trianglesarebetter2817
11-17-2008, 11:20 PM
Alright guys its time to find out. does octane booster work in any way and what experience have you had with it, and if its has worked what brand works the best.
thanx.
thanx.
|
View Full Version : Octane booster trianglesarebetter2817 11-17-2008, 11:20 PM Alright guys its time to find out. does octane booster work in any way and what experience have you had with it, and if its has worked what brand works the best. thanx. Icemark 11-18-2008, 12:59 AM What are you thinking that it is supposed to do? Raising the octane in gasoline does not effect the BTU (power output) of gasoline. It only lets a motor tuned for the higher octane not blow up. So if you are asking if using any octane boosters give you any more power, then no... it doesn't. It's some dumb tuner old wives tale that people think it makes more power. Now if you advance the ignition timing, or increase compression (to get more power) to the point when the engine has pre-igniting or is detonating, then an octane booster will help you not blow up your motor. Silver06 11-18-2008, 01:01 AM ^what he said. I once made the mistake of having a car that was tuned to need +94 octane gas. Never again for a street car..... nmarz77 11-18-2008, 01:14 AM It's a waste. And a lot of them don't even raise the octane, they just clean the combustion chamber of carbon build-up to bring the compression ratio back to stock. dannobre 11-18-2008, 01:25 AM Octane boosters work well...... At liberating your money from your pocket That's about it.................... toneskii707 11-18-2008, 01:35 AM I wouldn't use it unless your runnin nitrous Silver_Surfer 11-18-2008, 01:38 AM You be better off using lower octane fuel and running your engine right before it pings(MIAC). Say 87 or 89 Flame away!:batman: nmarz77 11-18-2008, 01:38 AM I wouldn't use it unless you're running nitrous and call it naaaaaws! nmarz77 11-18-2008, 01:39 AM You be better off using lower octane fuel and running your engine right before it pings(MIAC). Say 87 or 89 Flame away!:batman: Dis be true. getdamafiaonyou 11-18-2008, 01:42 AM what about if you cant find any premium? cuz i know about a month or two ago i couldnt find it anywhere. and used octane booster for about 3 tanks. nmarz77 11-18-2008, 01:44 AM That's what the knock sensor is there for. Can't find premium? Where do you live??? getdamafiaonyou 11-18-2008, 01:48 AM lol it was awhile ago. when gas got really expensive. i live in chapel hill durham hillsborough area in NC. Icemark 11-18-2008, 01:55 AM lol it was awhile ago. when gas got really expensive. i live in chapel hill durham hillsborough area in NC. They really ran out of premium? Or you didn't want to pay for premium and used octane booster instead? Either way if you use a gasoline that doesn't have enough octane in it, the knock sensor will retard the timing and engine power slightly to compensate. However if you use lower than 86 octane; the PCM with the knock sensor may not be able to retard the timing enough to compensate for that too low of a grade of octane. Charles R. Hill 11-18-2008, 01:57 AM Even with nitrous and F/I fuel higher than 93 octane is unnecessary with the right tuning. getdamafiaonyou 11-18-2008, 02:05 AM no they really didnt have premium. every gas station was out. which pissed me off alot. because i didnt know when i would be able to put it back in. and i dont like putting regular in my tank. StealthTL 11-18-2008, 02:08 AM There's no way it's cheaper to use..... Don't mis-read the labels - they claim a bottle added to ten gallons will raise the rating by two 'octane points' - they don't explain an octane point is POINT ONE of an octane 'rating'! So your 89 octane becomes 89.2! You'd go broke trying to duplicate premium gas. S getdamafiaonyou 11-18-2008, 02:10 AM yeah but i figured it was a quick fix for a little. i mean it's not like i still do it. ever. honestly i felt like i was betraying my car by pouring that shit in there. and then filling her up with regular. i hated it. but i went to about ten gas stations before giving up. SiLVeRE8 11-18-2008, 02:13 AM waste of money... might as well just put higher octane gasoline toneskii707 11-18-2008, 02:17 AM O by the way I'm finishing the naaaws;) this weekend I'm going to use a booster too what is a good one? nmarz77 11-18-2008, 02:20 AM lol....I hope you're joking. Just poor a gallon of ethanol in there. No don't do this...only kidding. krijpipudht 11-18-2008, 02:51 AM Does not work according to this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jbcCr2ll3c According to me, I tried it and felt nothing. dannobre 11-18-2008, 08:15 PM Toluene.............. nycgps 11-18-2008, 09:25 PM to get more power outa the octane booster u need to have lots of nawwwz and electricsupercharger. Highway8 11-18-2008, 09:59 PM I spent a couple of days looking octane boosters up and found several independant test results showing that most dont do what they claim and the ones that do what they claim are still a waste of money. The big problem is that the chemical many use to raise the octane rating is raising it but it causes the combustion to run hotter so you are effectivly doing nothing or in many cases making the situation worse. Also, the knock sensor on the RX8 is basicly worthless, so nobody should be trusting it to save your motor. If you can't find anything but regular unleaded then I you should not run WOT. plus/middle grade usually works fine on our cars as long as you have not tunned it to run leaner (AP or racing beat tune) I hear the RB tune is the most aggressive on the timing, so be very carefull running anything but supreme. Back to the octane boosters, some are effective at raising the octane rating but I would not trust it and its too expensive. nmarz77 11-18-2008, 11:24 PM If you google octane booster you will find tons of threads on how to make it yourself in more potent quantities. But I don't know if I would trust it. Like Highway8 said, it may burn hotter in the combustion chamber which could cause some major issues. Highway8 11-19-2008, 12:05 AM If you google octane booster you will find tons of threads on how to make it yourself in more potent quantities. But I don't know if I would trust it. Like Highway8 said, it may burn hotter in the combustion chamber which could cause some major issues. Wow you agreed with me. I saw you posted after me and I was gettign ready for an argument, JK LOL. Its all good. nmarz77 11-19-2008, 12:06 AM Hey, just because we don't agree on one thing doesn't mean we can't on another. Now, who did you vote for............ Highway8 11-19-2008, 12:32 AM Hey, just because we don't agree on one thing doesn't mean we can't on another. Now, who did you vote for............ HAHA. I never got a chance to vote. My absentee ballet ws thrown away by my wife. As far as the other topic, I earased it because it was pointed out that we both injected some poor and irrelevent information. I had posted a link to a very good artical, not sure if you got to read it or not. http://www.sportcompactcarweb.com/tech/0607_sccp_automotive_aerodynamics_part_1/index.html It covers everything about automotive aerodynamics. I still think it would help but thats my opinion. nmarz77 11-19-2008, 12:36 AM lol....I thought I had a dream about that whole thing. When I came on the next day it had vanished. Ok I will read it after I'm done screwing around on here. One website at a time....I'm an old man. kartweb 11-21-2008, 07:10 PM Toluene.............. Ding, ding, ding...we have a winner. Also try mixing about 20% E85. Some people will shudder but I've been running that for the last 22,000 miles and no problems. That will raise the octane of 87 to 92-94. tsxmidship 11-22-2008, 01:47 AM The premium shortage hes referring to was when Hurricane Ike hit. Most of the metro atlanta(as well as other metro areas in the southeast) was completely out of gas for about a week. When gas started to flow again, it was regular 87 octane for the first week or so, then mid-grade and premium started to flow in slowly afterwards. So it was about 2+ weeks where it was impossible to find premium. chickenwafer 11-24-2008, 12:23 AM That's what the knock sensor is there for. Can't find premium? Where do you live??? You do know the stock knock sensor on the RX-8 does absolutely nothing, right? It's virtually inaudible to knock. Not to mention one or two "major" detonation events and it's all over. I do remember a while back in Import Tuner magazine Power Pages (where they have a scientific way of dyno testing products) they found out some octane boosters DO infact raise the octane of your fuel. The best was actually the NAWWWS brand, I believe. It's better to source some 100 or 110 octane and mix in a gallon with a tank to provide some extra knock resistance, especially if experimenting with a new tune. This is extra true in places like California and Arizona where we only have 91 cat piss. 04RX8man 11-24-2008, 01:40 PM yeah when they say it raises it a point that's not 89 to 90 it's 89 to 89.1 so 5-10 dollars a bottle to raise from 89 or 93 up .2 is not worth it at all might as well just run straight 89 or whatever champi0n 08-17-2009, 04:30 PM Kind of an old thread but i've been researching Toluene for boosting octane. The best I can get here is 91 and I can't get rid of detonation above 5k rpm (during the summer). Winter it's not so bad, and sometimes in the winter I can run 89. (But of course, change in driving habbits during winter as well). And I also can't put aside that carbon buildup could be contributing to increased compression. Now it seems that anything under 40% mixture of Toluene (or probably better put, toluene "properties") should be safe for particular fuel line components, o-rings, lines, etc.. Which I would personally translate down to adding no more then 17-20% toluene per tank to compensate for existing "properties" in the existing fuel and any residual toluene left in the last few liters or last gallon of fuel from the last fill up. So once I find a supplier for pure toluene at a decent price, I will be calculating what octane will work best in my situation to get rid of detonation. I'm thinking of starting around 94 and working my way down (if of course 94 gets rid of the detonation). Typically you can source toluene from paint supply stores but tends to be a little expensive. (Though still substantially less expensive then over the counter octane boosters, and will yield better results). Toluene costs anywhere from $3-$10/gallon (maybe 0.90 - 2.70/L) Mixing 2.5 gallons (about 9.5L) of Toluene with 12.5gallons 91 octane premium should yield 94.5 octane. 2 gallons toluene (7.5L) with 14 gallons of 91 will get you 93.87 1 gallon toluene (3.78L) with 15 gallons of 91will get you 92.44 Potentially costing an extra $6-20 per fillup. (Hopefully more in the $6 range which would be what some people pay for the small bottles of "octane booster" getting only 0.2 - 0.3 boost). And we would be well within the safe limits of the amount of toluene added to the tank. And in addition to the "octane doesn't add more power"... well.. yes and no. It's one of those lost in translation type of sayings. It adds power to engines suffering from detonation (causing timing retard) which is resulting in less power. (so higher octane gives you more power if you're engine doesn't run well on lower octane fuel). Because it's now allowing your engine to run the way it was tuned to. But if your engine is running in tip top condition and fuel is burning properly, then octane isn't going to do anything in terms of power. Octane just makes the fuel more stable, not more explosive. Highway8 08-17-2009, 04:59 PM Kind of an old thread but i've been researching Toluene for boosting octane. The best I can get here is 91 and I can't get rid of detonation above 5k rpm (during the summer). Winter it's not so bad, and sometimes in the winter I can run 89. (But of course, change in driving habbits during winter as well). Are you driving an RX8 with a rotary engine? Because if so and you are in fact getting detonation, then your motor would be toast. Rote8 08-17-2009, 06:58 PM I use the CD2 lead substitute additive for the "lead" premix, my vacuum goes up about 2 inches for several tanks after I run one tank with CD2 through. CD2 lead substitute is marketed as an octane booster. /Catless and supercharged. I go from 24 inches of vacuum when decelerating to 28 inches decelerating when using the CD2 premix, or for a couple of tanks after using the stuff. Rote8 08-17-2009, 07:03 PM You do know the stock knock sensor on the RX-8 does absolutely nothing, right? . Wrong, it cuts the throttle when it senses detonation. /If you say it does nothing, why remove it? Highway8 08-17-2009, 10:46 PM Wrong, it cuts the throttle when it senses detonation. /If you say it does nothing, why remove it? Wrong, it retards the timing, not cuts throttle. Retarding the timing will effect power but not significatly. On a piston engine it detects minor detonation and retards the timing to prevent any major detonation that could cause engine failure. With a rotary any detonation usually means your motor is done. So while it may do something, its too late. Thats why the knock sensor is worthless on our cars. And yes there are many people with the knock sensor disconacted, it sometimes has a false reading, retards timing and reduces the power a few HP. My motor keep going full power detonation and all. Run the octane your car is tunned for and a little buffer to be safe. Any higher and it will cost you power, MPG and money. champi0n 08-18-2009, 12:01 PM Can someone please confirm that detonation is 100% fatal to a rotary engine, because if it was, the rotary would have died off years and years ago, and never been used in production cars. Detonation isn't "good" because the fuel is combusting before the spark plugs were to ignite it, but it's not condition that always leads to engine failure. I would say detonation has more wear and tear in a piston engine because its counteracting forces. (Piston still in it's upward stroke while the combustion is trying to force the downard stroke before TDC). Detonation in a rotary is not optimal, but likely not as counteractive to the rotating inertia. And since my car still runs great in lower air temps, and hasn't "blown up"... pre-detonation in turn is not fatal. Maybe if I were to continue blasting my car at high rpm's for extended periods with detonation you could expect something to eventually give. Huey52 08-18-2009, 12:53 PM May as well add my two cents to this silly thread. Using any higher octane then is needed to prevent pre-ignition (aka pre-detonation, knock, ping, dieseling), in your particular application, is a total waste of money. Period champi0n 08-18-2009, 01:13 PM I will be calculating what octane will work best in my situation to get rid of detonation. I'm thinking of starting around 94 and working my way down. as quoted from above. champi0n 08-18-2009, 01:18 PM With a rotary any detonation usually means your motor is done. My motor keep going full power detonation and all. interesting. Obteene 08-18-2009, 02:17 PM How prone is this engine to detonation? Under what circumstances? and why did Highway8 contraDICK himself? Gr8Bullet 08-18-2009, 02:21 PM this reminds me of the time some guy put noz energy drink in his bike and thought it was octane booster:rofl: Highway8 08-18-2009, 04:44 PM How prone is this engine to detonation? Under what circumstances? and why did Highway8 contraDICK himself? If your tune is bad, it will detonate and blow your motor, but with a proper tune and in NA form, it should not have any detonation. Most tunners will build some cushin into the tune, either a richer AFR or more concervitive timing. How did I controdict myself? I said that the knock sensor does not cut throttle and is worthless. Then I said when my motor blew, it was continued at full power dentonation and all. KNOCK SENSOR DOES NOT HELP WITH A ROTARY IN 99% of circumstances. If you run lean, or have the timing wrong or get low octane fuel, it can have detonation and almost certinly blow the motor, if you are lucky it wil be very minor and the knock sensor will retard the timing and keep it from getting worse and blowing the motor. Again if you are lucky, not likly though. So why is the rotary still being used even with this inherent problem? Because it is tunned in such away to prevent detonation and mazda tells us to use premium fuel, even though if you run 89 or 87 you will get better MPG and more power. Basicly our engine are tunned for 87 octane but we run higher to be safe. PhantomRX-8 08-18-2009, 10:57 PM I use this: http://torcoracefuel.net/pro-accelerator.html Its racing fuel concentrate that actually does add octane to premium fuel. I used it in my Saturn Redline blended to 97 octane and the car loved it. I ran 32* total timing on a supercharged engine with 19lbs of boost. I will be running this in the 8 when I get the car fully running again. Stuff is amazing, highly recommend it. |