View Full Version : My Long Drive
zeru57 11-03-2009, 10:12 AM A couple months ago I got a new job and became the proud owner of a 140-mile round trip commute. See the attached image for a map.
The trip is between Columbus and Athens Ohio on mostly 4-lane highway, some of it limited access. As you approach Columbus, the terrain flattens out, but from about Lancaster on down you're going up the Appalachian plateau. Lots of light but interesting curves and elevation changes, gorgeous scenery, and not much traffic, truck or otherwise.
And of course I do it in my 8. I debated back and forth about taking my wife's Saturn SL2, but then decided if I was going to be in the car for 2 and a half hours each day on that topography, it may as well be in one that's more comfortable and fun.
Gas right now isn't too much of an issue. I am getting about 280 miles on 13.5 gallons - about 20.5 mpg. I'm using 87 octane. I keep speeds between 68-72 to save on gas (going 74 on the limited access portions takes mpg down to 19.5) and not get smoked by the fuzz. I've got a BP credit card that gives me 5% off and every month they send me a little check.
Let me also say that I'm running Goodyear GT tires, which are great in the rain (and snow?) but big and heavy. I think I'm taking about a 2-3 mpg hit by running them as opposed to the crappy nankangs I had on it before. On really tight turns there's a bit of rubbing, so I'm wondering if I should maybe drop down to 17's next time around if I stay with this tire.
Anyway, you can all do the math regarding how much mileage I put on the car. The car has 86.6k on it as of this moment. For maintenance, I'm using Royal Purple 10w-40 at the absolute longest drain interval recommended by the manual.
Problems? None so far. I've had the car for about 35k at this point and have only had to do routine maintenance. I keep the oil topped off, rotate the tires, redline at least once a day and check everything else on the car weekly. I'm hopeful that the relatively light duty will keep the engine running longer as opposed to shorter.
Costs compared to driving a car like the SL2 for a long commute like mine? Assuming the SL got 36mpg, I'd say I'm spending about $2k/year more in fuel at today's prices. If gas goes up to $4 a gallon it would be $3k. Let's assume I do plugs once a year compared to once every two years for the SL, $20 cheaper oil changes, brakes and tires being roughly twice the cost, and insurance We'll add on another $600-$1k a year for maintenance over the cheaper car. So I spend about $3k-5k more each year than I "have to" to drive this car.
As of right now, it's worth it to me. I love how it drives, and I'm glad I get to stretch it out a little more (which I totally didn't get to do on I-70 which is flat and straight). It's nice to spend a little more time with it a day closer to it's element (curves).
JinDesu 11-03-2009, 10:29 AM That's one hell of a daily trip!
adamwzl 11-03-2009, 11:03 AM If your ok will racking up the miles on your car that quickly then more the power to you man.
I for one have a long commute. 110 mile round trip, and I have a seperate beater for the occasion.
I'm just too scared to use the 8 as my DD for such a long haul.
fyrstormer 11-03-2009, 11:28 AM That right there is when you pack up and move.
RyansRx8 11-03-2009, 11:33 AM Your using 87 octane???
zeru57 11-03-2009, 11:38 AM That right there is when you pack up and move.
Mrs. Mateo has a specialized job - it wouldn't be the easiest thing to just up and move.
Your using 87 octane???
Yep.
adamwzl 11-03-2009, 11:40 AM That right there is when you pack up and move.
Not that easy in this economy... right now.
Kaiser bun 11-03-2009, 05:48 PM Your using 87 octane???
^ is this true? Just for the record i would get some premium in that poor 8 before it leaves you for a different owner.
zeru57 11-03-2009, 05:52 PM ^ is this true? Just for the record i would get some premium in that poor 8 before it leaves you for a different owner.
What's wrong with 87?
Spinning Sushi 11-03-2009, 05:57 PM Nothing is wrong with using 87, these idiots just don't know anything.
Kaiser bun 11-03-2009, 06:01 PM read the manual, "This vehicle is designed to use 91 [(R+M)/2 method] (96RON) or higher gasoline for best performance. If [fuel i said the first time] is not availiable, gasoline from 87-90 can be used temporarily for emergency purposes, buth this will slightly reduce performance. Fuel with gasoline from 87-90, when driving in high temperature or low humidity conditions could cause engine knocking.
... it goes on, look in your owners manual in the index and go to fuel requirements.
jones75254 11-03-2009, 06:45 PM ....I for one have a long commute. 110 mile round trip, and I have a seperate beater for the occasion.
