RandyP
08-05-2004, 02:55 AM
I decided to use the Tape Hack (http://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=10530&page=1) to get quality sound from my iPod without waiting for a solution integrated with the Head Unit. When I turned it on, it was GREAT! Then I decided to get some power to the iPod - and the trouble began.
I saw a posting about the Monster Charger:
And here is the iPod in the car. I use a Monster Ultra-Low Profile Charger for iPod™ with Dock Connection (http://www.monstercable.com/compute...er.asp?pin=2132) which gets power from the accessory outlet and attaches to the iPod's docking port. It provides line level output which the patch cord plugs into. There's no risk of blowing to the head unit with the signal, since the iPod's volume control doesn't affect the line output. The adaptor includes a voltage inverter, so there isn't any noise from ground looping. I get perfect sound.I happened to buy my tape unit from ectomort, so I read this and bought one. What a disaster!
I don't know what the difference is between ectomort's installation and mine, but I got sound so terrible that it hurt my ears. The audio was broken and distorted, and a high-pitched whine was produced whenever the engine got over 3500 RPM or so. I checked ectomort's post again, and yes, I'd bought the same unit he referred to. (Note - ectomort, why do you feel there is an inverter inside the Monster unit? I googled it but the only references to the unit and "inverter" are in your post.)
How bad is it? I made a 80-second sample of Joni Mitchell's "Both Sides Now", switching between internal iPod battery, the Monster, and the solution that works for me. iPod volume at 50%, earphone output to tape unit, Bose amp at 28. Click the link to hear for yourself: Audio Test (http://www.eldoradosoft.com/temp/jm.mp3)
0:00.0 - 20 second intro on internal iPod battery
0:20.7 - "I'm plugging in the Monster"
0:23.1 - Monster plugged into iPod, audio gets dirty
0:26.7 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
0:28.4 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
0:36.7 - "I'm taking off the Monster"
0:38.1 - Monster unplugged, audio gets clear again
0:42.6 - "The Apple supply"
0:44.6 - Apple power supply plugged in, perfect audio
0:48.5 - "There's no difference"
0:51.7 - Rev engine, no whine
0:53.8 - Rev engine, no whine
0:58.3 - "The Monster" (seems appropriate)
1:01.5 - Monster plugged in, audio degenerates
1:03.1 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
1:04.7 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
1:05.7 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
1:07.6 - Monster unplugged for the last time
1:08.8 - "The Apple"
1:10.0 - Apple power supply plugged in[/COLOR]
I have no idea why ectomort would have perfect audio with the Monster, but you can hear clearly that mine sucked. I was bummed, to say the least. I started searching for "noise" and came up with the suggestion to use a Radio Shack "Ground Loop Isolator".
I can't say I felt good putting a $15 piece of Radio Shack low-end audio equipment between my iPod and my ears. But I had read it about it a lot, both here and at iPodLounge, so I bought one and hooked it up. What a total disappointment, yet again! The thing absorbs nearly all the high frequencies and attenuates the whole signal. I made a recording of "Wildflowers" (http://www.eldoradosoft.com/temp/wf.mp3) by Dolly Parton, Emmylou Harris and Linda Ronstadt, comparing the same passage with and without the GLI. iPod volume at 75%, earphone output to tape unit, Bose amp at 25; second half is with the GLI. I can't believe people would drop a few hundred for the quality of an iPod and then rub it into the mud with a GLI. You can see the loss in amplitude easily:
http://www.eldoradosoft.com/temp/Wildflowers.gif
I felt like I'd have to wait for a digital solution to get good, powered audio from my iPod. Then I recalled a forum member who said an inverter followed by a power supply worked for him. I grabbed a Linksys Power2Go I had laying around the house, plugged in the standard Apple iPod Charger... and got the Holy Grail of Undistorted Audio!
How good is it? Listen to the Joni Mitchell clip to hear a direct comparison of the Monster and the Inverter/Apple solution.
I found a great place to install the inverter and iPod charger: the nearly useless CD compartment behind the cupholders. I've posted some DIY images to show how nicely it all fits.
I saw a posting about the Monster Charger:
And here is the iPod in the car. I use a Monster Ultra-Low Profile Charger for iPod™ with Dock Connection (http://www.monstercable.com/compute...er.asp?pin=2132) which gets power from the accessory outlet and attaches to the iPod's docking port. It provides line level output which the patch cord plugs into. There's no risk of blowing to the head unit with the signal, since the iPod's volume control doesn't affect the line output. The adaptor includes a voltage inverter, so there isn't any noise from ground looping. I get perfect sound.I happened to buy my tape unit from ectomort, so I read this and bought one. What a disaster!
I don't know what the difference is between ectomort's installation and mine, but I got sound so terrible that it hurt my ears. The audio was broken and distorted, and a high-pitched whine was produced whenever the engine got over 3500 RPM or so. I checked ectomort's post again, and yes, I'd bought the same unit he referred to. (Note - ectomort, why do you feel there is an inverter inside the Monster unit? I googled it but the only references to the unit and "inverter" are in your post.)
How bad is it? I made a 80-second sample of Joni Mitchell's "Both Sides Now", switching between internal iPod battery, the Monster, and the solution that works for me. iPod volume at 50%, earphone output to tape unit, Bose amp at 28. Click the link to hear for yourself: Audio Test (http://www.eldoradosoft.com/temp/jm.mp3)
0:00.0 - 20 second intro on internal iPod battery
0:20.7 - "I'm plugging in the Monster"
0:23.1 - Monster plugged into iPod, audio gets dirty
0:26.7 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
0:28.4 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
0:36.7 - "I'm taking off the Monster"
0:38.1 - Monster unplugged, audio gets clear again
0:42.6 - "The Apple supply"
0:44.6 - Apple power supply plugged in, perfect audio
0:48.5 - "There's no difference"
0:51.7 - Rev engine, no whine
0:53.8 - Rev engine, no whine
0:58.3 - "The Monster" (seems appropriate)
1:01.5 - Monster plugged in, audio degenerates
1:03.1 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
1:04.7 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
1:05.7 - Rev engine, high-pitched whine
1:07.6 - Monster unplugged for the last time
1:08.8 - "The Apple"
1:10.0 - Apple power supply plugged in[/COLOR]
I have no idea why ectomort would have perfect audio with the Monster, but you can hear clearly that mine sucked. I was bummed, to say the least. I started searching for "noise" and came up with the suggestion to use a Radio Shack "Ground Loop Isolator".
I can't say I felt good putting a $15 piece of Radio Shack low-end audio equipment between my iPod and my ears. But I had read it about it a lot, both here and at iPodLounge, so I bought one and hooked it up. What a total disappointment, yet again! The thing absorbs nearly all the high frequencies and attenuates the whole signal. I made a recording of "Wildflowers" (http://www.eldoradosoft.com/temp/wf.mp3) by Dolly Parton, Emmylou Harris and Linda Ronstadt, comparing the same passage with and without the GLI. iPod volume at 75%, earphone output to tape unit, Bose amp at 25; second half is with the GLI. I can't believe people would drop a few hundred for the quality of an iPod and then rub it into the mud with a GLI. You can see the loss in amplitude easily:
http://www.eldoradosoft.com/temp/Wildflowers.gif
I felt like I'd have to wait for a digital solution to get good, powered audio from my iPod. Then I recalled a forum member who said an inverter followed by a power supply worked for him. I grabbed a Linksys Power2Go I had laying around the house, plugged in the standard Apple iPod Charger... and got the Holy Grail of Undistorted Audio!
How good is it? Listen to the Joni Mitchell clip to hear a direct comparison of the Monster and the Inverter/Apple solution.
I found a great place to install the inverter and iPod charger: the nearly useless CD compartment behind the cupholders. I've posted some DIY images to show how nicely it all fits.