to automatically turn the fans on a and off at specific temperatures without reprograming the ECU?

Carbon8 11-12-2013 08:06 PM

Cobb is the best option!

dannobre 11-12-2013 08:40 PM

Without an ECU reprogram the easiest is the RX8Performance fan control kit. You could also wire in an aftermarket fan controller with its own thermostat...but why bother ..the other option is a lot cheaper and easier

04Green 11-13-2013 07:00 AM

Before my cobb, I just changed them to come on low all the time. It worked great. If you can solder, you can do it. Or, if you can pull the fusebox and use the little blue splicer thingies, you can do it.

If you are looking for them to line up with the 170 stat, then they will likely be on all the time anyway unless you live someplace cold.

Carbon8 11-13-2013 07:04 AM

If I am not mistaken the whole purpose of the Mazarmt Tstat is to reach operating temp faster, IMO the fans should not ever operate under 200F. Also keep in mind the only purpose of the fans is for pulling air while not moving, once moving the aerodynamics funnel more air then the fans ever could. So turning them on lower than 200 means that a significant amount of the time your fans will be running but serving no purpose except add extra drain to the system.

pelensky 11-13-2013 07:29 AM

I went to the RX8performance website and could not find the kit. I guess I will call them today.

Does anyone have this kit or know how it functions? For example, is it adjustable and does it have a way to set the fan on and off temp?

One more question about our fans. I think I understood from reading some of the posts that the fans run in either parallel or series to get essentially two speeds. Is that true or does the ecu have some variable speed control?

wcs 11-13-2013 07:34 AM


Originally Posted by Carbon8 (Post 4543686)
If I am not mistaken the whole purpose of the Mazarmt Tstat is to reach operating temp faster, IMO the fans should not ever operate under 200F. Also keep in mind the only purpose of the fans is for pulling air while not moving, once moving the aerodynamics funnel more air then the fans ever could. So turning them on lower than 200 means that a significant amount of the time your fans will be running but serving no purpose except add extra drain to the system.

+1 this

dynamho 11-13-2013 06:07 PM

FWIW, according Racing Beat, a stock car will turn #1 fan on at ~207F and #2 at ~214F.

The stock fan-on temps make me nervous.

Racing Beat flashes have #1 fan turn on at ~189F and #2 at 194F.

Power Control Module (PCM) Flash - Specifications and Technical Information

invasion08 11-13-2013 06:47 PM


Originally Posted by pelensky (Post 4543693)
I went to the RX8performance website and could not find the kit. I guess I will call them today.

Does anyone have this kit or know how it functions? For example, is it adjustable and does it have a way to set the fan on and off temp?

One more question about our fans. I think I understood from reading some of the posts that the fans run in either parallel or series to get essentially two speeds. Is that true or does the ecu have some variable speed control?

Cooling Fan Control Kit by RX-8 Performance | RX8Performance.com

Carbon8 11-13-2013 07:19 PM

Those RB temps make me nervous, optimal operating temp for a Renises is 200F.

Explain the logic behind having the fans on earlier then that :uhh:

Get a Cobb, set it to 200F, increase OMP rates. Get a tune if you want the benefits, and be done with it.

pelensky 11-13-2013 08:03 PM


Originally Posted by invasion08 (Post 4543947)

Thanks. For some reason I was blocked to that before, but I can get to it.

pelensky 11-13-2013 08:04 PM


Originally Posted by Carbon8 (Post 4543959)
Those RB temps make me nervous, optimal operating temp for a Renises is 200F.

Explain the logic behind having the fans on earlier then that :uhh:

Get a Cobb, set it to 200F, increase OMP rates. Get a tune if you want the benefits, and be done with it.

Can you do that right from the Cobb or do you have to have other programs.

Carbon8 11-13-2013 08:12 PM

You can do it all from the Cobb, 300 bucks and your all set, unless you want a tune in which case you can use the preloaded stage 1 for free or get a custom tune from a variety of reputable tuner's (most are members here) for whatever price you two agree upon extra.

Can also disable any CEL's that come up for inspection purposes. IMO the Cobb is the one item every 8 owner should have regardless.

dynamho 11-14-2013 08:23 AM


Originally Posted by Carbon8 (Post 4543959)
Explain the logic behind having the fans on earlier then that :uhh:

I don't know why RB set it that way.
On that info page, it refers to mitigating heat spikes.
I can only guess what heat spikes are in a rotary and when they occur.

Perhaps they wanted to enforce temps within the generally accepted nominal street operating temps of 185-205?

Doesn't water jacket seal failure start at around 220?

