View Full Version : GI: engine cleaning meet
rx8thunder 03-25-2009, 11:50 AM Hey guys, anyone interested in cleaning the inside of their engine with seafoam (http://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=142852&highlight=seafoam)? Good opportunity for a meet? I will help organize if there is interest...
rotarygreg 03-25-2009, 12:37 PM Hey guys, anyone interested in cleaning the inside of their engine with seafoam (http://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=142852&highlight=seafoam)? Good opportunity for a meet? I will help organize if there is interest...
guys, i personally would advise against this. get your dealer to do this. a very important part of the procedure of cleaning out the engine is after its all done, using the mazda computer to go in and manually crank up the OMP from about 3 (at idle) all the way up to 60 and let it run like that for 15mins IIRC. That is very important and its not something you can do unless you have all the mazda compter system and software at your disposal. just my two cents.
mazdasp33d 03-25-2009, 01:01 PM guys, i personally would advise against this. get your dealer to do this. a very important part of the procedure of cleaning out the engine is after its all done, using the mazda computer to go in and manually crank up the OMP from about 3 (at idle) all the way up to 60 and let it run like that for 15mins IIRC. That is very important and its not something you can do unless you have all the mazda compter system and software at your disposal. just my two cents.
can somebody else elaborate on this?
Thumper3322 03-25-2009, 01:02 PM Think this is an important thing to do? I mean one hard day at the track should clean everything out no??
TheWulf 03-25-2009, 01:13 PM If you're worried about needing more oil from the OMP you could always just toss in some premix.
Footman 03-25-2009, 01:16 PM Man, when I read this title, I was thinking about "engine bay detailing" :lol:....knowing me.... :lol: I would!
rx8thunder 03-25-2009, 02:12 PM Greg, it seems like a lot of people have done this themselves without a hitch. What exactly is the risk? Engine damage?
If you have a cobb, can't really hook up to the computer, right?
prospectjtaz 03-25-2009, 02:24 PM Just to put it out there, this aint happening on my street. The install meets with everyone's victory laps were pushing it, this would topple it
rx8thunder 03-25-2009, 02:54 PM Maybe we could do this in conjunction with an RPM meet?
I'M IN!
Already asked my local stealership to order me some seafoam
rotarygreg 03-25-2009, 07:25 PM basically with that engine cleaner you have flushed out every bit of lubrication in there (as well as any carbon buildup which is the point). cranking up the OMP manually will make sure its good and lubricated. I will definitly come out and help out with this sort of meet, but the only way im taking the zoom zoom cleaner to my engine is if its followed by cranking up the OMP for the suggested time. thats just the way i see it. i know alot of guys do this without a hitch and whatnot, but i wont risk it myself.
Thumper3322 03-26-2009, 08:56 AM After reading what Greg has said I think I will let the dealership do it. Greg think it is really necessary? It was recommended to me at my last check up, but said don't worry about it since I redline every day and push my car hard when I can. They didn't seem to question it.
01Racing 03-26-2009, 11:15 AM If you do it in your driveway and have a problem, dont go to you dealer looking for warranty help!
rx8thunder 03-26-2009, 11:18 AM Al, any way of offering this service to a group of us at a special price? Make a day of it. Maybe a Sunday???
jmc23200 03-26-2009, 11:47 AM You can seafoam in your driveway with no problems just a little different then the dealer. This is in the DIY instructions.
"18)Make sure no one is around, cuz its gonna smell. FIRE THE BABY UP ! At this time, you can let the engine suck about 1/8 cup of CLEAN ENGINE OIL or 2 Stroke oil premix into the nipple for extra lubrication. Its going to smell really bad and you'll see TONS of white smoke out of your exhaust ... See pictures."
Full instructions here: http://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=142852
By doing this, and premixing(which mostof us do anyway) you will be fine. You would be directly lubricating the internals.
rotarygreg 03-26-2009, 12:49 PM You can seafoam in your driveway with no problems just a little different then the dealer. This is in the DIY instructions.
"18)Make sure no one is around, cuz its gonna smell. FIRE THE BABY UP ! At this time, you can let the engine suck about 1/8 cup of CLEAN ENGINE OIL or 2 Stroke oil premix into the nipple for extra lubrication. Its going to smell really bad and you'll see TONS of white smoke out of your exhaust ... See pictures."
Full instructions here: http://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=142852
By doing this, and premixing(which mostof us do anyway) you will be fine. You would be directly lubricating the internals.
that is alright i guess, but the fact is that the OMP injects oil directly onto the apex seals if im not mistaken. directly lubricating the parts taht need it where as dumping a hole bunch of unmetered 2 stroke into the engine while its running just douses everything. again, im not saying that doing this yourself is a sure fire way to kill your car or anything, im just saying from what i know that ithere is no way i would do this in my driveway at home.
jmc23200 03-26-2009, 01:20 PM that is alright i guess, but the fact is that the OMP injects oil directly onto the apex seals if im not mistaken. directly lubricating the parts taht need it where as dumping a hole bunch of unmetered 2 stroke into the engine while its running just douses everything. again, im not saying that doing this yourself is a sure fire way to kill your car or anything, im just saying from what i know that ithere is no way i would do this in my driveway at home.
Where do you think those ports ultimately lead to? Adding 1 ounce(1/8 of a cup) slowly into your engine through the ports is going to have the same result. When doing this you dont have the engine suck it up as fast as possible. Everything is done slowly. I think you are overly concerned.
I may be wrong about this but its al I could find on the OMP. The OMP injects .04 quarts of oil into the engine for every Gallon of gasoline. That means you get about .00222 quarts injected into your engine for every 1 mile you drive(roughly, using 18mpg average).
You are claiming that Mazda increases the OMP injection by 2000% which would mean that the OMP goes from .00222 quarts every mile to .0444 quarts every mile. Idling for 15 minutes would burn approx. 1/10 of a gallon at .0444 quarts of oil per gallon. After a little more math, you can calculate that you have injected .07 cups of oil in that 15 minute time period. We will call this .1 cups of oil. So, instead of adding 24 milliliters of oil in 15 minutes(1/10 of a cup), you would add 29 milliliters of oil over 5 minutes(1/8 a cup).
All in all, same out come, shorter period of time, the engine will be fine and will have proper lubrication.
rotarygreg 03-26-2009, 08:38 PM Where do you think those ports ultimately lead to? Adding 1 ounce(1/8 of a cup) slowly into your engine through the ports is going to have the same result. When doing this you dont have the engine suck it up as fast as possible. Everything is done slowly. I think you are overly concerned.
I may be wrong about this but its al I could find on the OMP. The OMP injects .04 quarts of oil into the engine for every Gallon of gasoline. That means you get about .00222 quarts injected into your engine for every 1 mile you drive(roughly, using 18mpg average).
You are claiming that Mazda increases the OMP injection by 2000% which would mean that the OMP goes from .00222 quarts every mile to .0444 quarts every mile. Idling for 15 minutes would burn approx. 1/10 of a gallon at .0444 quarts of oil per gallon. After a little more math, you can calculate that you have injected .07 cups of oil in that 15 minute time period. We will call this .1 cups of oil. So, instead of adding 24 milliliters of oil in 15 minutes(1/10 of a cup), you would add 29 milliliters of oil over 5 minutes(1/8 a cup).
All in all, same out come, shorter period of time, the engine will be fine and will have proper lubrication.
okay, the big difference in my mind is that the OMP injection is timed to spray onto the apex seal as far as i understand. your method has the oil just coming through the intake port when the rotor passes the SIDE intake port. this oil will be all over the rotor face and possibly side seals and not on the apex seals which is mainly where you want it.
jmc23200 03-27-2009, 09:38 AM okay, the big difference in my mind is that the OMP injection is timed to spray onto the apex seal as far as i understand. your method has the oil just coming through the intake port when the rotor passes the SIDE intake port. this oil will be all over the rotor face and possibly side seals and not on the apex seals which is mainly where you want it.
If you are putting Seafoam into your engine THROUGH the side ports, does this remove the lubrication from the apex seals aswell as everywhere else inside your engine?
What you are stating is that the seafoam enters the engine through the side ports and removes all lubrication even off of the apex seals. So, how does it remove the lubrication from the apex seals if it never gets to the apex seals? Your statements contradict one another. If the seafoam can remove lubrication then the oil can provide lubrication to all the same parts.
rx8thunder 03-27-2009, 10:17 AM ^ It sounds to me like the only difference is the metering of how much oil gets added when
jmc23200 03-27-2009, 10:37 AM ^ It sounds to me like the only difference is the metering of how much oil gets added when
That I do agree with and between premixing, for extra lubrication, and adding some oil into the ports, the engine will be fine since that extra lube from premixing normally wouldnt be there.
rotarygreg 03-27-2009, 12:45 PM If you are putting Seafoam into your engine THROUGH the side ports, does this remove the lubrication from the apex seals aswell as everywhere else inside your engine?
What you are stating is that the seafoam enters the engine through the side ports and removes all lubrication even off of the apex seals. So, how does it remove the lubrication from the apex seals if it never gets to the apex seals? Your statements contradict one another. If the seafoam can remove lubrication then the oil can provide lubrication to all the same parts.
Well, you make a good point for sure. Im simply voicing my opinion on this and my opinion is that using the OMP after the fact is the best way. I didnt mean to say that no oil at all will get onto the apex seals, however with the OMP way that im refereing to, it is concentrated onto the apex seals which is the reason for adding the oil back in either way.
rx8thunder 03-27-2009, 06:15 PM Greg, what's the cost at the dealership to get this done?
Scott, if we go DIY route, any suggestions on location?
rotarygreg 03-27-2009, 06:23 PM Greg, what's the cost at the dealership to get this done?
Scott, if we go DIY route, any suggestions on location?
hey, i was so busy at work today it completely slipped my mind. I'll see if i can get a price tomorrow.
jmc23200 03-27-2009, 06:30 PM Well, you make a good point for sure. Im simply voicing my opinion on this and my opinion is that using the OMP after the fact is the best way.
Prove it... and supply pics too :)
At this point, based off of research and the trials of many, many DIY'ers, you can safely do this yourself without causing any damage. Although I am sure someone will eventually fuck it up. Just look at all the 100k+ mile members. Most of them have done this. The real questions are do you feel comfortable to do this yourself and/or do you want to pay $80+ for a $5-10 job? Also, when the dealer does this for you, how long does it take? I know you are suppose to let this stuff sit in your engine for a few hours to dissolve all of the carbon buildup. I wonder if they just put it in the engine, wait 10-30 minutes and send you on your way.
If you do endup having a meet for this, anywhere with light and an open lot/field will do. Make sure it is a WIDE OPEN area that has somewhere close by to go to eat or watch a movie or something. The reason it needs to be wide open is because everyones car will smoke like its on fire for a good 5-10 minutes.
Take a peak... look for the house :) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7aAQ8Dbk8VI&feature=related
rx8thunder 03-27-2009, 06:38 PM ^ Wow, that's crazy
wcs, you live in the boonies, right? So maybe your place?
I could check with RPM on this as well...
rotarygreg 03-27-2009, 07:01 PM Prove it... and supply pics too :)
ill assume the smiley implies some sort of sarcasm. Opinion needs no proof.
jmc23200 03-28-2009, 10:11 AM ill assume the smiley implies some sort of sarcasm. Opinion needs no proof.
Yea I was been sarcastic. Opinions are like assholes, everyones got one and everyone thinks everyone else's stinks. Doesn't matter how good or bad someone says something is. When it comes down to it, it is your car and you can do what you want.
I think we can all agree on that.
rotarygreg 03-28-2009, 03:08 PM Yea I was been sarcastic. Opinions are like assholes, everyones got one and everyone thinks everyone else's stinks. Doesn't matter how good or bad someone says something is. When it comes down to it, it is your car and you can do what you want.
I think we can all agree on that.
no no no, i disagree. :)
rx8thunder 03-28-2009, 11:40 PM Well, there isn't enough interest in this to plan an event, so I won't pursue it any further. I will probably just go to my local dealership to get it done.
rotarygreg 03-29-2009, 07:37 AM i tried to get a price on this yestarday at work for you, but the saturday shift doesnt seem to want to do anything. Sorry. I'll try again monday. haha.
^ Wow, that's crazy
wcs, you live in the boonies, right? So maybe your place?
I could check with RPM on this as well...
LOL
Okay I'm north of HWY 7 but I still live in a subdivision.
YOU JERK! :D
However.......... I might be able to find something
|
|