I'm just too scared to use the 8 as my DD for such a long haul.
+1 on that. My last job was only a 45 mile commute and i bought a beater for THAT. Couldnt imagine 170 miles
zeru57 11-03-2009, 07:53 PM read the manual . . . .... it goes on, look in your owners manual in the index and go to fuel requirements.
That's interesting, my manual says "You may use a regular unleaded fuel with an Octane Rating from 87 to 90 but this will slightly reduce performance." Then again, the manual also says "don't use gasoline additives" and I'm premixing (2-4oz/tank).
I've read a lot about octane ratings on this forum and elsewhere. I ran 93 for a while. 91. 89. 87. I didn't detect much difference between the grades. There's no pinging, knocking, or timing change that I can detect. If there was, I would up it. I didn't even need to pull the room fuse when I went to 87. If performance suffers, I don't notice it.
So, at this point, I'm comfortable with my decision. I don't think my car will leave me. But if I do asplode the engine, I'll be sure to let everyone here know.
For others, I can understand not wanting to put a lot of miles on a nice car, but are some of you guys really that worried about your engines blowing that you won't drive it 70 miles one way on a daily basis?
Regarding the drive, my old commute was 33 miles one way, with 2/3 of that on I-70. It was flat, straight, and miserable. I hated it. Now, even though I'm going twice as far, I'm in the country, the road is curvy, open, and uncluttered. It is wonderful. It's down right enjoyable most days.
iwc3707 11-03-2009, 08:05 PM Required fuel Premium unleaded (91 octane) according to '10 brochure.
If you can't afford the $3.40 per tankful extra, maybe you can cut out a starbucks latte once per week.
Nothing is wrong with using 87, these idiots just don't know anything. This is coming from a person who doesn't even own a rx8 and owns a Toyota Camry.
Kaiser bun 11-03-2009, 08:07 PM BTW if i had to commute 170 miles a day, i would love to have the rx8, great cruising car IMO (got off subject on the whole gas thing)
rot8te 11-03-2009, 11:06 PM My daily commute is from Brooklyn to Manhattan, about 7 miles each way, although some mornings I bet it takes you less time. My last tank, 11.4 MPG. Thanks NYC traffic ( there was a ton on traffic last week because of construction).
Anyway, that's a hell of a commute. While I understand why some would want a beater, I commend you on your choice to have some fun on your way to work.
fyrstormer 11-04-2009, 12:32 AM Running low octane will only cause problems when the engine is at high risk of experiencing detonation, i.e. when the ignition timing is most advanced and the housing is hottest and the compression is highest due to the throttle being fully open. I don't know to what extent this engine can adjust ignition timing to compensate for lower octane, but that's usually the approach they use to prevent detonation.
Any chance I can find out what Mrs. Mateo's really specialized job is? You've piqued my curiosity now. Maybe something with the gummint?
ei8ht 11-04-2009, 05:51 AM Wowzers and I thought I had a long drive into Cleveland each day. 98 miles round trip.
I'm getting 18.5 Mpg but I look at it more as cost per mile.
Right now I get 6.5 miles per dollar. That is $15 per day or $75 a week for gas not to
mention ware and tare. (oil too) $300 a month is almost a car payment. LOL.
But its the cost of running high class.
Once the snow comes I'll put the RX8 up and go back to the del Sol, it gets 35Mpg on regular.
zeru57 11-04-2009, 07:42 AM Running low octane will only cause problems when the engine is at high risk of experiencing detonation, i.e. when the ignition timing is most advanced and the housing is hottest and the compression is highest due to the throttle being fully open. I don't know to what extent this engine can adjust ignition timing to compensate for lower octane, but that's usually the approach they use to prevent detonation.
And those conditions don't exist to a great extent with the style of driving I do, outside the odd redline. One thing I've wondered about is the "rate" of redlining. Everyone says redline once a day, but what about when your mileage goes up? Should you do it more? Depending on the day, I'll get between 1-4 redlines depending on lights I hit. Is that enough for 140 miles of highway driving? :dunno:
Any chance I can find out what Mrs. Mateo's really specialized job is? You've piqued my curiosity now. Maybe something with the gummint?
Mrs. Mateo is an Italian teacher at a Catholic school. When she got hired, she took one of about 20 full time jobs in Ohio, and the only one that was open in Central Ohio at the time. All things considered, she's got a decent gig, but it's not like being a Spanish teacher where you could just up and get a job anywhere.
zeru57 11-04-2009, 07:47 AM Wowzers and I thought I had a long drive into Cleveland each day. 98 miles round trip.
I'm getting 18.5 Mpg but I look at it more as cost per mile.
Right now I get 6.5 miles per dollar. That is $15 per day or $75 a week for gas not to
mention ware and tare. (oil too) $300 a month is almost a car payment. LOL.
But its the cost of running high class.
Once the snow comes I'll put the RX8 up and go back to the del Sol, it gets 35Mpg on regular.
Ugh, do you have to deal with the nightmare that is the Shoreway? I grew up in Chardon, so I know the area pretty well.
Thankfully I'm driving against traffic. I think I would cut myself if it was the other way around.
I'm around $100/week for gas. And yes, it is more than my car payment. And it will only go up! :icon_no2:
zeru57 11-04-2009, 07:50 AM My daily commute is from Brooklyn to Manhattan, about 7 miles each way, although some mornings I bet it takes you less time. My last tank, 11.4 MPG. Thanks NYC traffic ( there was a ton on traffic last week because of construction).
I can't say I envy you in that regard. Your monthly parking bill alone probably is more than what I spend on gas. Plus having to sit in traffic.
But you are ballin' in NYC, so that counts for something.
JinDesu 11-04-2009, 09:16 AM And those conditions don't exist to a great extent with the style of driving I do, outside the odd redline. One thing I've wondered about is the "rate" of redlining. Everyone says redline once a day, but what about when your mileage goes up? Should you do it more? Depending on the day, I'll get between 1-4 redlines depending on lights I hit. Is that enough for 140 miles of highway driving? :dunno:
To answer that, you just got to understand the purpose of redlining. By reaching redline, you are opening up all the ports and pushing any carbon buildup on those ports out with your exhaust. So generally, you should redline at the end of any trip (to and from), so when you off the car and leave it, the carbon doesn't settle as much.
I personally try to get to my redline a little bit after my car warms up, and a little while before I reach my destination. This ensures my ports are cleared (better MPG, I'm guessing) before the bulk of my travel, and also keeps it clear after the long driving. Of course, since I am young and invincible, I try to keep my car running at the upper rpms, and redline to pass people anyways.
Roaddemon 11-04-2009, 09:34 AM A couple months ago I got a new job and became the proud owner of a 140-mile round trip commute. See the attached image for a map.
The trip is between Columbus and Athens Ohio on mostly 4-lane highway, some of it limited access. As you approach Columbus, the terrain flattens out, but from about Lancaster on down you're going up the Appalachian plateau. Lots of light but interesting curves and elevation changes, gorgeous scenery, and not much traffic, truck or otherwise.
And of course I do it in my 8. I debated back and forth about taking my wife's Saturn SL2, but then decided if I was going to be in the car for 2 and a half hours each day on that topography, it may as well be in one that's more comfortable and fun.
Gas right now isn't too much of an issue. I am getting about 280 miles on 13.5 gallons - about 20.5 mpg. I'm using 87 octane. I keep speeds between 68-72 to save on gas (going 74 on the limited access portions takes mpg down to 19.5) and not get smoked by the fuzz. I've got a BP credit card that gives me 5% off and every month they send me a little check.
Let me also say that I'm running Goodyear GT tires, which are great in the rain (and snow?) but big and heavy. I think I'm taking about a 2-3 mpg hit by running them as opposed to the crappy nankangs I had on it before. On really tight turns there's a bit of rubbing, so I'm wondering if I should maybe drop down to 17's next time around if I stay with this tire.
Anyway, you can all do the math regarding how much mileage I put on the car. The car has 86.6k on it as of this moment. For maintenance, I'm using Royal Purple 10w-40 at the absolute longest drain interval recommended by the manual.
Problems? None so far. I've had the car for about 35k at this point and have only had to do routine maintenance. I keep the oil topped off, rotate the tires, redline at least once a day and check everything else on the car weekly. I'm hopeful that the relatively light duty will keep the engine running longer as opposed to shorter.
Costs compared to driving a car like the SL2 for a long commute like mine? Assuming the SL got 36mpg, I'd say I'm spending about $2k/year more in fuel at today's prices. If gas goes up to $4 a gallon it would be $3k. Let's assume I do plugs once a year compared to once every two years for the SL, $20 cheaper oil changes, brakes and tires being roughly twice the cost, and insurance We'll add on another $600-$1k a year for maintenance over the cheaper car. So I spend about $3k-5k more each year than I "have to" to drive this car.