Carbon8 11-14-2013 06:42 PM

220 has been seen by some members in extreme climates on track days, with no adverse affects, I would say 240-250 is were catastrophic failure occurs. I also believe you need to worry about the housings warping before the coolant seal fails, the seal itself does not normally just fail the housing warp thus rendering the seal useless and coolant rushes passed

Now I would not recommend anything above 215 for any relative duration of time to be safe, Just saying it has been done. Nor will you ever experience these temps with the OE cooling system unless you have a failure in the system that should be addressed

pelensky 11-14-2013 08:49 PM


Originally Posted by Carbon8 (Post 4543972)
You can do it all from the Cobb, 300 bucks and your all set, unless you want a tune in which case you can use the preloaded stage 1 for free or get a custom tune from a variety of reputable tuner's (most are members here) for whatever price you two agree upon extra.

Can also disable any CEL's that come up for inspection purposes. IMO the Cobb is the one item every 8 owner should have regardless.

When you say "disable CEL's" does that mean permanently tell the ECU to ignore a cat efficiency code as a result of installing a catless midpipe or do you mean just clear the code only to have it come up in another 100 miles?

Carbon8 11-14-2013 08:58 PM


Originally Posted by pelensky (Post 4544425)
When you say "disable CEL's" does that mean permanently tell the ECU to ignore a cat efficiency code as a result of installing a catless midpipe or do you mean just clear the code only to have it come up in another 100 miles?

That one would be correct, Cobb is the only way to do this. Can also perform the same procedure when installing the RB block off plate and deleting the air pump

wcs 11-15-2013 05:04 AM

I don't want to walk on Carbon8's feet here but ...

There's also MazdaEdit software (ME)
And if you go with the Cobb AP you will need to download and the Access Tuner Race software and modify the Stock Style Map with your changes then load it to your ECU
.

More or less same thing with ME

Carbon8 11-15-2013 05:31 AM

WCS,

Is also correct, I believe the Cobb is cheaper, not sure exactly what MazdaEdit runs nowadays or even how it works. Its just not as popular of an option but still very efficient

pelensky 11-15-2013 06:05 AM


Originally Posted by Carbon8 (Post 4544430)
That one would be correct, Cobb is the only way to do this. Can also perform the same procedure when installing the RB block off plate and deleting the air pump

Are there other options to purchase this or is madzamaniac the only one? All I see is the option to buy the unit and the custom calibration service or the base unit. Also, the base cobb unit can do all that you mention and it even has a tune in it for a basically stock car?

I see it $495 but you mention $300. Where can you get one for that?

Carbon8 11-15-2013 06:45 AM

Check the FS section here, thats where I got mine.

This is the only I can see now thats still open, check it every couple of days, have to jump on them quick of you can purchase from MM if you do not want to hunt down a used one.

https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-parts-s...ssport-247892/

pelensky 11-15-2013 12:17 PM


Originally Posted by Carbon8 (Post 4544513)
Check the FS section here, thats where I got mine.

This is the only I can see now thats still open, check it every couple of days, have to jump on them quick of you can purchase from MM if you do not want to hunt down a used one.

https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-parts-s...ssport-247892/

Are there any other sources to buy one new?

RIWWP 11-15-2013 12:21 PM

No, MM is the sole dealer for the RX-8 CobbAP. He worked out a deal with COBB to bring it back after COBB discontinued it.

MazdaEdit is the other option, and that is growing in support and community knowledge/discussion. There are drawbacks for each of them: Who you have to deal with for the AP, and the developing nature of the software for the MazdaEdit

pelensky 11-15-2013 06:06 PM


Originally Posted by RIWWP (Post 4544636)
No, MM is the sole dealer for the RX-8 CobbAP. He worked out a deal with COBB to bring it back after COBB discontinued it.

MazdaEdit is the other option, and that is growing in support and community knowledge/discussion. There are drawbacks for each of them: Who you have to deal with for the AP, and the developing nature of the software for the MazdaEdit

So when you buy a new Cobb it comes with the basic stuff loaded to do the fan temps, OMP, program out CEL for catless. Is it like other tuners (predator for example) where it is married to the car then the stock program resides in the tuner? Also do you have to pay yearly licensing fees to keep the thing working or one time pay and done just like the predator (as long as it is only married to one VIN)?

RIWWP 11-15-2013 06:09 PM

MM's base tune has that stuff, yes, though it's locked and you have to go through him for an changes (which he charges for).

The AP is married to the car, regardless of if the tune is locked or not. It's how the AP works to prevent sharing of APs between cars. You but the device to begin with, you have to pay additional for tuning, and repeat that payment any time you want to get re-tuned.

OR, you buy the device, download the tuning software, get some training/education on how to tune properly and what you do to flip stuff on or off, and do it all yourself with no additional costs (aside from repairing what you might break while you are learning)

I expect the MazdaEdit is paired the same way, but I can't confirm that personally.

pelensky 11-15-2013 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by RIWWP (Post 4544763)
MM's base tune has that stuff, yes, though it's locked and you have to go through him for an changes (which he charges for).

