Which do you prefer? I can't decide if I want the stock or MS version (pretty big deal since it's more than a $500 difference :) )

I would take any mazdaspeed part over a stock part but you are right it is all very expensive stuff.

Mazdaspeed spoiler of course

"of course" - it is such as non conditional statement.

I guess if you have appearance package, then it is coming with the stock spoiler?? (not sure :))

But the front dam and side & rear reflector is better for any spoiler - if you are considering it. Then it is ok for a MazdaSpeed spoiler.

It looks gay if you don't have any skirts with MSspoiler.

If you plan not to have no skirt, then I think you should either go for the euro lip or the Ings+1 spoiler.

That is my $.02

MS spoiler all the way... though I have the stock spoiler, I plan on getting a mazdaspeed later on.

I'm thinking about getting the appearance package with it, do you guys think its worth it? For around $970 MSRP, I'm not sure.