As of right now, it's worth it to me. I love how it drives, and I'm glad I get to stretch it out a little more (which I totally didn't get to do on I-70 which is flat and straight). It's nice to spend a little more time with it a day closer to it's element (curves).
The Saturn is cheap build with a good engine. Those miles would cause the trim to fall apart. You are spending 3hrs a day in a car and work hard for your money. You deserve The most fun getting there. I can't imagine doing it in a boring economy car. I do not blame you for taking the rx8. You can always trade off now and then to keep the miles and cost down on your 8. I feel sorry for people who have young children and work. Day care is like $45 a day. Your costs are minimal in comparison.
maxxdamigz 11-04-2009, 09:59 AM Personally, I wouldn't devote 12 hours a day to work. The cost of driving would be secondary. 8 hours work, 1 hour lunch, 3 hours driving... But I used to do 60 miles a day in traffic in the 8 (maybe 1.5 hours in the car a day) and it was livable.
JinDesu 11-04-2009, 10:09 AM Personally, I wouldn't devote 12 hours a day to work. The cost of driving would be secondary. 8 hours work, 1 hour lunch, 3 hours driving... But I used to do 60 miles a day in traffic in the 8 (maybe 1.5 hours in the car a day) and it was livable.
Depends on the road too. If it was pure traffic the whole way, that would suck. But if there was a section of road (maybe the scenic view) that was just a blast to drive, I would love do that every day. Just push it a little harder every day.... :D
maxxdamigz 11-04-2009, 10:19 AM My car has been from NJ to Boston, to Bufalo, to Myrtle Beach, to Columbus, to Cleveland, and to Detroit. Really even on open fun road, I only have about a 30 minute attention span. Besides, the more fun the road is, the lower my mpg. 140 miles a day at 8-10 mpg would hurt the wallet something fierce.
JinDesu 11-04-2009, 10:22 AM That is true; I don't have a daily car commute so I haven't had the shock of bad mpg hitting my wallet yet.
zeru57 11-04-2009, 10:24 AM Personally, I wouldn't devote 12 hours a day to work. The cost of driving would be secondary. 8 hours work, 1 hour lunch, 3 hours driving... But I used to do 60 miles a day in traffic in the 8 (maybe 1.5 hours in the car a day) and it was livable.
I work through lunch. Can't say it's optimal. But it is better than a 12 hour day.
And like I said, the drive is helped by being fun with minimal traffic. The limited access portion of road around Hocking Hills is great fun.
maxxdamigz 11-04-2009, 10:31 AM Hmmm - Hocking Hills - ever drive 664? It's more of a North South road but I have had some fun on that stretch. The only issue is it's so fun and still a 55 that the combination of road banking, gravel/dirt run off into the road from driveways/hillside, and the constant rolling hills can make it a little dangerous. On that road I have to keep telling myself that it's not a race track and if I hit any gravel in the road at the speeds I want to go, I'll be an aluminum stain on a tree somewhere.
zeru57 11-04-2009, 10:49 AM Hmmm - Hocking Hills - ever drive 664? It's more of a North South road but I have had some fun on that stretch. The only issue is it's so fun and still a 55 that the combination of road banking, gravel/dirt run off into the road from driveways/hillside, and the constant rolling hills can make it a little dangerous. On that road I have to keep telling myself that it's not a race track and if I hit any gravel in the road at the speeds I want to go, I'll be an aluminum stain on a tree somewhere.
I've never driven 664, but I very much want to.
Another 4 laner is Rt-35 between Chillicothe and Jackson. 4 lanes of new, semi-limited access with lots of banking and elevation change. The temptation to achieve sustained speeds of well over 100mph is overwhelming. I keep meaning to drive it some lonely Saturday or Sunday morning at sunrise.
jefecito87 11-04-2009, 10:49 AM cheap gas is not cool on mine at least i get some funky noises on it i only use it when im broke and have a long highway trip that i can just use a little and be back down to empty when i get home plus it feels so sluggish i gues you have to be madddd in tune to feel it even my girlfriend notices when i use cheap gas and she yells not to cause she knows now how it feels on 93 its so much smoother and it gets better mileage i mean like 4 or 5 but hey the car drinks gas as it is any little is best always using cheap gas i feel is bad doesnt matter how much power it has i have a paseo for emergency use and when i drive it i use 87 when i use 93 it feels stronger and i get better mileage too even though that little thing gets like 35 as it is
maxxdamigz 11-04-2009, 11:02 AM cheap gas is not cool on mine at least i get some funky noises on it i only use it when im broke and have a long highway trip that i can just use a little and be back down to empty when i get home plus it feels so sluggish i gues you have to be madddd in tune to feel it even my girlfriend notices when i use cheap gas and she yells not to cause she knows now how it feels on 93 its so much smoother and it gets better mileage i mean like 4 or 5 but hey the car drinks gas as it is any little is best always using cheap gas i feel is bad doesnt matter how much power it has i have a paseo for emergency use and when i drive it i use 87 when i use 93 it feels stronger and i get better mileage too even though that little thing gets like 35 as it is
Brought to you by the good people of Minnesota and Google. (http://www.state.mn.us/mn/externalDocs/Commerce/Gasoline_Octane_Facts_102902052227_OctaneFacts.pdf )
One caveat - engine manufacturers build in a margin of error. If I make a product that works on A 100% of the time and B 90% of the time, I will recommend A because I don't need 10% of my customers giving me flack. The Renny can knock on regular but a good quality regular at mild usage and mild temperatures is probably as safe as 91 in Arizona during the summer. The real question is - does it knock or ping or not?
fyrstormer 11-04-2009, 03:18 PM The Saturn is cheap build with a good engine. Those miles would cause the trim to fall apart. You are spending 3hrs a day in a car and work hard for your money. You deserve The most fun getting there. I can't imagine doing it in a boring economy car. I do not blame you for taking the rx8. You can always trade off now and then to keep the miles and cost down on your 8. I feel sorry for people who have young children and work. Day care is like $45 a day. Your costs are minimal in comparison.The little tyke's grandparents are free though, if you can get 'em.
fyrstormer 11-04-2009, 03:20 PM cheap gas is not cool on mine at least i get some funky noises on it i only use it when im broke and have a long highway trip that i can just use a little and be back down to empty when i get home plus it feels so sluggish i gues you have to be madddd in tune to feel it even my girlfriend notices when i use cheap gas and she yells not to cause she knows now how it feels on 93 its so much smoother and it gets better mileage i mean like 4 or 5 but hey the car drinks gas as it is any little is best always using cheap gas i feel is bad doesnt matter how much power it has i have a paseo for emergency use and when i drive it i use 87 when i use 93 it feels stronger and i get better mileage too even though that little thing gets like 35 as it isJesus H. Christ, someone get this guy a keyboard with functioning period comma, and shift keys. Look at him, struggling to communicate without them. Poor fella. :sadwavey:
zeru57 02-04-2010, 09:25 AM Wanted to give an update on the condition of my car, and figured this place was as good as any. Last week, I started getting the CEL for the SSV (the secondary intake port valve, or the "manual tuning valve" as the CEL would have it) being stuck open. About a month or so ago I noticed it sticking (didn't put two and two together at the time though), so I suspect at this point the carbon has built up so that the valve is now stuck. Thankfully it is stuck open, which doesn't have too much effect on the performance of the car either way. Suck closed, and life would suck. At some point in the next month I'll take a Saturday to remove the SSV and clean it out (DIY is located elsewhere on rx8club).
Anyway, I've done about 18k miles on this long drive so far. In the winter time, I suspect the intake doesn't heat up as much as it would in the summer, which could inhibit the carbon deposits shaking off. Also, I had to cut my redlining down to once or twice a day for a while because of road conditions.
So - did the long drive with limited redlining cause enough carbon to build up and finally stick the SSV? I think it could have. Then again, the car has 94k on it, and I don't know how it was treated the first 52k. So I'm sure the cumulative effect of engine use has a role to play, too.
I do think you could draw the conclusion that a long drive like mine requires more diligent redlining than shorter trips might, particularly in cold weather.
ObliqueFD 02-05-2010, 12:13 AM I can't believe you make that long of a commute. I used to commute from Lancaster to Athens for class at Ohio University and I thought it was a bit much. The drive is nice, but it definitely gets old.
I think you should try using higher octane fuel to help burn off some of that carbon build up. You can also try alcohol injection. I'm not very familiar with it, but it is my understanding that it helps keep rotaries running strong and clean.
|
|