The AP is married to the car, regardless of if the tune is locked or not. It's how the AP works to prevent sharing of APs between cars. You but the device to begin with, you have to pay additional for tuning, and repeat that payment any time you want to get re-tuned.

OR, you buy the device, download the tuning software, get some training/education on how to tune properly and what you do to flip stuff on or off, and do it all yourself with no additional costs (aside from repairing what you might break while you are learning)

I expect the MazdaEdit is paired the same way, but I can't confirm that personally.

Thanks a million for the explanation! I am new the RX8 but have dealt at length with Ford and GM FI engine mods and tuning.

I see on MMs website the custom calibration. So I guess if I go that route it costs me $600 for a new unit (with the custom calibration as you mention above) or buy a used one (unmarried) and then pay something more for the custom calibration (my guess is that it would cost more than $100). Last option is to buy new for $500 or used and buy tuning software. Are you referring to the mazdaedit or are there others?

Also if I bought a used one, are there a few sources other than mazdamaniac to get a simple tune written? If so what are the reliable sources for a simple stock tune?

Carbon8 11-15-2013 06:54 PM

Simple changes like Fan temp, OMP adjustments and blocking CEL's take 5 mins including the time it takes to download map to AP and reflash car. Its very easy to walk someone threw and their are even good reliable map tables here on this forum in regards to OMP rates. Once you get the AP and download ATR its very straight forward.

ATR (Access Tuner Race) program is free from the Cobb website once you get a Cobb AP you just have to enter the serial number to download it. The AP also comes with a stage 1 tune from Cobb already programed that you can use for a simple tune, I believe it mostly just refines throttle response maybe leans out your WOT slightly, not sure on the full details as I never bothered looking at it.

MM is not your only route for AP tuning either, a couple of reputable guys on here charge about the same but IMO go above MM on customer service and in depth explanations of what they are changing so you learn more about what;s going on, they also do not lock the map.. Not that that should give you any reason to change any tables if you do not fully understand the implications associated with doing so.

logalinipoo 11-15-2013 07:35 PM

Also the mazdamaniac service is.

Every other thursday for 2 hours his time. I think it's 6-8 PM arizona time. You comply to his exact demands or he ignores you and doesn't even tell you that you did not comply correctly. If you did it corectly he might ask a few questions then send your tune back or he might just send it back. If he does not get to it then you have to start all over in two more weeks. So If you are the first person online and get your stuff just right you might get two adjustments every two weeks. If not then it's one every two weeks. I don't know how long it will take him to get it.

Most of the thing you are asking about are in his base tune. So you might not even need any tuning, but you can make those with the FREE ATR program very easily.

pelensky 11-15-2013 07:53 PM

Great. Thanks for all the feedback and sharing your experiences. Sounds like I need an unlocked Cobb and use ATR.

logalinipoo 11-15-2013 07:59 PM

What year is your car. I have a copy of 2005 USDM ATR.

You have to have a cobb to use it. So it will not do any good until you get a Cobb.

wcs 11-16-2013 05:36 AM

@logalinipoo
The ATR software is married to the Cobb AP so you'll need a copy of the binaries from the installed ATR version from Pelensky's machine

Basically how I do it is ... I get the person to register and download the ATR software from Cobb. They install the ATR software on to they're PC .... default install location is c:\program files(x86)\accessport\Access Turner Race - MAZDA 2005\

I get the person to ZIP that file directory up and email to me. Unpack and run the TunerRace.exe and Bobs your uncle.
You can now create maps usable for Pelensky's AP device.

@Carbon8
I've not "studied" all the table differences between the Stock Style and Stage 1 maps.
But I do know that the Fuel tables are quite a bit leaner and the Trailing Ignition Map is quite different.

I've seen some scarey lean data logs from members running the Stage 1 map on their modified intake setups.
I don't recommend the Stage 1 if the person has any intake changes other than stock.
(just saying)

pelensky 11-16-2013 08:06 PM

I started looking for a Cobb AP. Do I need a certain revision level or will and V? work? Also are they programed for certain cars (RX8, mazda in general) or do they work on everything? The reason I ask is I see some for sale that was used on a Subaru wrx V2.

RIWWP 11-16-2013 08:11 PM

Each COBB hardware block has firmware that is specific to not only make and model, but often regional variances. Like a COBB AP for European RX-8s usually doesn't work on US RX-8s.

You have 2 options for buying one: buy a new one from MM, or buy a used one from the forums here. They disappear fast, I sold mine in about 6 hours.

(Or buy a Mazdaedit)

logalinipoo 11-17-2013 09:40 AM

@WCS
I did not know that about the software. I know once you install it you tie it to your Accessport, but I still have the origonal install .exe file. I've installed it a couple of times, but always the same AP.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:01 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands